Stunning photographs. Obviously they are not keen to encourage tourism.

Those photos are great. Umida deserves state funding, not imprisonment.

Oh dear God. Really obvious propaganda is all the ruling elite wants, of course, it’s a common deficiency among such states.

i am listening to the play now. what an amazing story. i admire your courage.

Believing these photographs are defamatory is insane.

The radio programme is drawing to a close and I have found it enthralling, disturbing and moving. I was just trying to form the next sentence in this comment, when I heard you/David Tennant on the radio say about “..principle not being principle unless you are willing to pay the price..” and it summed up something in which I believe strongly and for which you will now stand as an example.

Thank you for speaking up.

Andrew

have just listened to the play. It was excellent. Your story has inspired me. Keep up the good work. We need many more brave people like you.

Congratulations Craig on being a thorn in thier side. Peace and love to you and yours.

Very brave to show your self up to the world, warts and all. Had to look you up as soon as the play finished to find out more.

Anna

A tremendous play. I shall now read the book and follow your deliberations on your web site. Thank you.

If the story was not so interesting it would have infuriated me.Delighted that even at my age I can still be infuriated by this example of the total abuse of state power.

You’re my sort of person Craig; that disingenuous little sh1t Straw should be in the dock at The Hague along with B.Liar et al.

Terrific play; thank goodness there are people like you around.

Decent honest folk must stand up and be counted.

Incidentally it seems that Obama can quickly opine about Tiger Woods’s apology but can’t find the time to come out and say that Nazirael is doing very cruel and unpleasant things in the illegally occupied Palestinian Territories, amongst so many other sinful things that the US of A(read CIA) do all over the World.

I have just finished listening to todays play on radio four. I started to listen out of curiosity to hear David Tennant in a different role, but within a short period I had forgotten I was listening to David Tennant and instead became enthralled in the content of the play. Thank you for allowing such an honest and open account of your time as ambassador to be published and broadcast. Whilst there are things in the play it might have been tempting to hide, the fact you are able to show yourself in such an unedited manner gives me greater confidence in what you say.

It is a shameful story, and gives the lie to our government’s claim to represent any values other than those of narrow self interest and self survival. In supporting the United States in its war on terror we were like the weak boy in the school playground chosing to stand by the school bully in the hope it would give us security. Instead it has reduced our standing in the world.

We have a history in the West of supporting regimes as long as they are useful to us and of then suddenly realising what a brutal dictatorship they are when we no longer need them. The shah of Iran was our man, to be looked after and protected, but once deposed we would not even consider letting him live in Britain as the foreign office had an eye on selling arms to the new regime. Apparently before becoming Prime minister Margret Thatcher had assured him that she would be ashamed not to offer him residence. Shortly after becoming Prime minister and being briefed by the foreign office her view changed. How sad that there seem to be so few men and women of principle in high office and how refreshing to here a man of spirit and honour speak out.

Thank you. I wish you well and hope that you are able to shine a light on the corruption and deceit that our leaders would rather have hidden in the darkness arrising from fear and self serving that must keep many people in your situation silent.

It was great, Craig. I swallowed a big lump in my throat at one stage. I thought you were blessed to have David Tennant. I do hope you were pleased with it yourself. I’ve read Murder in Samarkand, and I felt it was very close. Congrats.

I really enjoyed the play, just brilliant to have something so though provoking on radio these days. The whole Bush / Blair chapter was always murky. I marched against war in Iraq knowing it to be ‘unjust’ because nothing said then or now was convincing. But, were do we go now?

Just excellent.

This got posted to your Jan 29 blog by mistake:

A very thought provoking and questioning play, thank you. Our politicians have much to answer for, condoning torture and murder throughout these countries to gain information under the guise of solid information. I greatly admire what you tried to do and thank the producers of the play for reminding me of your own personal ordeal. I wish you well and your future work.

It was better than I feared, and the BBC did a very respectable job publicising it beforehand .

Goood luck ,frogdave

Thank you for letting us know what went on. I admire your stand against hypocracy and deceit. Iam currently reading ‘Listening to Grasshoppers’ by Arundhati Roy which speaks of state abuses in India. Many people still believe the British Government to have ‘clean hands’ when it comes to torture and human rights. It is so important that their behaviour and attitudes are exposed. How else can it be stopped? Once again thank you.

I haven’t read your book. I was driving, had the Radio on 4, came in half way through the play, parked up and listened to most of it. Very interesting how the FO “stitched” you up…

However, another area that did sadden me was your treatment of your wife, the affairs through your marriage etc., and putting her in a very difficult position of supporting your efforts to clear your name and return to

Uzbekistan, whilst knowing you were having an affair. Yes, I know it was her choice, but one which any woman would find extremely difficult.

I would disagree with poster pete that womanising and human rights is a being grounded in an embodied humanity…and I won’t state the obvious either!

Good luck to you Craig and hopefully you’ll continue with your activism towards an outrageous violation of human rights in Uzbekistan.

congratulations and well done to david hare and BBC radio 4 for being so brave. i read your book a couple of years ago craig, but couldn’t finish it – too upsetting. i am involved in a campaign myself; to stop incommunicado detention and torture in spain. amnesty international is closely involved. go to http://www.youtube.com and put mohammed fahsi in search.

Amazing play by David Hare. I admire your courage in standing up for human rights, and was sorry for the way the FCO acted.

Good luck to you in continuing to highlight human rights abuses.

The use of torture goes on, it seems, and the way it affects the war on terror was well brought out.

It made me mad – hence the poem on my blog.

the site didn’t pick up the blog link – it’s here:

http://lmcollis.blogspot.com/2010/02/murder-in-samarkand.html

Heard the play on radio 4, if even half of that really happened, and I’m sure most of it did, you’ve had an interesting time of it.

Well done!

M

Thank you so much…i have been informing people on my social network in Pune India(Pune Bomb Blast re -German Bakery four days ago) about the connection between jihadism and Uzbek energy reserves/multinational investment and regional / Afghan wars.

We must engage at every level as ex President Havel inspiringly wrote from his prison cell.Every day.Power is relational and Akhmedova adds to the end result. Be inspired by her and let her jailing be a strength and voice for all like her.Love.

Those are excellent pictures, thanks for the link.

Terrible, terrible news that she has been imprisoned, a backward step.

Hope you’re very pleased with the play. It was brilliant. And thanks for Umida Akhmedova’s unforgettable photos. I wish she could know how many people are thinking about her.

First class! And no wonder it went out on Saterday afternoon on Radio 4…

The politburo would never have tolerated it any other time…and where are you standing this time round?

This is off-topic (maybe) and I’m flinging it in, just in case Mark is reading.

tinyurl.com/ivinscaseclosed

tinyurl.com/ivinsdidit

I didn’t think they could close this down, but they have. Have they?

I’ve just listened to the play and it reminded me to thank you for giving me faith that there are (were?)still a few people in ruling positions who put human rights above politics. After reading your story at the time I’d wanted to do this and now I can.

The play asks what you did that was brave. I think the answer is that you stood by your belief in what was right while knowing it would destroy your career. It’s a sad world where career is more important than telling the truth about appalling things that any country claiming to be civilised should be doing everything to prevent.

Freedom of speech is a fundamental human right for which no one should be imprisoned.

I heard the play today as I luckily had a cold so stayed in bed with the radio on .. I feel very moved by your story. Looking down your blog I see somewhere you say something about doing something about the current corrupt and dishonest regime in the UK. The genuine question I have is ‘What exactly?’ I don’t want to be too doom and gloom and in a way I am asking someone to convince me I am wrong, but is is not the case that the world is completely in the grip of people who lie somewhere in the range between amoral and greedy lying psychopath? I really don’t think that a change of government will make much difference. Is there any evidence to believe that it would?

Caroline… u need to be compelled by a result without wasting yourself or is justice compelling enough? Somethings you do without knowing whsat the effects might be and you do them because as Vaclav Havel says you choose to live in the truth. Its the part that never dies.Get creative, I have.You are free , use it.

Craig, this entry’s picture is too big for your blog, to save your time I made a smaller 640×424 version you can replace it with if you like:

http://homepage.ntlworld.com/fourwinds/akhmedova_s.jpg

( its best to download it and then re-upload it as it will slow the blog if you hotlink )

.

I don’t know what to say about Akhmedova’s punishment for taking her fine pictures, and yet she is one of thousands taken. It’s too wrong. Sorry.

Latest developments in “discovering” al Qaeda in Uzbekistan:

http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20100220/wl_nm/us_usa_centralasia

Just finished listening on Listen Again. Makes a mockery of democracy to think we are “represented” by these faceless, gutless bastards. Sad thing is we’re teaching the rest of the World to play this terrible game of “fool the people”. Make no mistake, the Americans won’t rest until they’ve done to the World what they did to the Native Americans, and all in the name of God.

Thanks for publicizing the case of Umida Akhmedova, Craig. Your headline, however, is slightly misleading. As far as I know, Akhmedova was not jailed prior to her trial; she was “only” barred from leaving the country.

Unfortunately, at the trial itself (on February 10), she was convicted as charged. The judge, however, immediately pardoned her – allegedly, in connection with some kind of general amnesty in honor of the eighteenth anniversary of Uzbekistan’s independence.

http://www.amnesty.org.uk/news_details.asp?NewsID=18622

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Umida_Akhmedova

http://www.guardian.co.uk/film/2010/feb/11/uzbekistan-umida-akhmedova-slander

I can’t help but thinking that this strange outcome had less to do with Uzbek independence and more to do with the incredible international solidarity campaign on Umida’s behalf.

Which is exactly the point that David Tenant-as-you makes in what for me was the most moving part of the BBC play (your/his speech to the Uzbek villagers): that all we have is solidarity.

Craig

The width of the photo above is driving your print off the right of the screen both here and in your main blog.

Makes it very difficult to read.

You might try reducing the size of the photo.