Site icon Craig Murray

With Ray McGovern in Dublin

This week I was in Dublin for the award of University College’s James Joyce Medal to my friend Ray McGovern. As part of our programme we gave a talk together at the Whistleblower Cafe.

The video of the event, which shows what a remarkable man Ray is, you can find below, provided by Consortium News.

I was particularly pleased with my own speech, which I think summed up a lot of what I am thinking at present about the state of the world. You can watch it in the video, or the transcript follows. As you will see from that, a lot of my speech depends on tone and inflexion and perhaps does not read perfectly. One downside of the fact I never speak from a written text.

Ireland is undergoing an existential conflict. The heart of this is the government’s drive to abandon its neutrality and join in the big EU and NATO push for war with Russia. One interesting facet of this has been very noticeable to me on Twitter this last week – there is a massive concentration of troll and bot activity around Russia/Ukraine and Ireland. More active than I have ever seen, even on Israel.

The EU’s sanctions against Chay Bowes and his family are appalling. Just as with the cases of Jacques Baud and Huseyin Dogru, Chay has had his money confiscated, his accounts frozen, he cannot travel and it is illegal to provide him with food or accommodation or to rent him a home, or indeed to interact economically with him in any way at all.

The day after the sanctions were announced, I had dinner with Chay and he was fairly sanguine. Ireland, he said, would never allow an Irishman and his wife and four children, to whom he returned after dinner, to starve. The Irish government was appeasing the EU; they would pretend to apply the sanctions but would not really enforce them.

I am afraid he has been disabused. The next day he found that the Irish government had frozen not only his accounts, but had frozen his wife’s accounts and taken all her money as well. He has been informed that he can apply to the Central Bank of Ireland repeatedly for permission for his bank to release funds in small amounts to feed his children.

It is dubious that his bank will want to do this and as he is not permitted to be employed or given money, it won’t last long anyway. All of this is done to him with no charges, no trial and no defence. He can theoretically appeal but as he cannot pay lawyers that is dubious. In any even the appeal process takes two years and ends at the EU’s European Court of Justice (not the European Court of Human Rights). The ECJ will only rule on whether the EU followed its own sanctions regulations, and not on human rights or natural justice.

What I find truly chilling is the reaction of EU supporters who genuinely believe that people ought not to be permitted to exist in society who hold a different view than them of the conflict in Ukraine.

That is one very important straw in the wind on the way Ireland is changing. Here is another. I was in Madrid ten days ago for Fergie Chambers’ extradition hearing. Thankfully he has been released on bail: the United States Justice Department finally admitted the translation errors on which I reported and which in the Spanish version much exaggerated the “crimes”. This belated US admission has caused the Spanish court to rethink.

An interesting observation on the subservience of Spain to the United States is that the Spanish court had refused to accept that there were translation errors – even though they were completely blatant – until the USA Justice Department itself admitted them.

But on the subservience to the US – and Israel – of this changing Ireland, it is worth noting that while I was there, Fergie Chambers’ Dublin home was raided by the Gardai on behalf of the FBI, in a desperate fishing expedition to find something – anything – to bolster their collapsing case in Spain. The Irish government permitted this even though Chambers is accused of no crime in Ireland and there are no actual charges against him in the United States.

Quite a few Palestine activists have taken up residence in Ireland believing it is one of the few safe places remaining in the western world for free speech on Palestine. But as I say, Ireland is changing – or rather being forcibly changed.

Here is the transcript of my talk:

Some time ago I was giving a talk in Brussels. A lady came up to me and said, are you Craig Murray? And I said, yes, and she said, “Oh, I thought you were only online”. LAUGHTER It was quite extraordinary. It took me some time after that to convince myself I am real.

If you go online, you can see a talk I gave last year to Pensioners for Independence in Glasgow. And that was a talk I went on for, I think, an hour and ten minutes before they told me to shut up. And during that hour and ten minutes, you can actually see on the video, I drink six pints of Guinness without even noticing I was doing so. LAUGHTER

Quite impressive. I’ve only going to speak for 15 minutes here and I have no Guinness. But I will… I will nonetheless see what I can do… I’m still running well from last night. Because last night… LAUGHTER Last night, Ray was awarded at the university with the James Joyce Award, which I think does as much honour to the James Joyce Award as it does to Ray. APPLAUSE

And afterwards, we went for dinner. And after dinner, we went to the bar. Then that bar closed and then we went to another bar. And Joe Lauria here from Consortium News forced me to keep going around Dublin looking for more bars. And after about… I don’t know, nine or ten pints together… It seemed normal somehow but in fact, when I think back about it, in some of those bars, young people seem to come out without putting all their clothes on.

It was very strange. And we ended up… And I got home, it was daylight. And I haven’t been to bed since. And so… So if I’m not as coherent as I normally am , I do hope that you will forgive me. Oh, right. Thank you. That’s very kind… Ray is going to forgive me. We’ll see whether the rest of you can forgive me by the time I’ve finished.

We live in extraordinary times. I had dinner with Chay Bowes two nights ago, where I bought him dinner – which is against the law. It is against the law to “provide him with the means of sustenance”. And we took a photo… We took a photo of ourselves and sent it to Kaja Kallas, saying “I bought him dinner, come and arrest me”. LAUGHTER

It’s a funny thing, but I sent the photo to a friend who said, “Craig, I didn’t know you were getting so old, you’re shrinking.” I said, “I’m not shrinking. The man’s a bloody giant, have you met him? Chay Bowes is enormous”.

Looking through what’s happening in the Western world today, it’s very, very difficult. We’re living in authoritarian times. I and my family have had to discuss whether it’s safe for us to continue living in Edinburgh. I’ve never hurt anybody in my life. All I’ve done is say things.

I was in Russia about three weeks ago, four weeks ago. Do you know, in the UK last year, in the last 12 months, 21,000 people have been arrested for speech offences. 21,000 people. That includes the 4,000 people who’ve been arrested for supporting Palestine Action.

Amongst those 21,000 people, there is a section who I think should be arrested: people who send threatening messages to their spouse, for example. That’s a tiny subset of that number. The vast majority of people have just been arrested for saying hurty things online, saying things that the state doesn’t like.

When I was in Russia, I decided to do some research, not just through official Russian government sources, I spoke to Memorial and others. The equivalent figure in Russia for people who were arrested for any form of speech crime is about 2,000 – not 21,000. Of those about 1,800 people were arrested for speaking against the war in Ukraine.

Personally, I’m very sorry, but 1,800 people in Russia have been arrested for speaking against the war. I don’t think anybody should be arrested for that. That’s bad. The vast majority of those resulted in fine rather than imprisonment, but even so, I still don’t think they should have been arrested.

The situation on free speech is much worse in the UK than it was in Russia. Twice as many people – more than twice as many people – are arrested in the UK for supporting Palestine Action alone as have been arrested in Russia for speaking and posting against the war.

Let’s just look at Ukraine. In Ukraine, 11 political parties are banned. 11 political parties which have had MPs in the last decade, not 11 non-existent or paper political parties. The parties that are banned include the Socialist Party, the Left Party and the Communist Party. They are all banned and illegal in Ukraine.

Because here we are, being urged to accept conscription, being urged to accept a welfare state being slashed, public spending being slashed, real wages falling, standards of living falling, in order to justify far greater spending on arms and weapons, because apparently we’re in a fight for democracy. Against Russia.

It’s a problem, isn’t it? It’s actually just a completely false narrative, but it’s a narrative with which we are imbued day by day by day by constant propaganda. And think of this: in Russia, the BBC have Steve Rosenberg, BBC Moscow correspondent, who every day is able to go around Russia producing anti-Russian pieces, is able to interview Putin and put out stuff, some of which is true, some of which is untrue.

But why shouldn’t he? That is freedom of expression. And the Russians permit it.

And here in Ireland, you have an Irishman, Chay Bowes, whose life is being destroyed. He’s got four young kids here in Dublin, whose family are being completely messed about, because he says nice things about Russia, because he says disobliging things about Ukraine. The notion that we live in a free-speech democracy, and that we live in the world of camps of good against evil, and we are the goodies, is nonsense.

Defying EU Sanctions against Chay Bowes. With Patrick Henningsen.

I actually don’t think that there are any goodies.

I’ve always felt that you would find that almost anybody who gets to the summit of political power in almost any country – there’s the odd exception – but 90% of the time they got to the summit of political power because they’re an evil bastard. Because that’s how you get to the summit of political power.

And that applies throughout the world. The notion that the world of Donald Trump, the world of Andy Burnham, these are the good guys; we have been sold this monstrous lie.

Thomas Piketty published some statistics the other day – the French economist. And he said, at the time of the large demonstrations in France, he said that in France in 1970 public debt – the national debt – was 20% of GDP. It is now 120% of GDP. Almost exactly the same thing is true in the UK. It was a bit higher in the UK in 1970 because of continuing World War II debt.

But the same rough thing has happened over most of Europe. Many of us remember when you had to have public debt, you had to have national debt at below 40% of GDP in order to join the European Union or join the Euro, which neither Germany nor France would be able to do on today’s figures.

Piketty said that since 1970, national debt has risen in France from 20% to 120%. But if you look at wealth, the accumulation of wealth owned in France, between 1970 and now, that has risen from 300% of GDP to 600% of GDP. There’s actually a far greater gap… there’s far more wealth compared to debt than there was.

And for reasons he explained – and I’m not an economist – it’s subtraction rather than division which is the relevant measure.

There’s far more wealth compared to debt, than there was, than there ever has been. France is now wealthier than it has ever been. But the problem is that all the debt is in the public sector, and all the wealth is in the private sector. And that wealth is incredibly concentrated.

If you look at Oxfam’s figures on the UK, you see the 50 richest families in the UK – the 50 richest families in the UK – own as much wealth as the 36 million poorest people in the UK. It’s the same in France. It’s almost certainly the same in Ireland. It’s the same all over the world.

And we have this situation where debt is nationalized and wealth is not only private, wealth is in the hands of a tiny, tiny sector of the population.

And it’s led to all kinds of economic distortions. It doesn’t happen naturally. This is not the natural order of things. This is due to a bunch of specific institutions, specific laws, governmental institutions and private institutions, all of which are aimed at and projected towards the concentration – the extreme concentration – of wealth.

The situation in which you and I work our butts off our entire lives and never have much to spare, and other people have billions and billions and billions: that’s not a natural phenomenon. They try to make you believe that is the natural order of things. It is not in any sense the natural order of things. It is a deliberate and careful state construct.

So we live in this strange society where that wealth gap is growing and growing. And if you look at the terrible things that happen in society – if you look at the war in Ukraine, if you look at the genocide in Gaza, and the way that’s being sustained by the weapons industry – the amount of money, it’s extraordinary.

We’ve all cried real tears, I think, when we’ve seen some of the images from Gaza over the last three years. I think all of us have. There’s probably nobody here who hasn’t at some stage cried. There are people who have made billions out of that. There are people involved in weapons manufacturing, supplies and security, who have made billions out of the genocide in Gaza.

These things don’t happen purely for reasons of atavistic hate or racism, though those of course are factors. They happen because of the economics of settler colonialism, the economics of war, the economics that want all of us to spend more of our money on things that kill people, rather than things that create or enhance life or make the world a better place.

That is where we are today. And it’s a world which is becoming increasingly dangerous for those of us who oppose it. But I want to put to you this: I see there’s hope. I think that the reason for this ever-increasing authoritarianism, particularly in Western states, is that they are scared of us.

I think once you reach a certain stage of wealth inequality, a certain stage where people realize that there is no hope their lives are going to get better, nobody has any serious hope that their children are going to have better lives than they did, or own more than they did, or progress more than they did, social mobility has died in the Western world: Once you take away hope from people, once people merely become helots, then the revolutionary sentiment starts to bubble up.

I was in Madrid last week and there was a huge demonstration of about half a million people walking through the streets because of the incredible cost of housing, which is part of this entire construct.

There are signs of popular resistance growing up all over Europe. And the fact that thousands of people are willing to be arrested because of their support for Palestine Action is another sign of that popular resistance. And when popular resistance grows, then authoritarianism has to react by becoming more and more and more authoritarian.

But eventually it will break. There is a better world that is possible, and it all depends on our own courage, own individual good acts, to keep fighting it. Thank you very much indeed.

—————————————–

Anybody is welcome to republish and reuse my work, including in translation.

My work has no funding at all except for your subscriptions. If you already subscribe, I would be grateful if you could check if your subscription is still active. Over 80% of my subscriptions lapse when debit or credit cards expire: the systems do not warn you.

Because some people wish an alternative to PayPal, I have set up additional new methods of subscription payment including Patreon account and a Substack account, if you wish to subscribe that way. The content will be the same as you get on this blog. Substack has the advantage of overcoming social media suppression by emailing you direct every time I post. You can, if you wish, subscribe free to Substack and use the email notifications as a trigger to come to this blog and read the articles for free.

I am determined to maintain free access for those who cannot afford a subscription.

Choose subscription amount from dropdown box:

Recurring Donations



PayPal address for one-off donations: craigmurray1710@btinternet.com

Alternatively by bank transfer or standing order:

Account name
MURRAY CJ
Account number 3 2 1 5 0 9 6 2
Sort code 6 0 – 4 0 – 0 5
IBAN GB98NWBK60400532150962
BIC NWBKGB2L
Bank address NatWest, PO Box 414, 38 Strand, London, WC2H 5JB

Bitcoin: bc1q3sdm60rshynxtvfnkhhqjn83vk3e3nyw78cjx9
Ethereum/ERC-20: 0x764a6054783e86C321Cb8208442477d24834861a

Exit mobile version