« Early draft of Iraq Dossier to be made public | Main | Peter Hain »
January 24, 2008
Imprisonment
Occasionally there is a moment of revelation, when an image makes plain an underlying truth. I think the Palestinian breakout through the Wall from Gaza into Egypt is such a moment. The joy of the ordinary Palestinians as they poured through the gap to do simple things like stretch their legs and shop, brought home graphically a truth which the Western media has been hiding for years: that an entire population is imprisoned in Gaza.
The images were so obviously reminiscent of the joy at the fall of the Berlin Wall, that it is going to be difficult to convince public opinion in most of the world that it is a good idea to wall the Palestinians up again. Only the most purblind can fail to realise that this terrible imprisonment and degradation is a major cause of Islamic radicalism, not only in the rise of Hamas but worldwide. It is essential that Egypt now resist pressure from the US and Israel to intern the Palestinians again.
Where is Tony Blair, the Middle East "Peace Envoy"? Not speaking out for the Palestinians right to freedom, certainly.
No doubt Aaronovitch and the Times will now call me anti-Semitic again.
Meantime back at home the government blindly pushes ahead with increasing Muslim grievance with yet another "Anti-terror" bill designed to curb our civil liberties still further. There is no possible justification for the desire to introduce internment at home. This will merely stoke still further the sense of grievance and alienation that can lead a tiny minority into violent reaction.
Posted by craig on January 24, 2008 12:37 PM in the category UK Policy
Comments
Well, anyone who thinks Craig is rude about Israeli politics should read what some Israelis write.
The veteran journalist Uri Avnery (veteran as in old enough to have been a refugee in 1933) wrote a typically perceptive article a few weeks ago about a little-noticed aspect of this whole saga: the ambivalent position of the Egyptians.
http://zope.gush-shalom.org/home/en/channels/avnery/1199602046
On the one hand, Egyptians presumably are horrified by what they see happening in Gaza. On the other hand, they are under tremendous pressure to keep the border sealed, and anyway Egypt is poor and cannot contemplate the prospect of 1.5 million refugees. Though an exodus into Egypt could be exactly what the Israeli right wants.
Posted by: Cide Hamete Benengeli
at January 24, 2008 9:46 PM
The news heavy-weight Sky is more concerned about an Australian“s, who died in the USA, funeral arrangements.
First for breaking news!
Posted by: daveo
at January 25, 2008 11:07 AM
The economic/political/military elite that rules/owns Eygypt doesn't give a damn about the Palestinians in Gaza or anywhere else. They have abandoned and betrayed them. In contrast, the overwhelming majority of ordinary Eygyptians, like most people in the Middle East, feel an extraordinary level of solidarity with the plight of the Palestinians. It's this growing conflict between the attitudes of the pro-Western elite, who've surrendered to the Israelis, and the rest of the population, that is a potentially volatile and explosive mix.
Craig's second point about the slide towards authoritarianism is also valid. I believe the so-called 'terrorist threat' is lie designed to convince us that our cherished civil liberties are 'expendible' in the 'war on terror'. What's striking is how few of us are killed by terrorists compared to how many we slaughter in Iraq, Afghanistan, Somalia... Of course any unecessary deaths are tragic, but we need to reflect and get a sense of proportion, and look at the 'terrorist threat' rationally and soberly. Something the government and most of the mass media don't want us to do. They is way too much power and money to be made by blowing the terrorist threat out of all proportion.
Compare the numbers killed and severely injured on the roads all over Europe, year after year. The figure is around 100,000, a massive figure, yet no one talks about this a threat to our way of life and our values. The 'war on terror' is such con, with huge benefits for the State, the security services and the growing security industry, that one almost begins to think that our government must be behind the terror threat themselves!
Gordon Browne's resent remarks about the need to reform the UN and other leading international organizations are also interesting. What he seems to want is to weaken the security councils ability to delay or hinder or vote against pre-emptive war against rogue states and at the same time make it easier for the 'colonial' occupation to succeed when the wars are over.
Posted by: writeon
at January 25, 2008 4:27 PM
Do you have a contact e-address
Posted by: Neil
at March 22, 2008 11:54 AM

