Palestine Action Supreme Court Hearing Day 2 252


I woke up at 5am, and rather than dashing back to court, I made good progress on writing up the first day. The surprising lack of demand for the public gallery was probably due to the fact that you were not actually allowed in the courtroom, but only in an overflow court. So I arrived about 9am, confident that I would get in with no problems. There were fewer protestors around, but a great many more policemen.

There were four separate teams of policemen photographing demonstrators. Each was a two-man team, and two of these teams functioned with a camera operator plus a man with a hefty backpack, which was presumably uploading for facial recognition in real time.

Due to the lack of demonstrators, the police camera teams were forced to queue up to photograph individuals. I felt perhaps the police would feel left out of the game if nobody photographed them, so I took this nice picture of one of the teams, who were playing hide and seek behind a wall. I have since uploaded the photo to our own website facial recognition technology, which tells me that the policeman on the left is named Jimmy Palantir, and the policeman on the right is Xavier Wellington Felixstowe-Gillespie, a distant cousin of the Marchioness of Accrington.

Once in court, Sir James Eadie KC was continuing the case for the government. It is very, very important to understand that Eadie is representing the government view. He is not outlining some neutral analysis of the law. It would be entirely fair to replace his name with Shabana Mahmood, Ed Miliband or Andy Burnham, because that is on whose behalf he is talking.

I make this point because of the appalling hypocrisy of the Burnham government (proprietors: Labour Friends of Israel). Ed Miliband directly lied when he said that nobody wanted to criminalise grannies. Compare that with the account below of what Eadie actually argued on his government’s behalf in court.

Sir James Eadie KC opened by saying for the Burnham government that Palestine Action meets the statutory definition of terrorism. No permission had been given to appeal that decision and it was not a matter that could be disputed before this court.

The threshold test is set by parliament. The Joint Terrorism Assessment Centre had identified three incidents which met the threshold of terrorism.

Lord Briggs interrupted that this was before the Brize Norton attack.

Sir James agreed that at the time of the JTAC assessment, the Brize Norton incident had not yet happened. The lower courts had assessed that the three terrorist incidents were in fact not outliers as to scale and intent.

The Court of Appeal had said Palestine Action’s activities were the antithesis of a democratic society, said Sir James. Palestine Action in fact lauds those actions described as terrorist, including Filton.

Eadie’s second point for the Burnham government was that Palestine Action had a wide range of targets, not just Elbit, but also any other company in the UK considered by Palestine Action to enable Israel. The Secretary of State (Yvette Cooper) had told parliament that Palestine Action claimed responsibility for attacking Jewish businesses in North London, including smashing windows.

The JTAC assessment was that Palestine Action’s activities included incidents being investigated by the Metropolitan Police as hate crimes against the Jewish community. There were recent incidents but these were in closed material.

[In addition to the public hearing, the government can introduce “closed” secret evidence from the security services. Huda Ammori and her legal team are never shown this, are given no idea of what it alleges, and no opportunity to answer it.]

James Eadie said thirdly for the Burnham government that it was not sustainable to call Palestine Action a non-violent organisation. The lower courts had rejected the claim that Palestine Action were engaged in civil disobedience. The attempt to place it in this tradition was disproved by the lower courts’ findings of fact.

The Underground Manual encourages the use of an “efficient sledgehammer”. Activists had carried sledgehammers and crowbars as weapons. JTAC’s assessment of the Filton incident was that Palestine Action entered the factory with weapons including sledgehammers intending to attack. Subsequently security guards and a policewoman were injured.

[Eadie was not ever interrupted by the judges except for a very few occasions when they intervened to agree with him. If the judges had been testing Eadie’s argument in the same way they had constantly attacked Raza Husain KC when he spoke for Ammori, they might have pointed out that this JTAC assessment had been completely rejected by successive juries. The defendants had been found not guilty of all charges of carrying weapons. Only one person had been convicted of a violent offence, and that specifically without intent.

The judges had this information in front of them from Henry Blaxland KC. But the judges allowed Eadie, who was speaking for the Burnham government, to continue his factually untrue allegations with no intervention.]

Eadie continued on behalf of the Burnham government that the Underground Manual instructs activists in how to conceal their actions. It calls on people to “dream up crazy actions”. It tells them to “damage, disrupt and destroy” and to “think big”.

A major part of Palestine Action’s funding went into these destructive actions.

The Margaret Jones case makes clear that there are proper bounds to the scope of civil disobedience. Damage to property can be violence. The attempt by Raza Husain KC to draw a distinction between violence to the person and violence to property had no substance whatever. You end up making a virtue of not advocating serious harm to persons.

This was shown by the JTAC assessment of Filton. Also at Thales, pyrotechnics were thrown into an area where people were gathering. This could hardly be termed non-violent.

Mr Blaxland’s characterisation was entirely untenable. There was no intention to accept arrest. The Underground Manual taught encryption, use of burner phones, etc., to avoid detection.

At Filton, the sledgehammer attack upon Sergeant Evans was of particular concern. Judge Johnson had found a terrorist connection. He analyses serious damage to property, but that pales into insignificance compared to the assaults.

This level of criminal damage and use of reckless force with no restraint did not amount to civil disobedience.

Lord Briggs asked what sentences had been imposed, and was told six to eight years.

Lord Sales asked whether the sentencing remarks could be taken into account in the proportionality exercise, as they were post-proscription, then he convinced himself that they could.

James Eadie on behalf of the government said, yes, it was agreed they could be included. The remarks about the sledgehammer attack were particularly important.

[Again the judges tested Eadie with no contrary questions. They could have pointed out that those sentences were given without proscription, with which they had no connection – as it happened after the Filton incident. So they might be viewed as showing that proscription was not necessary. But of course, they said nothing against the government case. The contrast between how they treated Eadie and how they had treated Husain and Blaxland was stark indeed.]

For the Burnham government, James Eadie continued that Brize Norton was dealt with in the second statement of Mr Sinclair of the Home Office. Palestine Action had sprayed paint from repurposed fire extinguishers directly into the turbines of planes and had done damage with a crowbar. This plainly falls within the definition of terrorism as serious damage to property.

The Secretary of State had been entitled to take it into account as part of the proportionality exercise.

Lord Briggs said that the only question was, was the damage serious? Eadie replied that paint into turbines is undoubtedly serious. These planes were used for humanitarian relief missions. What if one had been needed the next day?

Speaking for the Burnham government, James Eadie now made his fourth point. Palestine Action’s membership and structure were obscure. It operated in secret cells. Huda Ammori had been found to lack candour about this.

Eadie’s fifth point for the Burnham government was that the advice received by the Secretary of State was that Palestine Action’s activities showed an escalating pattern of violence. This escalation had begun with the 7 October Hamas attack on Israel. JTAC stated that Palestine Action members intended to further escalate their activities.

Palestine Action had a footprint within all 45 policing jurisdictions in the UK and had pledged escalation. Any suggestion it was moderating after Filton was disproved by Brize Norton.

Lord Lloyd Jones asked if there had been any indication from Huda Ammori that she was planning to escalate. Eadie replied no, but there were judgements on the facts from two lower courts that violence was escalating. The Filton sentencing remarks showed this. Palestine Action was not engaged in any kind of domestic campaigning.

For the last ten minutes Eadie had been repeating the same few points. He asked for a recess to confer with his team, which was granted.

On behalf of the Burnham government, James Eadie KC then said he would now address the decision-making process.

The Secretary of State (Yvette Cooper) had been advised throughout by experienced and competent people on the security side on the benefits of proscription. The Proscription Review Group were themselves advised by JTAC and by Counter Terrorism Police (CTP).

CTP had produced a lengthy report weighing up the pros and cons of proscription.

Lord Stephens said the Secretary of State had presumably also received legal advice. Eadie confirmed that she had.

JTAC had justified proscription in terms of the statutory tests. Counter Terrorism Police had listed the benefits of proscribing Palestine Action. They had weighed the benefits of proscribing against use of the criminal law in terms of operational impact. They identified the need for a holistic approach to go after the organisation’s activities.

This included the point made by Lord Briggs, that the existing law had not prevented the attacks, including the violent one at Filton.

[If the judges were scrutinising Eadie in the same way they did Husain, they would logically have asked him at this stage how this had worked out. Had the attacks stopped? Of course, they did no such thing but continued to show Eadie great deference as the government’s representative.]

On behalf of the government, James Eadie stated that the proportionality exercise had to be about the legislative context and about margin.

[The margin of appreciation is a legal term roughly corresponding to benefit of the doubt. The doctrine is that a large amount of discretion or deference should be shown to the executive in matters of national security].

Eadie said on behalf of the Burnham government that the 2002 Terrorism Act makes the provision for the Secretary of State to proscribe against set criteria. The law confers both the power and the responsibility on the Secretary of State. There is an affirmative vote procedure in parliament for democratic accountability.

On behalf of the Burnham government, James Eadie set out multiple judgements by the Supreme Court under Lord Reed, the current President, which had argued a wide margin for the Secretary of State. In weighing proportionality, the court must give a wide margin for constitutional reasons relating to the separation of powers. It was for the executive, not the court, to safeguard national security. National security decisions must have the widest margin.

James Eadie argued on behalf of the Burnham government that it was the government, not the court, which had the expertise and competence to judge questions of national security. It was the government which had the democratic mandate and responsibility. Eadie quoted a judgement in another case, on which he said four of the five members of the current court sat, which said precisely that.

There was, he said, a long line of top court authority which gave the Secretary of State the widest margin in cases of national security.

On behalf of the Burnham government, Sir James Eadie said that a wide margin is to be given to the government’s discretion in the area of national security, even when applying criminal prohibitions on freedom of speech.

This margin applies at all points of the proportionality analysis, including in assessing the impact on freedom of speech.

On behalf of the Burnham government, James Eadie KC stated, “Amnesty and Liberty are wrong about this.”

Lord Briggs said that the Appeal Court had suggested in some decisions that less margin should be given to the Secretary of State in terms of the effect upon individuals. Lord Lloyd Jones said that seemed to be the same point being made by UN Special Rapporteurs in this case.

Sir James Eadie said, yes, it was, but that argument had been rejected by the Court of Appeal. There are limits to proportionality.

On behalf of the Burnham government, Eadie said that the aim of proscription is to protect the lives and liberties of ordinary citizens from Palestine Action. Proscription is not the objective; degrading the capabilities of Palestine Action is the objective.

The government was entitled to take into account the escalating patterns of violence as shown in the very serious attacks at Bristol and Brize Norton.

The second point on proportionality, said Sir James Eadie on behalf of the Burnham government, was that proscription operated at a national and international level. It would enable authorities to degrade and disrupt Palestine Action as a network.

On behalf of the Burnham government, Sir James Eadie said that the third point was that less intensive measures were not available which would be equally effective, and they would compromise the achievement of the objective. This, he said, had been set out in another earlier Lord Reed judgement (they gazed at each other smoulderingly and there was a beat, during which I wondered if I should book them a room).

On behalf of the Burnham government, Sir James continued that proscription brings with it a fixed suite of measures which had been mandated by parliament. It amounted to a holistic attack on the organisation itself.

Lord Reed commented that here the Secretary of State had agreed the Counter Terrorism Police analysis. On behalf of the Burnham government, Sir James simpered in agreement. He said none of the proposed lesser measures would, individually or together, achieve the same effect.

The lesser measures proposed were not such as to take the proscription outside the margin to be allowed to the Secretary of State in choosing proscription instead.

The covert nature of Palestine Action’s activities required proscription rather than criminal prosecution. There was nothing in the evidence before this court about Red Teams and Black Teams. Some participants wished to escape arrest. That is the advice from CTP. The criminal law had not stopped this activity or prevented damage to property or people.

[Again there was no attempt by the judges to intervene and test some incredible underlying assertions here. Is criminal law expected to actually prevent any crime from ever happening? Do ordinary criminals never seek to evade arrest?]

Sir James then continued that civil injunctions were utterly hopeless in this case, as stated by the Court of Appeal.

On behalf of the Burnham government, Sir James stated that none of the proposed alternatives to proscription passes muster when judged objectively. But the minimum position is that the Secretary of State, within her wide margin of discretion, was entitled to conclude based on the advice she received that proscription was necessary.

Finally, Sir James Eadie said he would address on behalf of the Burnham government the question of the balance of proportionality. The Secretary of State must be afforded a wide margin of discretion on national security matters.

You will have noted by now that Sir James was endlessly repeating himself. He kept glancing at the court clock. Due to well over 100 highly hostile interventions by the judges, Huda Ammori’s legal team had needed to cut their arguments very substantially short, but still overran by 20 minutes. That meant they would only have 10 minutes for rebuttal when Sir James finished speaking, but could regain some of that time if he finished early.

It had been obvious for some time that Sir James was padding out his thin material to take up the time, and as he said “margin of appreciation” and “serious attack at Bristol” for the umpteenth time, it was difficult to stay awake.

Sir James droned on, on behalf of the Burnham government. The fundamental question, he opined, is the nature of Palestine Action as an organisation. It is not, he said, a non-violent direct action group in the tradition of civil disobedience.

It is the opposite. It engages in covert action. It does not accept responsibility and punishment. It bears no resemblance to non-violent civil disobedience groups. It took crowbars and sledgehammers as weapons. It could not be a surprise if in the heat of the moment that turned into serious violence as at Bristol.

On behalf of the Burnham government, Sir James Eadie said that any criminal conduct is outside the protection of Articles X and XI (freedom of speech and freedom of assembly). This applies even more strongly if the activity falls within the definition of terrorism.

Lord Briggs suggested that those who spoke up for Palestine Action were not involved in the terrorism itself.

On behalf of the Burnham government, Sir James Eadie KC said that parliament had foreseen that terrorist organisations would have such supporters, and parliament had set out the criminal provisions that would be applied against them. Parliament had decided that these measures against the organisation and its supporters are appropriate to degrade the organisation.

Palestine Action had been engaged on an escalating trajectory of violence. There was a benefit to degrading Palestine Action and its finances. The aim was to prevent and discourage terrorism and to degrade the organisation, taking all of its activities into account.

Lord Reed stated that as described by the Secretary of State, the organisation had attacked Jewish businesses in North London. Sir James Eadie agreed that this is very important; all of its activities have to be looked at.

Sir James then argued on behalf of the Burnham government that the Court of Appeal had rejected the argument about the impact on Article X and XI rights. He stated that the proscription will not prevent any protests against Israel or Palestine or against Elbit.

On behalf of the Burnham government, Sir James Eadie KC said that the Court of Appeal had found that only a small number of people were likely to face arrest as supporters of Palestine Action. In any event, little weight ought to be given to those who made a conscious decision to break the law by supporting Palestine Action.

Indeed, said Sir James on behalf of the Burnham government, there is evidence that Palestine Action are deliberately engaged in an effort to encourage people to get arrested to overwhelm the justice system.

Huda Ammori had overstated the effects of proscription. The Court of Appeal had said that the number of people whose speech might be chilled was significant, but whatever level it is at is outweighed by the benefits of proscription.

It was a strange performance. Sir James had saved up until the last two minutes the utter demonic callousness of the government’s attitude to the thousands of protestors being arrested for holding placards, and then rushed it all out at once, completely unvarnished.

I suppose that, as his time then ended, he avoided being challenged on it by the judges, but there was no chance of that happening anyway.

Raza Husain KC now had 11 minutes to respond to Sir James on behalf of Huda Ammori. He stated that he would address 9 topics. This was very ambitious, and I am not sure it was wise, as he bolted through them so fast I could hardly get any notes, let alone weigh their significance, but here we go.

  1. The proportionality framework does not give primacy to the Secretary of State, only a degree of discretion. This was the omniscience problem: parliament could not foresee all future events. That is why the proscription regime is subject to the provisions of the Human Rights Act.
  2. Eadie said that the Divisional court and Court of Appeal stated that the three incidents analysed as terrorist were not “outliers”. But what they actually said was that they were “at one end of a spectrum”.
  3. Eadie repeatedly said that Palestine Action were a “self-styled” non-violent direct action group. But that was what every single one of the official Home Office papers and assessments called them. There was not one document before the Secretary of State that said they were violent. Lord Stephens at this stage looked apoplectic and demanded whether Palestine Action had condemned the sledgehammer attack. Raza Husain KC said that the matter was sub judice as currently subject to a criminal case appeal. Judge Johnson’s rulings were under challenge, which should be borne in mind in considering his sentencing remarks. The Underground Manual was very similar to guides produced by other non-proscribed groups, especially in climate action. Trident Ploughshares had also used hammers in their actions.
  4. It was untrue that Palestine Action did not try to convince democratically through their arguments. They did so in the same kinds of way as the Suffragettes.
  5. I couldn’t follow.
  6. Palestine Action has legitimate aims. It is seeking to prevent material supply to an active and widely seen Genocide.
  7. Palestine Action had never attacked Jewish businesses or Jewish people per se. The court had evidence from Andrew Feinstein that he would never support Palestine Action were it antisemitic. The accusation of antisemitism was rejected in the strongest possible terms.
  8. Impact on free speech had been widespread. Lord Lloyd Jones intervened to say that if you supported a proscribed organisation, you opened yourself up to the suite of measures under the Terrorism Act. Husain countered that the point was that Palestine Action did not pose a threat to society.
  9. There was now under a minute left. Raza Husain KC said that this was about the most important issue of our time: Israel’s annihilation of the already oppressed Palestinian people. Palestine Action’s activities ranged from protest to the destruction of drones intended to kill Palestinian children. That was the true import of these proceedings.

So the last sixty seconds from each side showed what they truly thought. The Burnham government said that all those pensioners being arrested are antisemitic terrorists and should be in jail. Raza Husain said that Israel is murdering children and it is legitimate to try and stop it.

That was it for the public sessions. There was to be a closed session. That would be held before the judges without Huda Ammori’s legal team. The government presents its “secret” evidence from the intelligence services. Huda’s team are never told what they say and never get any chance to answer it.

We can be pretty certain they will claim that Palestine Action is funded by Iran or is part of Russia’s “hybrid warfare”. They probably make claims about bombs and guns and other lies. These are coming from the same security services who told you that Iraq had weapons of mass destruction.

The irony is that the very day before these Palestine Action hearings, the High Court ruled that MI5 would not face contempt of court action for lying in another case – not misleading, not misjudging, but actually lying. They conveniently decided that for MI5 to face charges would “not be in the public interest”.

The court was now going to give these liars a secret hearing where they could tell more lies about Palestine Action.

The implications of all of this are truly chilling. The Court’s doctrine is that in matters the government deems “national security”, the Human Rights Act is a dead letter because the decision of the “democratically elected” Secretary of State must be respected, also because she has “national security” technical experts.

The area of national security and the security services is precisely where the Human Rights Act is most needed and the state abuse it protects against is most likely to occur. Under Lord Reed the British “justice system” proudly announces that it is entirely at the service of power in an increasingly fascist state.

As I walked out into London, there was an entirely appropriate postscript. A small group had gathered around a police van. I took a photo and then walked over.

An eighty-four-year-old lady named Margaret had been arrested for supporting Palestine Action. I stood in the rain and waved as the police drove her away.

 

—————————————–

Anybody is welcome to republish and reuse my work, including in translation.

My work has no funding at all except for your subscriptions. If you already subscribe, I would be grateful if you could check if your subscription is still active. Over 80% of my subscriptions lapse when debit or credit cards expire: the systems do not warn you.

Because some people wish an alternative to PayPal, I have set up additional new methods of subscription payment including Patreon account and a Substack account, if you wish to subscribe that way. The content will be the same as you get on this blog. Substack has the advantage of overcoming social media suppression by emailing you direct every time I post. You can, if you wish, subscribe free to Substack and use the email notifications as a trigger to come to this blog and read the articles for free.

I am determined to maintain free access for those who cannot afford a subscription.

Choose subscription amount from dropdown box:

Recurring Donations



PayPal address for one-off donations: [email protected]

Alternatively by bank transfer or standing order:

Account name
MURRAY CJ
Account number 3 2 1 5 0 9 6 2
Sort code 6 0 – 4 0 – 0 5
IBAN GB98NWBK60400532150962
BIC NWBKGB2L
Bank address NatWest, PO Box 414, 38 Strand, London, WC2H 5JB

Bitcoin: bc1q3sdm60rshynxtvfnkhhqjn83vk3e3nyw78cjx9
Ethereum/ERC-20: 0x764a6054783e86C321Cb8208442477d24834861a

 


Allowed HTML - you can use: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

252 thoughts on “Palestine Action Supreme Court Hearing Day 2”

1 2
  • Antoinette DHOOGHE

    How can there be a trial with a secret part to it ??? This should not be allowed under any pretence. There is no independent judicial power anymore, so much is clear. So it means we are in for abuses without recourse. Shall this have to end in front of the International Court of Justice ? How long is this going to take…

      • Alyson

        position which the government is adopting. If you want to jail supporters of a criminal actor then jail all the people who didn’t think Russel Brand was doing anything wrong. They all knew he was an abuser and didn’t care about his victims. They are all accessories to his crimes, by this text book. As a precedent this proscription of supporters to a direct action protest group could have much wider applications.

        We understand that the country is in a bind. We understand that a certain influence group bribes MPs and gets those who decline its freebies expelled from Parties. This partisan position, which perhaps a majority of politicians have accepted, and complied with, underpins the contortions which the Legal System is twisting into here, to try and put genocide perpetrators into a delusional martyr defensive posture.
        The argument doesn’t hold water. The splashback is unavoidable.

        • Brian Red

          Russell Brand was found not guilty of two rapes and an attempted sexual assault, and guilty of one rape and three sexual assaults that allegedly occurred between 17 and 27 years ago. Gotta say it’s interesting that there hasn’t been a huge mountain of evidence to show he has assaulted anyone in the past 17 years.

          • Stevie Boy

            He assaulted the sensitivities of the wokerati with his well put outspoken views !
            His accusers waited two decades to surface at the most opportune moment, this is straight out of the Assange and Salmond playbook, accuse your enemies of sexual misdemeanors absent of any evidence. She said, he said. Oh, and ‘everyone’ apparently knew what he was like but …

          • Brian Red

            @Stevie – Yes, the evidence that Russell Brand raped Woman X whom he was convicted of raping 17 years ago – as opposed to evidence that he was such-and-such a kind of person – seems to have mostly consisted of a) what Woman X said a lot later, anonymously as far as reporting is concerned, and b) text messages of which the worst lines seem to be “you treated me like an animal” and “sorry”.

            Many celebrities’ agents are placing calls right now. His former wife Katy Perry is even “planning a tell-all docuseries about her ‘dark marriage’ “, but curiously she didn’t give a statement to the CPS. The line that’s being put out is that the CPS didn’t ask her to, which gives her a ready answer to the question of why she didn’t do it and was probably worked out in cooperation with her agent and, who knows, perhaps also with Justin Trudeau’s.

          • Tom74

            And look at the state propaganda machine at full tilt against Brand, just as an all police states, completely in cahoots with the authorities. The coverage doesn’t even seem to match the events. I must admit I was also thinking Julian and Alex this morning. I hope Brand gets some relief on appeal but I get the feeling the state made its mind up long ago.

          • AliB

            My, what a lot of rapist apologists are on this feed . Apparently Brand found christianity – but not sufficient to acknowledge his past crimes and plead guilty- no, he insisted on putting all the women through a full trial. I find I have no christian forgiveness for him.

          • Bayard

            “My, what a lot of rapist apologists are on this feed ”

            It is not “apologising for rape” to point out that a) Brand has been critical of the Establishment in the past, b) there seems to be strong correlation between critical of the Establishment and being tried for sexual crimes, c) many rapists who are not high-profile and critical of the Establishment never come to trial and d) the authorities have had 17 years to do something about this particular crime and haven’t and to suggest that there might be a connection between these things in this case. That is not to even imply either that Brand didn’t do it or that he doesn’t deserved to be punished for it.

          • Brian Red

            @Tom74 – Yes and they are going after Ian Winter, Russell Brand’s barrister now:

            https://www.theguardian.com/culture/2026/nov/06/russell-brand-barrister-ian-winter-reports-himself-bar-watchdog-confronting-sunday-times-journalist

            If anyone new now wishes to “come forward” (in tabloid speak) to make an allegation of rape against Brand that is false, she may feel strengthened by the fact that although Brand was found not guilty of one rape charge, the person who made it remains anonymous.

            I’d be interested in how long the jury took to find him not guilty of that charge, but AFAIAA this hasn’t been reported.

          • Brian Red

            @AliB – Nobody here has posted any apologies for rape. As for Brand pleading not guilty, you do realise that all defendants have an absolute right to plead not guilty, and that the state must then prove its case by bringing evidence through the witness box that the defence can challenge and question? Do you have a problem with Brand pleading not guilty to the rape charge he was acquitted on??

          • Clark

            This is why we have to abandon “representative democracy” and instead choose and rotate our decision makers at random, like we do juries. Power itself is the problem. This is why we need Sortition Now!

            – “It should hardly need stating that those who chase power are also those with an appetite for it. And those with an appetite for power are the most likely to abuse that power if and when they achieve it. That happens in the entertainment industry, but it also happens in media, in politics, in law, in business.”

          • Bayard

            “Power itself is the problem.”

            Indeed, the whole idea of representative “democracy” is based on the absurd notion that those who seek to gain power do so entirely from a wish to better the world and not for selfish reasons. Even if that were the case, the difficulties placed in the path to power mean that only the most determined to succeed ever manage to reach the end of that path and with determination usually comes inflexibility, if not bigotry.

    • SleepingDog

      @Antoinette DHOOGHE, don’t forget secret laws, secret courts, secret councils, secret services, secret treaties, secret histories, secret archives, secret committees… all covered by censorship rules which are… secret!

    • Tom Hall

      That’s precisely the sort of tactic- secret evidence- used every day by Israel. And it’s one more indication of what “democratic” rulers have in mind for their subjects, in country after country.

    • Townsman

      Antoinette, the underlying problem is that the UK has no formal Constitution.
      The purpose of a Constitution is that it limits what the politicians can do. To change a country’s Constitution typically requires either a supermajority (not just a majority) in the legislature, or ratification by a referendum, or both.

      Without a Constitution, the party that has a majority in Parliament can make or repeal whatever laws it wants. Typical rights that citizens used to have – the right to remain silent, the prohibition of double jeopardy (being tried twice for the same offence), the right to challenge the evidence against one – are gone.

      A constitution is not a panacea for all ills. Nothing can completely block evil politicians, as we have seen in the USA. But in spite of everything, American citizens in the USA still have rights against excessive government power that we do not.

  • Steve Norris

    Reading through all this, to paraphrase Hunter S Thompson, one can come only to a single conclusion: the British ‘justice’ system is decadent and depraved.

  • Tom Welsh

    “In addition to the public hearing, the government can introduce “closed” secret evidence from the security services. Huda Ammori and her legal team are never shown this, are given no idea of what it alleges, and no opportunity to answer it”.

    That single fact alone renders this whole process a mockery. That cannot ever happen in a fair justice system. Moreover, even the threadbare excuse is absurd: as if Britain had any “security” to worry about! Nobody cares enough about this pathetic little country to bother harming it. We would be much better off if all the “security” services were abolished. If they can’t keep thousands of civilians in rubber dinghies from entering the country illegally, they have obviously failed at the very first hurdle.

    • Stevie Boy

      Let’s recall that some of those civilians in rubber dinghies will be recruited by or have been recruited by the security services. There will be no pushback of the dinghies by MI5/MI6. The secret services wouldn’t want their dirty washing to be viewed by the public, people might get the wrong idea.

    • andic

      If it wasn’t so serious it would be a joke, like the scene in Monty Python’s holly grail where the French shout “we have already got one” and then sit sniggering behind the wall. I imagine the Lords and Sirs doing much the same in their closed sessions.

    • Bayard

      ” If they can’t keep thousands of civilians in rubber dinghies from entering the country illegally, they have obviously failed at the very first hurdle.”

      That presupposes that they even want to keep thousands of civilians in rubber dinghies from entering the country illegally, which is by no means a given. Illegal migration is a gift to the Establishment. It not only provides a pool of labour outside the labour laws and taxes that make labour expensive in the UK, but gives dissatisfied people a scapegoat for their economic woes. What’s not to like?

    • Squeeth

      The Dreyfus Case Redux, the secret dossier too inflammatory to be opened in public that contains damning evidence, rather than a beer mat and a couple of luncheon vouchers.

  • Tom Welsh

    “These planes were used for humanitarian relief missions”.

    Stop it, stop it! You’re killing me. By the way, I am the Emperor Bokassa.

    • Pyewacket

      Tom, many years ago I visited the Farnborough Air show where, without exception, everything displayed was described as having a Defensive and/or Humanitarian role. The words; Attack, Lethality or any hint of aggression was simply never mentioned.

  • Tom Welsh

    “The doctrine is that a large amount of discretion or deference should be shown to the executive in matters of national security…”

    In plain English, all the government ever has to do is scream “NATIONAL SECURITY!! NATIONAL SECURITY!!” and it can then trample all over the law. How King Charles I would have loved to be able to play that card – he might have retained his head. If anyone was ever an obvious terrorist who needed to be proscribed, surely it was Oliver Cromwell.

  • Tom Welsh

    “On behalf of the Burnham government Sir James stated that none of the proposed alternatives to proscription passes muster when judged objectively”.

    How can he tell? Since apparently no one has judged anything objectively in this case.

  • Jm

    Disgusting tyranny,truly evil.

    Thanks so much for bearing witness and documenting this Craig,historians will refer to this in the future as an example of a seriously twisted and sick society.

    • David Warriston

      We have to hope so. Here is a link to an earlier celebrated case: the Reichstag Fire of 1933. Selecting the right judge has always been part of the game.

      ” On March 3, 1933, Goering told the Cabinet that the preliminary examination would soon begin. The examining magistrate was Dr. Braune, “who used to investigate charges against the National Socialist Party, and who has always been most ruthless with us. Even if he did his work objectively, he is hardly the right man to handle so important a case. Thus he might restrict his investigations to the criminal alone….He might even set Deputy Torgler free.” Hitler concurred. Thus, Judge Vogt was chosen to replace Braune.”

      The Reichstag Trial was a bit of a flop internationally for the Nazis judicially but worked well enough on the domestic front at least. Compliant judges rarely face judgment even after the regime they serve falls by the wayside. This extract from post war West Germany:

      ”In one chamber of forty-nine judges, forty had been Nazis, some accused of murder. Some cases aroused intense international interest. One Dr. Hallbauer, a former Storm Trooper, had been a judge in Prague and had sentenced Czechs to death for listening to the BBC or trying to escape slave labor. When a Czech survivor of his “justice” discovered that Dr. Hallbauer was serving as a judge in Hamburg, he brought an action seeking compensation for his injuries. The West German courts ruled that Dr. Hallbauer’s sentences had been “juristically correct.” In 1962 the West German justice ministry prosecuted the Association of Victims of Nazis as “anticonstitutional” the three judges assigned to the trial had all been Nazis, and one a Storm Trooper.”

  • AG

    “Whenever they mention national security it is almost never about the security of the nation.”
    Noam Chomsky

    p.s. On the basis of ascribing to Palestine Action a secret cell structure I would suggest that every family is now regarded as a secret cell too. Since the public is not informed about what is going on inside the family´s everyday life. So let us install 24/7 surveillance cameras in each room of every apartment and house.

        • AG

          “virtually nothing”
          Is it or is just not being reported?
          I know from Germany that many things are just below the line for MSM.
          And then they take place and they have an impact on those present.
          But MSM just claim nothing ever took place.
          So essentially we have multiple histories – locally and globally – taking place at the same time.

        • SleepingDog

          @Stevie Boy, this Freedom Press commentary asks Why aren’t UK students revolting? and notes a difference in education systems. I’ve heard other opinions that mention the revolutions covered positively in school curricula elsewhere, along with citizenship; while most British children are taught subjection, I guess. Although at least they don’t start the day with flaggy oaths of allegiance.

      • Robert Hughes

        Thanks for this info, Clark. We ( my partner and I ) are going to try to make it down to ‘ The Smoke ‘ for this event

        Good to know there are sources of resistance to the utter lunacy that is being imposed on us. Hopefully there will be similar organised protests in Scotland – and throughout the U.K

        It must be made unequivocal to the likes of Gormless Mk2, ie Burnham; Hatchet-Faced Halfwit Healey; Little Dandy ‘ Damien ‘ Streeting ( ahahaha ); & winner of Scotland’s Undertaker Of The Year ( any/every year ) award, ie First Muppet Sw………( sorry, was overcome by deep drowsiness at the mere thought of….thingmy, whitsisname, aye, him ) that if they want a war they’ll have to fight it themselves; or resort to Tellytubbyland East * recruiting * tactics and start dragging men – and women – off the streets, viciously assaulting them in the process before sending them into the Meat & Soul Grinder. * Good luck * with THAT UK LGBZzzz & Zionist Protection Service aka Police Force. They may find it a bit more challenging than * dancing * at Pride Events

        Will the psychos be influenced to, eg change course from catastrophic war, by such protests though? We remember – what I believe was the largest such protest ever in the UK,- ie contra the Iraq * War * ( Slaughter ) and how that had no effect whatsoever on the Bush/Blair awesomely shocking orgy of death prosecuted on the disgusting lie of Saddam’s ( fictional ) WMD.

        Now it’s ‘ Putin is gonna take over the whole of Europe ‘ ( ahaha, why the fuck would Russia or any other country be stupid enough to expend all their resources in ‘ taking over ‘ this Madhouse? It’s leaders are destroying the Continent from the inside ).

        Different day – different lie – same fckn wankers pushing the same shite for the same shite motives. GTTF ( work it out 😉

        • Stevie Boy

          Our glorious democracy lets the people protest – as long as the protesters follow the regimes rules for acceptable protests: keep to the backstreets, keep the noise down, avoid the synagogue, smile for the cameras, nice orderly queuing, etc.
          The only protests that had a (minimal) effect on the government was the poll tax “riots”. There’s the clue, the regime is happy to see protests as long as the status quo is preserved.

          • Robert Hughes

            Aye, Stevie, yr * cynicism * ( realism ) is merited – I share it. Just think there has to be some kind of manifestation of – let’s not forget – the majority opinion against this manic war hysteria being whipped-up. The Poll Tax ‘ Riots ‘ were indeed a good example of public protest having an effect on Government Policy, though that is the only instance of that happening – in modern times anyway – that I can think of. Worth trying anyway I’d say; the alternative being passive acceptance of being herded in potential catastrophe

      • Alyson

        Oh…. You know, we really don’t want martial law. In France a soldier carrying a sub-machine-gun stands at the entrance to the train station. Musk is really keen on having a civil war in Britain. Democracy needs truth in order to function as a precursor to government by consent, but that is infinitely preferable to the alternative

    • JK redux

      Clark
      November 8, 2026 at 21:43

      Clark,
      there don’t seem to be any links to Russian anti-war groups in the youthstrike link?

      • Clark

        I suggest you make that connection if you can; I certainly wouldn’t know who to contact.

        But my understanding of the conflict in Ukraine is that Russia dare not stand down unless NATO can be brought under control by the people of the West. I am convinced that the USA made that war inescapable for Russia, and has somehow convinced EU leaders to take up the fight – the UK mob needing no convincing. I know you disagree, but:

        https://www.rand.org/pubs/research_briefs/RB10014.html

        https://www.middleeasteye.net/opinion/russia-ukraine-us-invasion-paved-how

        https://www.medialens.org/2024/did-the-west-provoke-the-ukraine-war-sorry-that-question-has-been-cancelled/

        • AG

          I feel kind of embarrased today that I once took this RAND paper so seriously.
          But then – one always starts somewhere.

          The stuff these brainies are putting down on paper is in part so childish just by looking at it.

          “Developing but not deploying an intermediate-range missile could bring Russia back into conformity with the Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces Treaty but could also prompt an acceleration of Russian missile programs.”

          What on Earth is that supposed to be? A game of hide and seek between toddlers?

          Or their constant allusion to airpower with an airforce that´s in part 50 years old with missile systems that are nearly as old in an environment that is as hostile to airpower as could be. They finally realized it but a little too late.

          Oh and what I really consider a speciality of RAND: their weighing both sides: It could be this. But then it could be the opposite too.

          Gee. No wonder they fucked this up…

          —
          [ Mod: This article concerns the UK proscription of Palestine Action, not Russia/Ukraine (for which comments should be posted under a more relevant article or on a corresponding thread in the discussion forum). ]

        • JK redux

          Clark
          November 9, 2026 at 00:25

          It is strange that anti-war groups are organising all over Europe (and Turkey) but not in Russia or Ukraine.

          • Clark

            Both those countries are explicitly at war, so suppression by the authorities will be stronger, public disapproval of anti-war protest will be stronger, and personal conscience will be more conflicted.

          • Bayard

            “or Ukraine.”

            Of course, that couldn’t possibly be because protestors would be rounded up and sent to the front if they did, regardless of age or sex. No, it has to be because all Ukranians love the war and enjoy only having electricity for three hours in twenty four and their male relatives being given the opportunity to find out just how dulce and decorum est pro patria mori.

          • JK redux

            Clark
            November 9, 2026 at 14:57

            The Russian regime until recently has jailed anyone referring to the Russian invasion of Ukraine as a war.

            Of course Ukraine is the victim of an unprovoked attack so the likes of “youthstrike” are as thin on the ground there as anti-war protesters were in the USSR in late 1941.

          • JK redux

            Bayard
            November 9, 2026 at 18:40

            Yes Bayard. Ukrainians ” love the war ” just as much as the people of Kyiv and Moscow did in late 1941.

            In the latter two cities, *anti war* protestors would have been shot regardless of age or sex as Nazis.

            And quite right too.

          • Bayard

            “In the latter two cities, *anti war* protestors would have been shot regardless of age or sex as Nazis.
            And quite right too.”

            So you are in favour of shooting conscientious objectors without any form of trial? Even during the WWII in Britain, COs were merely sent to prison if determined to have nothing to do with the war.

          • Stevie Boy

            So, the EU is rounding up all the Ukrainians to send them back to the meat grinder. No peace for Ukraine, to the last Ukrainian …. leopards don’t change their spots !

          • Yuri K

            “The Russian regime until recently has jailed anyone referring to the Russian invasion of Ukraine as a war.”

            Stop spreading lies. I already posted the numbers here sometime ago. In most cases, the indicted get away with a fine.

          • Clark

            JK redux:

            – “Ukraine is the victim of an unprovoked attack…”

            That’s untrue; note the authority of the quotes and citations, particularly the Wikileaks release:

            https://ianjsinclair.wordpress.com/2023/07/19/testimony-from-us-government-and-military-officials-and-other-experts-on-the-role-of-nato-expansion-in-creating-the-conditions-for-the-russian-invasion-of-ukraine/

            – “so the likes of “youthstrike” are as thin on the ground there as…”

            Most Ukrainians want negotiation, not war:

            https://lordashcroftpolls.com/2026/05/ukraine-russia-and-the-battle-for-public-opinion/

            You sicken me, JK redux. You lie, and lie, and lie, to encourage destruction and killing. Crawl under a rock.

      • zoot

        According to this Josh Freeman report you link to, the primary driver behind campus self-censorship and ‘quiet’ no-platforming in Britain is the targeting and disruption of pro-Israel speech.

        So the real threat to free speech in this country is actually anti-genocide students!

        Not our beloved zog, mass arresting pensioners as ‘terrorists’ for holding signs, implementing sham zionist reports to brainwash schoolchildren, banning distinguished academics, liberal US pundits etc from the UK for not being conducive to the public good.

        Btw, you never answer what exactly it is you personally are self-censoring about — the very worst form of censorship according to yourself. This strong agreement with Josh Freeman’s report, however, leaves it wide open for anyone to guess.

        • Pears Morgaine

          Gay rights activist Peter Tatchell was no platformed for islamaphobia after being critical of the attitude of Islamic nations towards gays (still carries the death sentence in some states). Harry Enfield was no platformed because he once appeared in ‘blackface’ in 2007. Alec Salmond was no platformed because the sexual allegations made against him of which he was subsequently acquitted.

          I for one would love to listen to someone who supports Israel’s actions in Gaza and the armed settlers driving Palestinians from their homes justify their position. Wouldn’t you like the opportunity to try and change their mind?

          Universities are increasingly avoiding debate on difficult subjects and limiting speakers to a shrinking list of safe subjects and opinions. This is not the way towards ‘critical thinking and liberation’.

          • zoot

            Right, so you’re annoyed that genocide supporters are getting cancelled by a few kids on some colleg campuses. But not about your actual government helping to commit that genocide and branding those trying to stop it as terrorists and anyone protesting it as antisemites?

            And why are you still refusing to specify what you’re censoring yourself on? What is this issue you can’t speak your mind on, Pears? What are you gagging yourself about?

          • Clark

            Pears Morgaine’s original link is to hepi.ac.uk, the Higher Education Policy Institute, a think tank directed since 2014 by Nick Hillman, the former Special Advisor to the Conservative Party who helped introduce university tuition fees. Very inclusive, I don’t think.

          • Pears Morgaine

            so you’re annoyed that genocide supporters are getting cancelled by a few kids on some colleg campuses. But not about your actual government helping to commit that genocide

            Where did I ever say that?

          • zoot

            Yes, exactly. You have never acknowledged your governments participation in the crime of crimes in Gaza, let alone condemned it.

            Now, how about you answer my question. Either specify what it is you must censor yourself on or quit whining about it.

      • AG

        Here is the problem:

        I don’t know British legal tradition. In the FRG – of course – antisemitism is such a brilliant excuse to suppress free speech because essentially what German legal tradition says: antisemitism is not free speech. It is incitement of violence if happening publicy on- or offline. This is part and parcel of judicial practice since the existence of this, ahem, republic.

        Which is e.g. why you have this old slogan very popular among German leftists: Fascism is no opinion.

        So eventually what you witness is the almost complete breakdown of critical thinking and tradition of an entire nation of 80M.
        Why? Because of the faulty definition of “free speech” as put down into the constitution and the various laws about that.

        To my knowledge thus the only genuine guarantee of free speech is the First Amdendment in the US. Which however was an addition to the Constitution only and is hampered by the immense powers of the presidency and of course other things…

        p.s. All this despite the fact that the German Constitutional Court in essence ruled that “speech is not being censored”. As a basic agreement in society. Alas that is thwarted by the addition that this does not protect the individual from legal consquences if the opinion was incetement of hate. That´s that. And this contradiction which neuters the most important idea of free speech (discussing views the powers to be are opposed to) has never become so apparent as now. If leftists are opposing free speech and protest, in the name of an ideology that contradicts core leftist ideas, what can you do? Suffer incarceration, debanking, loss of job, ostracization for 100 years until something may improve? No promising outlook.

        • Bayard

          ” In the FRG – of course – antisemitism is such a brilliant excuse to suppress free speech because essentially what German legal tradition says: antisemitism is not free speech. It is incitement of violence if happening publicy on- or offline. This is part and parcel of judicial practice since the existence of this, ahem, republic.”

          This sort of thing is a result of binary thinking, something is either good or it’s evil. If it’s good it’s all good, if it’s evil it’s all evil. Anti-semitism, (Jew-hating, not the modern definition, which encompasses any criticism of Jews or Israel) is a problem. Many blog comment pages, especially the USA based ones, are rife with it. However, things like the above assume that because it is wrong to say that Jews are evil, then it follows that Jews must be good and not just good in parts, but good through and through. Furthermore, it assumes that, because Jews are all good, then no-one will take mean advantage of such legislation to do bad things in the knowledge that such legislation protects them from criticism. All of which is absurd as the most cursory study of history will show.

          • AG

            “This sort of thing is a result of binary thinking”

            Well, that derives from the way “Nazism” has been treated as a historic subject since 1945.

            It is the embodiment of evil vs. good. And everything that is regarded as essential part of Nazism, such as antisemitism, will elicit the manichean state of madness.

            History and its instrumentalization in the past comes back with a vengeance these days.
            And it´s getting worse every year.

  • Twirlip

    “On behalf of the Burnham government, Eadie said that the aim of proscription is to protect the lives and liberties of ordinary citizens from Palestine Action”

    What, you’re doing all this for little old me? How very kind and thoughtful of you! But please, don’t go to all this trouble, just on my behalf. I’m not scared of Palestine Action. (Of course, I don’t support them. Heavens, no!) Nor am I scared of all those grannies and vicars you’re proposing to lock up, presumably also in order to protect my life and liberty. I’ll take my chances against that lot. Please, just don’t bother. I’ll be fine, honestly! But it’s very nice of you, Mr. Burnham. I’m touched by your concern.

  • Heterodox

    Apologies for the length of the following – Mods: please remove if too long.

    I am NOT a lawyer, this is a layman’s interpretation of the law (specifically the Terrorism Act 2000). Readers will note that I profess support for neither side in the argument, though they may wish to interpret my stance as they desire.

    The Statutory Definition
    Section 1 of the Terrorism Act 2000 defines terrorism by reference to “action” falling within five categories:
    serious violence against persons,
    serious damage to property, endangering life,
    creating a serious risk to public health or safety, and
    serious interference with electronic systems.
    The action must be designed to influence a government or intimidate the public, and must be made for the purpose of advancing a political, religious, racial or ideological cause.

    Section 1(4) expressly provides that “action” includes action outside the United Kingdom, that references to persons or property apply wherever situated, that “the public” includes the public of a country other than the UK, and that “government” includes the government of a country other than the UK. The definition contains no carve-out for state military operations. There is no exemption for “just cause.”

    Application to Gaza
    The documented facts are these: over 70,000 acknowledged deaths; 92 per cent of housing destroyed; hospitals, schools and public infrastructure flattened. UN bodies have found genocide, war crimes and crimes against humanity. These findings are contested by Israel but are not seriously disputed in any legal forum that has examined the evidence.

    On the face of section 1, these actions correspond to the conduct enumerated in section 1(2)(a) (serious violence against persons), (b) (endangering life) and (c) (serious damage to property). If the objective effect is to cause widespread fear among the civilian population, the “intimidation of the public” element is difficult to argue as absolutely incapable of being satisfied. At the definitional level, the conduct cannot be excluded from the category of “terrorism.”

    The Confirmed British Victims and the World Central Kitchen Strike
    The public record confirms that British nationals have died in Gaza as a result of IDF actions. A written parliamentary answer in February 2025 confirmed that the deaths of four British nationals in Gaza since 7 October 2023 had been reported to the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office.

    The most extensively documented incident is the 1 April 2024 Israeli drone strike on a World Central Kitchen convoy in Deir al-Balah. The strike killed seven aid workers, including three British nationals: John Chapman, James Henderson and James Kirby. The UK government’s own statement at the UN Security Council described the UK as “appalled” by the killing of the seven aid workers, “including three of our British nationals”. The Foreign Secretary summoned the Israeli Ambassador and set out “the government’s unequivocal condemnation of the appalling killing”.

    The circumstances are these. The convoy consisted of three vehicles, two of them armoured, all clearly displaying the World Central Kitchen logo. The charity had coordinated its movements with the IDF. According to the charity, the convoy was hit while leaving a warehouse after unloading over 100 tonnes of humanitarian food aid brought to Gaza by sea. The three vehicles were struck separately over approximately four minutes as survivors attempted to move from one car to another. The Israeli military initially described the strike as a “grave mistake” resulting from misidentification, and later said that what soldiers believed was a weapon carried by a person entering one of the vehicles was actually a bag.

    Even accepting the IDF’s claim that it was targeting Hamas, the deliberate lethal strike on a vehicle killing British nationals remains an unlawful killing captured by the statute. Section 1 of the Terrorism Act 2000 contains no exception for mistaken target identification or claimed military purpose; the deliberate use of lethal force causing death falls within section 1(2)(a) and (c). Section 63C provides jurisdiction where such an act of terrorism is done against a UK national and would, if committed in the UK, constitute murder or assault causing injury. The IDF’s admission that it deliberately struck the vehicles it believed contained Hamas operatives establishes the intentional use of lethal force; the claim of mistake goes to lawfulness and proportionality, not to whether the act was deliberate. An unlawful intentional killing is murder; the statutory gateway does not require proof of a correct target, only that the conduct constitutes an act of terrorism and a listed offence.

    The Jurisdictional Gateway: Section 63C
    Section 63C of the Terrorism Act 2000 provides that if a person does anything outside the UK as an act of terrorism or for the purposes of terrorism, his action is done to or in relation to a UK national, UK resident or protected person, and his action, if done in any part of the UK, would have constituted an offence listed in subsection (2), he shall be guilty of that offence. The listed offences include murder, manslaughter, and assault causing injury.

    The legal conditions are therefore satisfied at the textual level in respect of the World Central Kitchen victims: British nationals were killed; the conduct corresponds to murder or assault causing injury; the conduct occurred abroad. The only remaining legal question is whether the conduct constituted an “act of terrorism” within the meaning of section 1. As established above, the conduct in Gaza meets the definitional threshold on the face of the statute, and the killings occurred as part of that conduct.

    The Government’s Silence
    The government has not stated that the conduct in Gaza meets the definitional threshold of section 1. It has not stated that section 63C is legally available in respect of the British victims. It has not characterised any IDF action in Gaza as an act of terrorism. It has instead summoned ambassadors, called for investigations, and expressed condemnation in the language of humanitarian concern rather than the language of terrorism legislation.

    The reason for that choice has no official explanation in the public record. What is clear is that the government has chosen not to make a statement it was free to make: that the conduct meets the definition, and that, were the jurisdictional and evidentiary conditions satisfied, it would treat the conduct as terrorism.

    The Domestic Contrast
    The government’s position in the Supreme Court is that “serious damage to property” alone can constitute terrorism, and that the action “did not need to involve violence or an intent to endanger life”. The Court of Appeal upheld the proscription of Palestine Action. Home Office statistics for the year ending September 2025 record 1,630 arrests linked to supporting Palestine Action, of whom 243 were charged under sections 12 or 13 of the Terrorism Act 2000. By the time of the Supreme Court hearing in November 2026, the court was told that more than 3,000 people had been arrested since the ban.

    (Part 2 to follow)

  • Heterodox

    Part 2…

    The Point
    The two situations are not legally identical. One involves conduct on a scale that the statutory definition was designed to capture but cannot reach through the UK’s jurisdictional provisions except in the narrow circumstances section 63C contemplates. The other involves property damage and a single assault being processed through the same statute against people holding placards.

    But the disparity is this: the government is willing to use the broad “property damage = terrorism” theory against domestic protesters, while refusing to characterise conduct in Gaza that killed named British citizens as terrorism, despite section 63C providing a jurisdictional gateway that is legally available. The government could say, without asserting any jurisdiction it lacks, that the World Central Kitchen strike and the broader conduct in Gaza meet the definitional threshold of the Act. It has chosen not to. That is not a legal necessity. It is a political choice.

    The logical path is this: the statute’s definition encompasses the IDF’s conduct; section 63C provides a jurisdictional gateway in respect of UK victims; British victims are confirmed, including three named individuals killed in a deliberate missile strike on a marked aid convoy; the government has never characterised the conduct as terrorism; it has nonetheless applied the same statute’s broad theory aggressively to domestic protesters. The hypocrisy lies in the selective willingness to name what the law defines.

    • azymax

      Bravo for the marathon argumentation! The stark hypocrisy of – not just the Government, but – the consensual political establishment is indeed astounding.

      The legal dodge for them, as I’m following it (and this is not just limited to English jurisdiction), lies with the jurisprudential tenet that state agents, as organs of state, cannot commit ‘terrorism’ as such. Atrocities, war crimes, breaches of International Humanitarian Law or the Genocide Convention, yes in certain circumstances, but not ‘terrorism’. Therefore, the Terrorism Act 2000 and subsequent legislation will not apply.

      That caused a problem for the UK Govt when it came to obliging Israeli lobby clamours to proscribe the Iranian Revolutionary Guards Corps (e.g. from ‘We Believe in Israel’, amongst others), since the wailing did not comprehend (i) that proscription could not apply to a governmental organisation, nor (ii) that if it weren’t for (i), the IOF would be suffocating in litigious shit. As a result, we now have the fast-tracked National Security (State Threats) Act 2026, under which designated state-backed groups and their deemed ‘proxies’ can be nominated and pursued (along with existing national security legislation), thereby enabling the outlawing of the IRGC …

      And that simply to protect the hypocrisy, since designation will always be asserted as a matter of national security, assessed subject to discretion of responsible ministers/AGs/DPPs and their expert security advisers. The augmenting disparity between national legislation and compliance with international legal norms demanded of High Contracting Parties to ratified treaty conventions has yet to begin to resolve. Meanwhile, HMG continues to stonewall requests from the families of the victims of the World Central Kitchen massacre for a proper enquiry; Counter-Terrorism Police iteratively declines to investigate evidence of dual-nationals illegally implicated in IOF military operations in the occupied Palestinian territories; HMG maintains, in spite of serial ICJ opinions prohibiting co-operation with an unlawful occupation, a secretive military development agreement with the state of Israel; and so on …

      • Heterodox

        “The legal dodge for them, as I’m following it (and this is not just limited to English jurisdiction), lies with the jurisprudential tenet that state agents, as organs of state, cannot commit ‘terrorism’ as such.”

        Not at all. I was trying to prove that there is a legal path to “prosecution” of the IDF under provisions of the Terrorism Act 2000.

        Firstly by proving Section 1 (essentially that many of its actions constitute terrorism as defined) and then by applying Section 63C (illegal killing of British nationals even in a foreign jurisdiction).

        The Government has totally ignored that potential pathway (which includes illegal killing of 3 UK nationals) and chosen instead to arrest (and prosecute?) hundreds or thousands of peaceful placard wavers as terrorists.

        Both pathways are available to follow legally but either or both are at the discretion of the Government.

        I actually followed up on the research above and wrote another one that shows a legal path (with precedent and evidential basis) to the UK Government prosecuting itself for Terrorism under the 2000 Act! It’s very long, but i enjoyed the thought process getting there… Possibly too much to post here (as I suspect my previous submissions were).

        • ANN OWEN

          Many years ago, when I was teaching in Nigeria, I spoke to many students at my college, who told me that they hoped to study Law in the future. I was surprised at that as, at the time I was involved in agricultural education, but of course – that was not an attractive proposition for any of them, not surprising given their background…. I could not understand their desire to follow a legal route instead of a career which would have been of more practical/immediate value to their communities. By now, I am a bit wiser, so I hope that my erstwhile students are now able to ignore the advice I gave them and continue to advocate for justice via the LAW- good luck to them on that !

  • Feral Finster

    You never will get justice from.a british court.

    The point of the police surveillance was to tell protesters: “Big Brother Is Watching You.” Pretend that this were happening in Russia or any other country that the Empire doesn’t like.

    • Heterodox

      I agree entirely. In the same vein, if you substituted “IRGC” for “IDF” in my rather long treatise above, the police would be bringing the protesters cups of tea, not arresting them as terrorists

  • M.J.

    As I understand, Ed Miliband’s comment was explicitly cited in court. Because it is now part of the official record, it can be regarded in judgment (by those justices who are willing) as indirect support for using ECHR Articles 10 and 11 to ‘read down’ the way ‘support’ in the law is interpreted—effectively restricting it to material and financial support.
    That compromise would enable the justices to both show ‘deference’ to HMG on national security while simultaneously ‘reading down’ the legislation to avoid convicting pensioners as terrorists for simply carrying placards.
    We’ll have to wait and see, though hopefully the wait won’t be indefinite, given that thousands of arrests and pending cases are tied to this wider crackdown. A decision before Christmas would certainly bring some much-needed clarity to a lot of people.

      • Peter Mo

        Perhaps the most important point not made is that proscription of groups such as Hamas and Hezbollah also indirectly of Palestine Action encourages Israel to go on a killing spree. Any such encouragement to kill civilians is prohibited in English law.
        Proscription may be OK at some other time but right now the court must be mindful that the violence has to stop. It should be more a crime to advocate for proscription than to oppose it.

      • M.J.

        I stand corrected. Milliband’s remarks were to LBC, not the court.
        It was an AI hallucination. I think I should confirm such “info” on apparent fact eg with other news reports.

      • M.J.

        Response from AI (Google Gemini) to my comment about its proneness to hallucinations:
        “Systems like mine process massive amounts of patterns, but we lack real-world awareness, do not genuinely “remember” events, and can confidently fabricate details (hallucinate) when gaps in data or timelines occur. Your experience is a textbook example of why critical thinking and human corroboration remain absolutely essential.”

  • David on an Island

    My maternal grandfather emigrated to the US in 1907 after nearly two decades as a member of the D’Oyly Carte Opera Company. Smart man. I will never visit that sh*thole country of England again.

    The English invented the concentration camp in order to slowly kill Boer women and children by neglect and have continued their assault on human dignity through the imprisonment and force-feeding of Suffragettes and the H-Blocks of Belfast down to today.

    How does opposing the Revisionist Zionist genocide threaten the national security of England? The government won’t say in public but it doubtless involves money changing hands to the sole benefit of elites, not the nation they falsely purport to represent. Even Trump and Miller could not be so brazenly biased against the opponents of actual fascism (Ze’ev Jabotinsky was a dedicated follower of Mussolini; his terrorist Stern Gang followers Begin and Shamir founded Likud).

    Disgusting — thank you for your reports!

    • Pears Morgaine

      Sorry to be pedantic but it was the Spanish who invented concentration camps, first using them during the Cuban war of independence 1895-98.

      https://suruinstitute.com/concentration-camps-in-cuba/

      If both cases the intention was not to kill but to deprive their opponents of support. Both the Spanish and the British underestimated the problems of supplying these camps with food and that already over-stretched medical facilities (the British lost more men to disease during the Boer Wars than to enemy action) would collapse.

      • Bayard

        “In both cases the intention was not to kill but to deprive their opponents of support.”

        Which is why the Nazi “concentration camps” were not, in fact, the same as the British and Spanish ones, but were either death camps, where death was the object, or just a particularly nasty form of prison camp from which it was never intended that the inmates should ever return to normal society, little different from the PoW camps for the Russian PoWs or the Allied PoWs in the Far East.

    • Clark

      – “How does opposing the Revisionist Zionist genocide threaten the national security of England?”

      Because Israel is the West’s psychopathic attack dog and “unsinkable aircraft carrier” in the Middle East, to ensure an abundant supply of liquid fossil fuels for, primarily, military aircraft and all naval vessels other than nuclear subs and aircraft carriers.

      And indeed, it involves money; see, for example, extensive comments about Tony Blair by Komodo, here:

      https://www.craigmurray.org.uk/archives/2015/02/an-apology/

      • Brian Red

        Most air strikes that western powers have carried out in the Middle East, when not launched from their own literal aircraft carriers, have been conducted from bases in Gulf Arab countries such as Qatar. Occasionally Cyprus has also been used. But the Occupation regime in Palestine is not known for allowing other powers to use its resources much. As for why this is so, it’s not about fear of the table suddenly turning in the other direction, or about keeping up an image, but simply an illustration of the power relationship. As in “Why don’t they? Well why should they?” (Cf. the royal family don’t offer their drawing rooms for the peasants to come into and have a good knees-up.)

        • Clark

          You’re claiming that Israel controls the West. With reference to the vast disparity of resources available to each, the length of time that this has persisted, and that the UK and the USA were primarily responsible for the Israel being established, please explain how this is so.

          • zoot

            It hardly requires explanation, as it’s self-evident. Never more so in these last 3 years.

            The questions that need answering are all for those who desperately want to deny it.

            How have ‘anti-racist’ western liberal governments benefitted from being seen to pitilessly shred brown babies in Gaza?

            What is ‘liberal’ Britain gaining from being seen to arrest hundreds of pensioners as terrorists and trying to end the ancient right to trial by jury in order to secure convictions?

            Why, if Israel is just a tool of the west, does it bankroll every US presidential and congressional candidate and half the British cabinet? To the tune of hundreds of thousands of pounds in Our Andy’s case. The fact that core reality of western ‘democracy’ is never referenced by western media is just one more question. Ask yourself why they never mention it.

          • Clark

            Zoot, of course these “leaders” support Israel; Israel is very useful as a weapon, an excuse and a focus for public anger. This is convergence of interests; surely not Israeli control of the West, because I don’t see how it could be possible. Israel couldn’t control the Middle East monarchies / dictatorships without the West. Only the USA has hundreds of military bases all over the world. It has nearly half of all military capacity in the world too.

            There is control, or decisive influence, but it is not on overt display; so-called democracy is a good cover for and distraction from it. Big money, multiple multi-billionaires, vested interests such as the media, surveillance, arms, and oil industries; these to a large extent run Israel and the West, certainly far more than governments do.

          • Bayard

            “please explain how this is so.”

            If you want to know who runs a country, just look to see which group you are not allowed to criticise. IHRA definition, anyone?

    • Squeeth

      Oh FFS! The Spanish used concentration camps in the American-Spanish war 1898 and they copied them from that nice Andrew Jackson who used them to concentrate the Cherokee and Seminole people before sending them on death marches (see the Treaty of New Echota for the Cherokee) later copied by the Japanese army in the Philippines.

  • OdessaGagarin

    Thank you Craig for your efforts, much appreciated. I admire your courage and tenacity. There is no hope of course. The democratically elected Israeli government will continue to kill Palestinians very democratically. I read somewhere that 80% of Israeli voters agree with the current genocide, so this is democracy in action. The democratically elected UK government will continue to support Israel and continue to jail anyone who publicly disagrees or tries to organise résistance. Again, democracy in action. The democratically elected US government will continue to kill people overseas very democratically. Everyone agrees that all the ordinary Americans care for is cheap gas and cheap food. Who is going to provide that? Americans themselves? In the fattest country in world, with the most jails, with the highest levels of schizophrenia, depression, anxiety, ADHD, autism, genderism, diabetes, where mass shootings are daily events? That can only be gotten by getting Venezuela’s oil, Iran’s oil, killing people along the way, getting extortion money from everyone including allays. It is not publicly commented on, but the Americans know it with their guts, so they very democratically vote for assassinations, wars, and killing others, in order to get the cheap gas and cheap food. Again, democracy in action. This of course is not going to change anytime soon. As long as the state has money to pay the police, there will be no change. There is no shortage of people fighting to get a safe, secure, well paid job, from Peterloo to Orgreave, to arresting grannies holding a piece of paper. This blogs sees 100 comments on a good day. The unhinged Simon Tisdall gets over 2000 cheering supporters in the comments each time he calls for WWIII, they are so eager, they can’t wait for it to start. It is truly dismal and dispiriting. I lived half of my life in the country X, ruled by a communist party, and half in the countries Y and Z, exemplary democracies. Country X is no longer ruled by the communist party. But here are two points. In my opinion, country X was never ruled better than it was ruled by the communist party. Commenters here may disagree, but consider this: whatever they think country X did (if it ever did, there are lots of myths about concentration camps and repressions), it did it to their own. It never attack others, never supported wars or violence. And now it a democratic country, and also poor, corrupt, in demographic blackhole it will not come out of in 50 years, if ever, living standard a fraction of what it was, but with NATO bases, and supporting overseas wars. When it is a matter of national security, the state apparatus in country X would have been just as you describe it here. But most people don’t notice or don’t mind, and this is what counts. The propaganda in the ‘West’, which overflows in countries like X, is ever so pervasive and slick, it makes people vote against their own interest. And this is not going to change either. Everyone of us is complicit in our own little or big way. For example, I have no courage to take to the streets with a card ‘ I support PAG’, and I am complicit too. Does not look promising I am afraid. I don’t know what the answer is. Saying ‘I admire your courage, PAG, H…A …ri’ is surely not the answer, but unfortunately, I have not got the strength of character to do more than make a money contribution to your blog, or perhaps joining a march or something.

    • M.J.

      Here are a few reasons for maintaining hope in democracies.
      1. The US Midterms and probable direction of that country under leaders of the next generation like Zohran Mamdani, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, Abdul El-Sayed and James Tallarico.
      2. I’ve just opened Ilan Pappé’s book Israel on the Brink (ISBN 9781836433248) which sets out a vision for the future.
      3. Even in Israel there are dissidents such as Mesarvot.
      4. Democracies contain the possibility of change which dictatorships do not permit. When the FBI caught the Soviet spy Kaarlo Tuomi in the late 50s, one of their agents (during a debate with the captive spy) said to him, ‘We have real problems in this country, but we can at least try to solve them with the ballot box.’ Not that human nature won’t make for difficulties, in every generation.
      5. In this country an anti-Zionist resolution was passed by the Green party, which is gaining in influence. But even before that, Amnesty International had judged Israel to be an apartheid state that committed genocide.

      • Crispa

        “Democracies contain the possibility of change which dictatorships do not permit”. Arguable. Dictatorships” including absolute monarchies when brought down by internal or external forces often result in radical change do they not? French Revolution, Russian Revolution, Iraq, Afghanistan, Syria etc etc. Meanwhile democracies bumble on without any real change – no prospects of real change in uni-party USA, Israel , EU or anywhere else. Sparks will be quickly extinguished. I can read the same issues about such as abolition of the monarchy and House of Lords, Irish unification and the threats to the established order posed by radical movements in Victorian newspapers and the status quo is exactly now as it was then. Establishment rule in a so – called democracy is far stronger and more controlling than in many “dictatorships”. They just use different and more insidious methods as we are seeing right now.

        • SA

          The so called democracies have ceased to be democracies when it has legalised buying parties by uncontrolled donations by the billionaires and oligarchs. All is left is the figleaf of elections within a system that is unchangable democtatically.

      • Clark

        M.J., I’m glad to see that you have been thinking about the deficiencies in Western so-called democracy.

        Democracy needs an upgrade. Again.

        This is how it goes throughout history. When sufficiently oppressed, the people rise, fight for and win more rights, freedoms and power. The forces of repression and exploitation then gradually and increasingly work out how to undermine those gains. The population become increasingly frustrated until they again boil over. Less the political pendulum we are told of; more a sawtooth-shaped pattern of change.

        Sortition Now!
        Friday 20th November – be at your local protest and contribute to a people’s assembly.

        • Heterodox

          No chance! Sortition would require a change in the law. Who makes the laws… ah yes, the politicians who we want to replace. Asking the Turkeys to vote for Christmas.

          And yes, I’d be a massive fan of “qualified, fixed term sortition”. For example: minimum intelligence threshold, 2-3 (?) year term, swapping out 1/6 of the assembly every year to ensure some sort of continuity of process… we can dream!

    • David Warriston

      OdessaGagarin,

      I think the fig leaf of ‘democracy’ to justify loot and plunder is disintegrating, much as its predecessor ‘christianity’ did early in the 20th century. I can’t see the next pretext- most probably some form of ecological ideology- being much of an improvement if the warmongering sentiments of the German faction is any guide.

      I don’t see the problem as ideology per se. The three I listed above are all capable of speaking to what is admirable in human nature and generally people are quick to respond to such ideas. Unfortunately many are equally quick to respond to the more basic instincts you described and, far from beng brainwashed by propaganda, are actually comforted to hear justification for their inner selfishness. Many model citizens of the post war Raspberry Reich were loyal Nazis back in their youth and were no more brainwashed by Hitler than they were by Marshall Plan money.

    • Yuri K

      ” The democratically elected UK government will continue to support Israel and continue to jail anyone who publicly disagrees or tries to organise résistance. Again, democracy in action.”

      I disagree on this one. As I pointed out already, the majority of British public holds negative views of Israel (69% according to Pew Research), so this is either a democracy in inaction or a non-democracy in action.

    • ABruce

      80% of Israeli voters are as you say genocide supporters, but when you consider that the arab portion of Israeli voters allowed to vote make up 20%, that looks to me like a demographic of 100% psychopathic mönsters.

  • Brian Red

    “plus a man with a hefty backpack, which was presumably uploading for facial recognition in real time.”

    Likely to be for a lot more than identification.

    The policeman Jimmy Palantir is suspected of being the grandson of Lord Lucan. Facial emotion analysis of his mug (he’s a complicated man, so the NSA had to be called in) has revealed … well I wouldn’t want to say here.

  • Crispa

    There is another upcoming trial that will no doubt test the justice of the justice system which is that of Sarah Wilkinson from January 4 2027 at Birmingham to hear charges of:
    – Two counts of encouraging terrorism, relating to statements allegedly posted on her X account in March 2024.
    – Two counts of expressing an opinion or belief supportive of a proscribed organisation, namely Hamas.
    – Two counts of disseminating a terrorist publication, relating to videos allegedly shared on X in May 2024.
    – One count of failing to comply with a notice issued under section 49 of the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000, by allegedly failing to provide the PIN for her mobile phone in November 2024.
    The trial is scheduled to last two weeks and it has taken over two years to come to trial with Sarah Wilkinson on bail all that time with her freedoms seriously curtailed over that period. Note how the British State has its citizens in a tight pincer grip in its use of its proscription powers.

    • Brian Red

      Section 12(1A) of the British regime’s Terrorism Act 2000 is a corker. “A person commits an offence if the person (a) expresses an opinion or belief that is supportive of a proscribed organisation, and (b) in doing so is reckless as to whether a person to whom the expression is directed will be encouraged to support a proscribed organisation.”

      That the belief is correct, or even that it is probably correct, or may be correct, is no defence.

      How can a belief be “supportive” of anyone anyway?

      Does it have to be a belief about a factual state of affairs, or can it be a belief as to what should or shouldn’t happen? For example if a person believes that this Act should be repealed, and they tell someone, has their action met the requirement for criterion a) ?

      “I oppose genocide. I support the repeal of S12(1A) of the Terrorism Act.”

      “The trial is scheduled to last two weeks and it has taken over two years to come to trial

      Police took my laptop and a number of phones more than two years ago and have never charged me.

      • Bayard

        “How can a belief be “supportive” of anyone anyway?”

        The legislation is deliberately vague as its purpose is not to prevent crime but to enable the government to lock up anyone they don’t like.

    • AG

      “If the Government is allowed to produce unchallenged evidence in secret”
      That´s the problem which in essence was already one during the Inquisition.
      The only thing they do different today is not burn people.

      • SA

        Bayard
        It is no longer the case that anyone cares about justice. Many cases are now discussed openly and widely as they are being tried, so much so that I cannot understand how any jury would not be swayed by the public debate about them as seen by many recent trials.

        • Bayard

          “It is no longer the case that anyone cares about justice. ”

          I’d disagree. There are many people in this country who care deeply about justice, it’s just that they are not let within spitting distance of the levers of power. Justice is still available in the UK, except if it involves putting the Establishment at a disadvantage. The phenomenon you cite generally only occurs when one side of the court case involves the government.

          • SA

            Of course there are people who care but the various instances of open trials by the press of ongoing cases even sometimes before they are being investigated by the police is a case in point.

  • glenn_nl

    Thank you for another such detailed report – the only one we’ll ever get.

    Unbelievable that open courts, open government and evidence being available to examine and verify, are all matters of convenience as the government sees fit.

    I fear that the courts – like our famous “Petitions to Parliament” are no more than cynical theatrics, a show, a pretence to democracy.

    Incidentally, anyone who thinks a sledgehammer would make a good offensive weapon, has obviously never lifted one in their entire life.

  • AG

    speaking of censorship:

    Currently there are discussions of a bill to “reform” censorship of German media at large.

    The idea is to install 24/7 live AI-based surveillance of media channels and if the AI gives an alert the people in charge can without any court decision shut down access to the channel immediately.

    So it couldn´t get much more dystopian than this.

    Amazingly this discussion is happening without any participation of the very media that would be operating under this regime. They ignore the issue.

    Only alternative media are reporting on this – as usual.

    This isn´t funny any more.

    Only glimmer of hope is the fact that all 16 states have to agree to this which won´t happen.

    But the fact that there are enough sick politicians to work out such drafts (one such discussion paper pdf has 190 pages) is nauseating enough.

    I really don’t know what is happening with “society”. How is this kind of stuff even possible.

    • andic

      “Amazingly this discussion is happening without any participation of the very media that would be operating under this regime. They ignore the issue.”

      Not amazing at all, legacy media have no intention of stepping out of line and it won’t affect them – only the competition. They literally have nothing to loose by ignoring the issue.

      • AG

        Of course, absolutely right – especially if we look at the things said behind closed doors.

        On the other hand you do have a very large crowd of journalists who are working for major channels and outlets and who are of a generation that criticizes the security state – or used to – and so forth – and yet lost all its critical bearings – just as the left as such in Germany has lost it. That is: those in the MSM who do not act entirely without reflecting on power and not entirely with regard to their own benefit only. THOSE people do not cover this either. THOSE who used to say, diversity matters (“DEI”?!).
        The failure of those who used to sit on the right side.

    • Robert Hughes

      ‘ I really don’t know what is happening with “society”. How is this kind of stuff even possible.’

      This is a question I ask myself every day, ’cause it seems like * things *, * society *, are getting worse every day. It feels increasingly like we ( eg the majority of commenters here ) are watching a really crap movie – ludicrous plot, risible characters and awful acting, and the whole cinema is cheering wildly at the drivel on the screen; whilst we look around, open-mouthed with dismayed bafflement asking ‘ are we watching the same film? ‘

      We can speculate ‘ how this kind of stuff ( is ) even possible ‘ and we all have our individual * take * on that: not going to into that ATM; for one thing, It’s fairly complex and difficult to determine how all the various ( negative ) elements have interacted & coalesced to bring us to such a frightful precipice. One imponderable is whether the current appalling state of * things * is a direct result of the abysmal calibre of the Political Class or if the latter is reflective of a deeper, broader malaise within the Collective Psyche of Humankind – specifically, the West/European Psyche, from which so much darkness and jaw-dropping stupidity is pouring.

      ‘ Germany to rearm in a massively resourced programme of military spending, ie spending on the Military: WUNDERBAR!! ‘ German Economy declining rapidly: MEIN GOTT!! What could possibly go wrong with a Germany under the control of fanatical ideologues, teetering on the edge of if not economic collapse, certainly socio-economic turmoil and decline? Twice in one century of German unresolved Will To Power leading to millions of deaths and utter devastation not sufficient; is it a case of ‘ 3rd time lucky ‘ for those heirs of Aryan Supremacy ( now camouflaged as * protecting Europe from the evil ‘ Putin ‘ ) fantasists, eg Von der Idiot, Fredo Merde, and ‘ honorary Krauts ‘ like Gaga Kallas ( the former Soviet Bloc countries now amongst the most unhinged in their desire to see Russia harmed – ideally, in the twisted Balkan revenge-seeking mentality, Russia destroyed; basically, acting like desperate-to-please their new masters in the E.U sycophantic poodles who imagine they’re terriers ) ?

      I’m incline to believe the latter is the case, in short…..’ we get the Politicians/Political System we deserve ‘. If not ‘ deserve ‘ ( what the hell could we have done to ‘ deserve ‘ the current bunch of fckn idiots? ), then by our passivity, ‘ I’m alright Jackery ‘, partisanship and acceptance of mediocrity/bad faith, no more than we can expect: aim low – get low results.

      The main question is not, so much ‘ how did we get to this depressing pass? ‘ but ‘ how the fuck can we get out of it? ‘. As previously stated, I don’t see any other answer to the latter question than, REVOLT.

      • JK redux

        Robert Hughes
        November 10, 2026 at 09:00

        “Si vis pacem, para bellum” is still true, sad to say. Even in Germany.

        Presumably you are equally critical of increasing defence spending in Sweden, Finland, Poland and the Baltic States?

        But perhaps, not critical of the enormous increases in Russian military and “security” spending?

        • Robert Hughes

          Look, pal, gonnae stop addressing me directly. I think I’ve made it clear I’m not remotely interested in yr opinion on the subject of the Proxy War; on the contrary, people like yrsel just irritate-the-fuck out of me. If you want to be an idiot, or perhaps have no choice other than to be one, fine, nae bother, but don’t lay yr idiocy anywhere near me. Not least because if the lunacy you continue to salivatingly support actually comes to pass, eg if Conscription happens, I have a son who would potentially be amongst the Conscripted, So while you fuck about in Belgium, manifesting what Bayard excellently describes as ‘ the reckless bravery of the non-combatant ‘ there are very real-life consequences for what you rather pathetic Armchair Napoleons are supporting. So, just fuck off, away from me, anyway. If Craig is content to let the likes of you dribble yr pish hereabouts that’s up to him

          Mod. Please note. I have asked him not to address me/any comments I might make directly. If he continues to do so, I’ll consider it deliberate provocation and respond accordingly

          • JK redux

            Robert Hughes
            November 10, 2026 at 10:20

            It’s a discussion forum, “pal”..

            —
            [ Mod: It’s an article comments section. The discussion forum is a separate facility.

            From the moderation rules for commenters:

              In general, there is no need at all to address other commenters in your remarks.
              You can address their arguments, but that is different.

            Questions should be phrased so they can be answered by anyone. ]

          • Robert Hughes

            I have nothing to discuss with you; for the same reason I don’t consume MSM slop, pal

          • Bayard

            ‘ the reckless bravery of the non-combatant ‘

            To be fair, I didn’t make it up, I read in a story by Saki (H.H.Munro).

        • Bayard

          “Presumably you are equally critical of increasing defence spending in Sweden, Finland, Poland and the Baltic States?
          But perhaps, not critical of the enormous increases in Russian military and “security” spending?”

          The difference between Russia and the others is that Russia can afford to spend more on defence as it is a net exporter and the others can’t as they are net importers. It’s the difference between a rich person who buys a fancy car out of their yearly bonus and a poor person who buys one out of the money they need to feed their children.

          • JK redux

            “The difference between Russia and the others is that Russia can afford to spend more on defence as it is a net exporter and the others can’t as they are net importers.”

            That strikes me as a very weak argument for advocating against increasing military expenditure in Europe.

            After all, Russia while geographically vast has a modest population (less than France and Germany combined) and a miserable economy.

            In the end, democratic countries invest in defence in order to deter aggression.

            Countries with authoritarian regimes invest in their military to intimidate their neighbours…

          • Twirlip

            JK redux at 18:14:

            “In the end, democratic countries invest in defence in order to deter aggression.

            Countries with authoritarian regimes invest in their military to intimidate their neighbours…”

            Jesus Christ! What on earth can one say to that? Where does one even begin? I thought I was pretty ignorant (and so I tend to keep a modest silence), but this comment proudly displays a level of ignorance before which even I most bow.

            By the way, and on a more constructive note, thanks to Robert Hughes for eloquently expressing how I also feel about “society” and “things” every single freaking day now. It’s a pity someone saw fit to distract from that by repeating the kind of mindless media propaganda that contributes so much to that very feeling

          • JK redux

            “Jesus Christ! What on earth can one say to that? Where does one even begin? I thought I was pretty ignorant (and so I tend to keep a modest silence), but this comment proudly displays a level of ignorance before which even I most bow.”

            I thank the author of that comment but I’d be interested in a reasoned reply to my claim that “That strikes me as a very weak argument for advocating against increasing military expenditure in Europe.”..

            (“That” being the claim that Russia can afford to spend more on defence as it is a net exporter and the others can’t as they are net importers.)

          • Bayard

            “That strikes me as a very weak argument for advocating against increasing military expenditure in Europe”

            I am not sure that personal impression is a particularly strong point to argue from either. Some actual logic would be better together with facts, rather than easily disproved falsehoods and irrelevancies. So please explain why buying something you can neither afford nor prove that you need is not a bad idea.

          • Jen

            “… The difference between Russia and the others is that Russia can afford to spend more on defence as it is a net exporter and the others can’t as they are net importers …”

            Here, I’ll fix this statement and maybe the fix might enlighten JK redux a little.

            The difference between Russia and the others is that Russia can afford to spend more on defence as it is a net exporter of energy and the others can’t as they are net importers of energy…”

            If Russia is a net exporter of energy, that would imply that the Russians have sufficient quantities of energy (in the form of oil, natural gas, electricity, whatever) that help meet the RF’s own defence needs. The income earned from exporting energy can be apportioned amongst the RF’s most pressing needs, including defence if necessary. After all, the RF does have long land borders and considerable maritime territory to defend.

            The other northern European nations and the Baltic states are net importers of energy: that would imply their own energy resources are not enough even for their own essential needs. They’d have been better off not joining NATO and being compelled by that organisation’s heads to stir up trouble with a large neighbour they have land and/or sea borders with, and instead try to maintain peace and diplomacy.

        • AG

          MOD, I will make 2 comments addressing this and then maybe a 3rd one with links in the Ukraine Forum.

          ++++
          JK redux

          The second comment later:

          Now on public communication and propaganda in general:

          Mary Dejevsky, Moscow correspondent for THE TIMES 1988-1992 and after that working as a Russia expert for THE INDEPENDENT and THE GUARDIAN had a wise comment when talking to Ian Proud and Steve Jermy about Western reporting on Russia/Ukraine that you may want to take into consideration. She essentially says that Western/UK media rely entirely on what Ukrainians say in public and believe everything they say, and do not even listen to Russians. Even block Russians to not allow the occasion to arise to do just that. Which eventually leads to wishful thinking instead of proper and honest analysis and eventually results in a totally deformed perception of reality. And she calls this a huge a failure.

          Of course you can replace Ukraine with any other (Eastern) European country that is regarded as a Western ally and enemy of Russia, like the Baltics, Scandinavia or Poland.

          see: TC 12:00-14:20
          “A conversation with Mary Dejevsky and Commodore RN (Ret’d) Steve Jermy”
          https://thepeacemonger.substack.com/p/why-boris-johnson-must-answer-for

          • AG

            JK redux

            Why don´t you start studying the available and declassified national security records by the USSR and post-Soviet Russia and of the US:
            e.g.

            the US NSC (National Security Council) planning documents since 1950 / US national security doctrines and records since 1945 / such articles as “The End of MAD” from 2006 and 2010 by Keir Lieber and Daryl Press (see Belfer Center or „Foreign Affairs“) and that in conjunction with Ted Postols and Hans Kristensen´s publications about the “super-fuze” and expanded first strike capabilities (THE NATION 2015 and BULLETIN FOR THE ATOMIC SCIENTIST short summary: https://fas.org/publication/super-fuze/ ) – one major reason for renewed Russian rearming / US STRATEGIC COMMANDS´s views on winnable 2-front nuclear war

            US national security doctrines and assessments since 1991 / speeches and articles by Putin since 2000 / scholarship about RU asking for admission to NATO / NATO´s once secret Cold War planning documents such as MC 48 or MC 14/3 and their analyses by Marc Trachtenberg / CIA´s declassified documents about organizing terrorist activities in Eastern Europe during the Cold War and after / US plans to dismember Russia / Daniel Ellsberg´s scholarship about the CIA misconstrueing Soviet capabilities/ the declassified CIA and USSR records that confirm that the aggressive intentions of the USSR were totally exaggerated by the US agencies in public.

            Also there is not a single Russian document that demands that Russia deliberately attack Poland, the Baltics, Scandinavia, or that the destruction of Ukraine is a desired outcome.

            Just imagine all these strategies and goals were expressed by Russia directed against Europe and the US. The outrage in the West could be heard on the Moon.

            So this entire RU-bashing is 1) delusional 2) counter-factual 3) insanely biased.
            NATO is lying to us constantly re: Iran and Gaza. Why believe them re: Russia of all places?

            I will comment if/when links are in Forum.

          • JK redux

            AG
            November 10, 2026 at 20:08

            Hi AG.

            I enjoy debating with you but the mods prefer that we post on a topic rather than in reply to a poster.

            I wish you well..

          • AG

            JK redux

            Trying to respect the rules I merely wanted to hint at sources which I may do some other time via forum.
            After all there is not much discussion anyway. It´s more about studying certain records or not…
            That´s all. Not my intention to cause anyone trouble with MOD (Ministry of Defense – 😂).

      • Bayard

        “One imponderable is whether the current appalling state of * things * is a direct result of the abysmal calibre of the Political Class or if the latter is reflective of a deeper, broader malaise within the Collective Psyche of Humankind – specifically, the West/European Psyche, from which so much darkness and jaw-dropping stupidity is pouring.”

        My personal opinion is that we are now coming out of the shade cast by two world wars into the full glare of homo elitus unleashed from the constraints of decency put upon them by having to deal with a population that had gone to war and won, or at least not lost. This is the default state of homo elitus and something us Brits have not suffered from for over a hundred years, so everyone who remembers what they can be like is dead. In addition, the last time H elitus was so unconstrained was in the aftermath of a religious revival which also acted as a partial brake on naked greed and selfishness. To get a better parallel to modern times you have to go back two hundred years, to when powerful men drew up shopping lists of MPs and what they would have to be paid to vote for a particular motion and many of those MPs represented only a handful of voters in a “rotten borough”.

        • Robert Hughes

          Excellent points/comment, B. Yes, the Political System in the U.K has never been particularly admirable – despite the conceit of WM as the ‘ Mother ( fucker ) of all Parliaments. Not been that great ANYWHERE, really. Scandinavia of the post-war era up until say 20 years ago seemed to have achieved a productive balance of high wage, high productivity, generous *welfare* provision/spending policies ( fairly ) ‘ Liberal ‘ societal tolerances. They’ve all fucked-up now, with their uncritical adherence to the diktat of the EU/NATO Idiotocracy. Maybe not irretrievably, but if those countries continue with their blinkered short-termism, the damage may prove irreparable.

          It’s just that the consequences of the ‘ rotten borough ‘ era of UK/English Politics – whilst bad enough for the poor and populace generally, other than those with ‘ independent means ‘- were not planet threatening or anywhere near the scale of potential lethality as currently

        • Republicofscotland

          Bayard.

          Very true, we also have the likes of Cressida Dick and Tom Watson working for Palantir – and of course Dick ordered the hunting down of Charles de Menezes.

      • AG

        Robert Hughes

        “The main question is not, so much ‘ how did we get to this depressing pass? ‘ but ‘ how the fuck can we get out of it? ‘. As previously stated, I don’t see any other answer to the latter question than, REVOLT.”

        Maybe answering both questions – how we got here and how we could get out again – go back to the betrayal of organized labour as the most serious political entity we can form.

        As you suggest the attempts to explain the seemingly inexplicable – the current state – shift from day to day – but if one is looking at constants over long periods the demise of the labour unions – that is: membership and union culture – vs. the gig workers ideology of the late 90s – may be one major factor.

        As much as the social fabric had fallen apart so had the numbers of union membership decreased and the mass media world´s respect for it as well. All those happened in lockstep.

        So the problem has turned from a political to a cultural one.

        By that I mean the demise of the labour unions and labour as political force began in the 1970s, was exacerbated in the 1980s and was a given but unrecognized fact with the Schröder administration and the dismantling of the “Flächentarifvertrag” (a German system which put in place labour contracts and wages for entire industries that would apply everywhere in the country instead of individually negotiated from company to company – once among the most powerful tools of unions.)

        Once this political force was demolished by pushing back union influence that turned cultural i.e. it became a mass phenomenon.

        While “political” was an issue mostly of interest only to professionally organized labour – the hard core – once culturally implemented and a “fait accompli” it was then something generally understood and accepted as one of those alleged and false “facts of history” as if the demise of unions was natural which of course it was not.

        Instead the fall of labour after the end of the Cold War is one of the most decisive and least understood victories of capital since the rise of fascism in Europe in the 1930s.

        But once this “wisdom” is “culture” that makes it very difficult to return to a pre-madness state since culture is above all one of time passing.

        And as I like to say regarding Germany as the Third Reich – everything in place long enough legitimatizes itself by sheer duration. And the longer that duration the more difficult to reverse it.

        In a temporal sense of “quantity turns to quality”.

        ps: Richard Harris in a way reflected on this truism in his speculative dystopian novel FATHERLAND/VATERLAND.

        • Robert Hughes

          Thanks for this excellent comment and critique of ‘ where we’re at ‘ – and how we got here: with which I concur in it’s totality.

          Coming from a culture and household – Glasgow/Working Class – where Union membership was ( almost ) universal, some of my own uncles were Shop Stewards and ( as I’ve mentioned previously ) my grandfather was a Red Clydeside former Catholic Alter-boy turned fervent Communist ( before the excesses of Stalin occurred or were widely known ) I literally grew-up amidst Trade Unions/Trade Unionists; ergo have watched the withering away of the latter with increasing * depression *.

          Not that they – Unions – never made mistakes, got things wrong or were completely free of corruption, but it’s aften forgotten in the revisionist rush to make Individualism axiomatically ‘ better ‘ than Collectivism, more accurately….Socialism; it’s crucial to remember how much good they ( once ) did for the people who looked to them for protection and advocacy. They may have ‘ sold-out ‘ – but so have multitudes of those who would formerly have been under their aegis

          How does that supposed superiority ( of Individualism ) look now; has it brought about fairer, kinder more equitable, less violent Societies? I think we know the answer to that question

          • Republicofscotland

            Robert.

            What if I told Burnham has conducted secret polls on Scottish indy using taxpayers cash, but he’s has refused point blank to publish the results, Michael Gove done this once before as well, and even though a judge ordered him to publish the results Gove still didn’t do it.

            Of course it was Gove and Kate Forbes that devised the plans to force freeports on Scotland.

            https://nitter.netbub.com/LauraEWebsterr/status/2119369429272199513#m

            The second link is about taxpayers cash secretly given to private companies involved in Burnham’s authority in Manchester.

            https://nitter.netbub.com/feli_campbell/status/2119708766526452173#m

          • David Warristoncomforted

            The trade union bureaucracy was perfectly happy to eschew the ‘confrontational’ McGahey/Scargill approach as seen in its support for the 1984 Miners’ Strike which was lukewarm at best. The removal of Clause 4 from the Labour Party constitution followed soon after. Their vision was of a social democractic EEC where the interests of Labour and Capital could be resolved as part of some imaginary Nordic/West German sweetheart deal. They were going to wrongfoot Maggie by this clever ploy and get back to beer and sandwiches at Number 10.

            These were not mere mistakes: these were serious misjudgments rooted in self interest and called out as such at the time by trade union representatives ike myself. Rather like the USSR the British Trade Union movement, while attacked from outside, was destroyed from within.

          • Robert Hughes

            Aye, RoS, I seen that. Trouble for us is, even if those polls showed, eg 80% in favour of Independence the Keystone Swinney SNP would still defer to W.M for the * granting * of another Referendum.

            Nonetheless, the fact that they are not revealing the results of those polls strongly suggests they show a rise in YES support; we can be certain if they showed the opposite the results would be all over the MSM. We just need rid, desperately, of this collection of fakes, frauds, freaks n freeloaders: the can ‘ eff ‘ right off

          • AG

            Individualism is an interesting problem.
            In the educational system as far as I can judge teachers always tried to convey to children the value of solidarity.
            In fact it comes naturally. Until professional education sets in and the former ideals taught in school are slowly eroded.
            It´s in fact schizophrenic.
            We teach our children ideals which they have to ignore as adults if they wish to be successful later in life.
            So the problem is less educational but the economic system and its fascist rules that “welcomes” us all eventually.

          • Robert Hughes

            A.G

            Yes, it has always been very difficult to get a functional balance between the interests of the collective and the individual. A perennial problem, which nonetheless, has in certain times and places worked – with varying degrees of success and depending on how we define ‘ success ‘.

            Looking back it could be said the European/US Post WW2 Era was about as close as we’ve come to achieving a kind of balance of those two often conflicting interests. Wages and standards of living generally were – broadly – increasing, along with a loosening of the mores of the yet to be fully outgrown Victorian Age. In short, things/lives were improving for the majority of the people, a bit more freedom and opportunity, and a bit more cash to enjoy that freedom with. Then……………Thatcher. It’s hard to avoid the conclusion that it’s all been downhill since 1979; though that’s kinda arbitrary, depending on when we think the rot started, but something definitely changed significantly from that year onwards. The results are all around us

          • Bayard

            ” It’s hard to avoid the conclusion that it’s all been downhill since 1979; ”

            The oligarchical fightback began with the first Tory government after WWII. Just as the hottest part of the summer tends to come about three to four weeks after the longest day and the coldest part of the winter similarly after the shortest, the results took some time to show, but the regression was under way from that point.

          • AG

            Odd how public opinion shifted
            had everyone hated Thatcher back then as much as today…on the other hand she was only the odd package of a sinister content completely independent of her and if it hadn´t been MT it ´d have been someone else most likely. But I could be wrong.

          • Bayard

            “had everyone hated Thatcher back then as much as today…”

            I don’t think Thatcher was much less unpopular then as her memory is now. However you have to remember that the rot had set in to the post-war socialist state. There were definite problems that needed tackling. The trades unions were wielding far too much political power, all the nationalised industries, which had been nationalised so that the profits they made could benefit the country rather than the companies’ shareholders had long since stopped making profits and had become giant job-maintenance schemes. There was, of course, a lot wrong with Thatcher’s approach to doing this, part of which was driven by ideology part by greed and part by government incompetence and a complete ignorance of economics which persists until this day. Indeed, the success of any form of political theory, socialism, capitalism, communism lies how it manages the forces of greed and selfishness in practice, not in how it manages to running of the country in theory. In my experience capitalism manages greed by pretending it’s a virtue and socialism manages it by pretending that it only exists amongst the regulated and not amongst the regulators.

        • Tom Welsh

          A man’s rights rest in three boxes. The ballot box, jury box and the cartridge box.
          – Frederick Douglass (speech, November 15, 1867)

  • John Cleary

    “The three judges, including Lady Chief Justice Baroness Sue Carr, say a contempt case would be too complex for the court to manage, meaning it is not in the public interest to proceed.”

    What does “too complex” mean, I wonder?
    Can it possibly be true that these crimes by MI5 are sheltered under the royal prerogative?
    Is it possible that, far from having no powers at all, King Charles has the power to dissuade the courts?
    Is it possible that King Charles in fact has unlimited powers, but employs those unlimited powers to conceal what he is doing?
    Is it possible that a protection racket is operating at the highest levels?

    • Tom Welsh

      “What does “too complex” mean, I wonder?”

      Maybe channelling Clint Eastwood as Harry Callaghan:

      “A woman’s got to know her limitations”. Of course one might wonder why a simpleton would be placed in her position.

  • Goose

    Little faith in Britain’s judiciary. They all share the same views , mix in the same circles. Take this today :

    “Brand barrister’s cross-examination of victims shocking and depressing, says Labour deputy” – Guardian

    Er…the man was fighting for his life, what does she expect his barrister to do?

    The media bias was appalling in this case ; public and institutional pressure is always to unconditionally believe accusers leading to a presumption of guilt before a trial even begins. High-profile public exposure undoubtedly causes irreversible reputational and professional damage, regardless of the legal outcome.

    On the low thresholds for investigations: investigations proceed based entirely on testimonial evidence without corroborating physical forensics, which leaves the system vulnerable to false or weaponised allegations.

    On the anonymity disparity : In the UK, complainants of sexual offences are granted lifelong anonymity, whereas the accused is publicly named upon being charged. This asymmetry creates an unfair power imbalance that permanently stigmatises an individual who is supposedly legally presumed innocent.

    Who would want to be a celebrity today? And the only people in public life, will be those who’ve never said or done anything remotely controversial

      • David Warristoncomforted

        It’s hard to believe many of the major rock stars of the 1960s behaved much differently than Russell Brand or their contemporary Jimmy Savile. Some of them have since been knighted and are still revered on Google links so I suppose they are regarded as untouchable.

        The most appalling eploitation of the poorer members of society and child grooming is of course economic but that has long been normalised. Throwing the masses an occasional piece of meat in the form of some squalid, barely talented ccelebrity seems to be working fairly well so far.

          • Goose

            @all

            Diana was 16, Charles was 29, when they first met in November 1977.

            Somehow don’t think the establishment or corporate media are going to be claiming she was groomed, do you?

          • Goose

            cont..

            I remember army recruiters regularly coming to school to promote a career in the armed forces to pre-16s.The govt won’t even allow them to view social media, but they’re apparently old enough to know they want to risk their lives in the army?

            You can join aged 16 and be at the front, in a conflict, risking serious injury, PTSD or death, by the age of 18. Yet that’s classed as an honourable career path, by the same political class who are currently obsessing by age disparities between celebs and their fans. How is army recruitment morally better? For if people couldn’t join the armed forces, until say 21-years of age, quite a few may never have joined who did suffer injury or death?

          • Stevie Boy

            And, I believe it used to be the case that judges sentencing young offenders would offer them the choice of Army or jail ?

  • Allan Howard

    Given the outcome of the mid-term elections one does wonder how Hakeem Jeffries is being touted as the next speaker/leader of the House.especiallygiven his fervent support for Israel In a vid posted a couple of days ago Jimmy Dore shows a clip of Jeffries spouting ‘Israel today, Israel tomorrow, Israel forever’:

    Progressives Betray Voters & Back Rabid Zionist for Speaker

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9SP51bP9XSU (19.05)

    No need to watch all of it, and the first few minutes will suffice. But what the fuck is it about Israel that gets these people so animated….oh right, the dosh of course. Also came across this article on Code Pink by Medea Benjamin, posted yesterday:

    10 Reasons Hakeem Jeffries Should Not Be the Next Speaker of the House

    https://www.codepink.org/10_reasons_jeffries

    There’s a link to a petition at the end which over a million people have already signed, and it’s not restricted to just the US. As Medea says at the end of the article:

    Voters did not reject Republican extremism just to see Democratic leaders continue pouring billions into wars and corporate interests while families struggle to afford housing, healthcare, and basic necessities.

    And the grassroots are making their voices heard. In just a few days, more than one million people have signed a petition demanding new leadership. Congressional offices are being inundated with calls, and several incoming Democrats—including Melat Kiros, Claire Valdez, Chris Rabb, and Adam Hamawy—are withholding support for Jeffries.

    The Speaker of the House holds enormous power. That power can be used to confront the military-industrial complex, challenge corporate money and AIPAC, stand up for immigrants, and put human needs ahead of endless wars. Or it can be used to protect the very system that has brought us to this crisis.

    • zoot

      Jeffries and Schumer both have significantly lower approval ratings than Donald Trump (18% and 13% respectively, compared to Trump’s 33%, according to a November NBC News poll).

      The fact the ‘Democratic’ party is still going to install them as the leaders of Congress lends further credence to suggestions that America is not a democracy in any meaningful sense, but a dictatorship where both parties serve capital, war and genocide.

    • Jack

      And just look at how close the Democrats (well some of them) became to impeach Hagseth, but of course – 11 Democrats did not even show up for the vote which caused the vote to fail.
      So many corrupt, gatekeeping israel-firsters in the DNC making a geunine “Blue-Wave”-change impossible.

  • Ewan2

    Should anyone need reminding of the reasons for 4000 arrests:

    BBC article: Israeli forces kill Palestinian boy, Health Ministry says.

    ” The Israel military says sources identified ” several terrorists who intended to throw stones”….. The soldiers fired towards them ” to remove the threat”

    The terrorist was 14.

    • Heterodox

      /Sarc on

      To be fair, terrorists (of any age) intending to throw stones are far more dangerous than terrorists waving placards.

      Ergo, the proportionality of response is more or less in the right balance:

      Kill the 14 year terrorist who has stone-throwing intentions, whereas merely imprison (for up to 14 years) the placard-waving terrorist

      Sarc off/

      • Bayard

        Most placards are mounted on a stick and that stick could used to injure or even kill someone, so placard wavers should be shot, too. In any case, how do the authorities know that those carrying placards, even ones without are stick, don’t have a stone in their pocket or on the ground next to them and aren’t potential stone throwers, too? Safest to shoot the lot.

        • Tom Welsh

          Many of them wear ties, belts, or even long socks that could easily be used to strangle people.

          Something that is sadly missing from our political life is loud, derisive laughter. We should bring it back.

          Although there have been several years for people to laugh at the Novichok story, and very few have done so. Perhaps it’s a lost cause.

    • Allan Howard

      Apparently trade from illegal settlements in the West Bank to the EU is worth up to $400 million a year. And Holland appears to have gone somewhat further than Burnham and Milliband:

      Netherlands protesters oppose trade with Israeli settlements as distribution centre challenges ban

      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wmNb0okSHnI (Al Jazeera 2:34, posted 2 months ago)

      PS Apparently there were demos all across Holland a year ago (bearing in mind that ‘1 year’ on youtube could be anywhere between a year and two years ago…. but looking through the vids there’s been quite a lot happening over there))

      • Republicofscotland

        Western banks/institutions finance the building of illegal settlements in Gaza and the West Bank.

        “The United Kingdom awarded 10.7 million pounds ($14.4m) in new public contracts to firms with links to illegal Israeli settlements in the occupied West Bank, despite British government pledges to punish companies that profit from settlement activity, an Al Jazeera investigation reveals.”

        https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2026/11/10/firms-tied-to-west-bank-settlements-win-15m-uk-deals-despite-sanctions

        • Clark

          Burnham’s government has also contracted Boston Consulting Group BCG for its so called “Ten Year Plan”. BCG drew up the “Gaza Riviera” plan that Trump boasted about, working with Blair’s foundation, and is associated with the so-called “Gaza Humanitarian Foundation” that was murdering Gazans at their so-called food distribution points. Zack Polanski has called out Burnham on the BCG contract; video at this link:

          https://skwawkbox.org/2026/11/10/watch-polanski-on-burnhams-hypocritical-use-of-genocide-linked-firm/

          • nevermind

            Thanks for that link Clark. Its about time Burnham gets hauled over the coals.
            Adrian Ramsays critic and open opposition to the Greens policy is sadly misplaced.
            Did not watch the video as I do not allow instagram or google boss me about.
            Take care

          • Republicofscotland

            Yes that’s right.

            Below Polanski calls Labour out.

            https://nitter.click/ZackPolanski/status/2120067844683481412#m

            Also the Greens stance on Zionism appears to be spreading.

            “The Green Party of the United States has adopted Proposal 1332, “Zionism Is Racism: Green Party Opposition to Zionism and Support for Palestinian Liberation.” Voting closed at midnight Pacific time on November 8, 2026, and the proposal page on the party voting site now reads Closed, Adopted. The result was announced on November 9.

            The final count, from the official Green Party voting results page, was 77 Yes, 4 No, and 4 abstentions, with 85 votes cast from 35 states and caucuses. The page records the presence quorum as 29, two thirds of 43 active accredited states and caucuses, and the consensus quorum as 41, a majority of the 81 Yes and No votes. It cleared both, and the result date shown on the page is November 9, 2026.”

            https://dearbornblog.com/2026/11/09/green-party-us-declares-zionism-is-racism/

          • Stevie Boy

            Yep. These bastards are really sickening. There is no hope for this country whilst this lot have power.

          • Republicofscotland

            “Nothing brings British politicians (and journalists) together ”

            Zoot.

            Unless of course its about Remembrance Sunday and the poppy, the below seems appropriate with regards to the date – the SAS terrorist out fit has been rumbled.

            “An inquiry into UK special forces operations in Afghanistan has released photos described as “essential evidence”, showing soldiers could have executed unarmed people lying asleep.

            For the first time, the inquiry has made public photos taken of the deceased, across two SAS operations, that show multiple individuals lying in bed with shots to the head.”

            https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cm20w093y3gqo

          • zoot

            ‘We will remember them’ ..

            .. by committing a racist genocide and forgetting every single lesson from both World Wars.

          • Tom Welsh

            zoot, it’s true: Zionism is not racism. It’s much, much worse. Racism consists merely of thinking people of different origins are inferior, superior, whatever. Zionism consists of believing that all non-Jews are “lower than animals”, soulless, and fair game for extermination. Then setting out to exterminate them.

          • zoot

            Tom,

            Indeed. The last 3 years have proven that beyond a shadow of a doubt. The Greens’ motion would probably have resonated much more widely and deeply if it had stated that zionism is inherently *genocidally* racist.

            It’s been the relentless, psychopathic, no-boundaries, pitiless murderousness of Israelis that has shaken people the most (outside political and media circles).

          • Brian Red

            “The Greens’ motion would probably have resonated much more widely and deeply if it had stated that zionism is inherently *genocidally* racist”

            For example with reference to eschatology in the Jewish religion, which is very different indeed from eschatology in Christianity and Islam.

            The princely Al Jazeera has published this “opinion piece” by a pillock at Chatham House who scribbles that Zionism definitely isn’t racist, oh no sir, it absolutely isn’t, and anyone who thinks so is probably motivated by hostility to the settler state and is in any case undermining the Palestinian cause:

            https://www.aljazeera.com/opinions/2026/10/7/the-uk-greens-are-wrong-zionism-is-not-racism

            The editors at Al Jazeera don’t want to lose too much of their market, mind. They say there’s room for two sides on the issue.

          • Brian Red

            @zoot – members of the City of Westminster Council demonstrating they’ll all pull together for the settler state may well be connected with the plan to build a Jewish holocaust memorial centre in Victoria Palace Gardens next to the Houses of Parliament – which is surely far more than a plan to erect a building with some exhibits and information boards in it, staffed by museum employees working 9 to 5.

            Strangely no settler authority seems to be in favour of a building in Quds to commemorate the British POWs murdered by the Japanese in the same war.

          • zoot

            Brian,

            It’s surprising they haven’t done that already and mandated annual visits by every school in the country. It is coming, for sure.

            Frightening who al-Jazeera chose to write about the Greens’ motion. Like a parody of a Telegraph or Jerusalem Post columnist. Qatar is a slave state in more ways than one.

  • Republicofscotland

    So as far as I make out – there’s absolutely not one shred of evidence that Jenson Huang’s Chinese squeeze is a Chinese spy, Huang is the top man at Nvidia Chips, which is HQ’d in the USA – already the companies shares are in freefall – as the board decides whether or not to remove Huang from his position.

    The reason for removing Huang – and claiming that his squeeze is a Chinese spy becomes a bit more apparent when you realise that important Russian weaponry uses Nvidia chips to function, China also uses the chips – but not as widespread as Russia does.

    We can see where this is going especially with regards to Russia.

    Update Huang has stood down as president and CEO of the company. (BBC)

    • Stevie Boy

      “It is now clear that Jensen is the target of a conspiracy …
      The conspiracy to oust Jensen Huang serves several purposes –
      – Take over control of Nvidia, the single most important AI company in the world
      – Release liquidity for the upcoming Anthropic IPO later this month
      – Stink up Xi-Trump meeting in Shenzhen
      – Tighten chip export ban further
      – Tee up banning Chinese open AI
      – Ensure closer tech alignment with government priorities – don’t cross the line”
      https://huabinoliver.substack.com/p/more-with-jensen

      • Republicofscotland

        I read today that Netanyahu said a couple of years back that Israel will be the leader in AI, three jooos are currently vying for Huang’s position as CEO – and a Senate hearing is to be called to delve deeper into what happened at Nvidia.

        As you rightly say its a scam to oust Huang – and replace him with some sort of puppet CEO – who’ll make sure Nvidia chips, don’t go to countries that Washington doesn’t want them to go to.

1 2