Posts


Newsnight Trash Scotland

Newsnight held an item on Scottish independence last night in which the BBC threw away any pretence at objectivity. Allegedly investigating the practicalities of independence, it ran a series of interviews with diehard unionist figures, mostly openly New Labour. The only “expert” interviewed on the economy stated that nobody could support an independent Scotland on the grounds they would be economically better off. Another “expert” opined that an independent Scotland may be kicked out of the EU, while a former New Labour Lord Provost of Glasgow said it was laughable that a country the size of Scotland could have its own army, navy and coastguard [presumably Norway, Sweden, Denmark, Finland, Ireland and Portugal don’t, then].

The point is that these were not presented as pro-union views, but as “expert analysis” of the practicalities. Jeremy Paxman then tried but failed to intimidate Nicola Sturgeon, and went through a pantomime of body language and facial expression at the idea that Scotland may leave NATO and eventually get rid of the pound sterling.

The good news is that propaganda as bad and blatant as this has little effect – and indeed is counterproductive for those promoting it – in a situation where people do have access to alternative sources of information. Scotland is not Uzbekistan. A great many Scots will have watched Newsnight last night, and realised that the BBC think we are stupid.

View with comments

How Did You Get Here?

About 12% of those who arrive on this site, so so as a result of a search. The majority come via links from other sites, and about 25% come direct by entering this site on their navigation bar. My statcounter covers the last 5,000 visitors. Of those among that 5,000 who came via a search engine, this is what they were looking for:

273 43.47% craig murray
18 2.87% craigmurray
9 1.43% i hate london
4 0.64% spanking
4 0.64% craigmurrey
4 0.64% tony baldry mp
4 0.64% tavish scott decent
3 0.48% should david laws have resigned ?
3 0.48% alisher usmanov criminal
3 0.48% “craig murray”
3 0.48% site:craigmurray.org.uk middleton africa
3 0.48% ivory coast craig murray
3 0.48% the duchess historical accuracy
3 0.48% craig murray blog
3 0.48% craig murray on bahrain
3 0.48% Paul AFOKO
3 0.48% ALISHER USMANOV jewish
2 0.32% palestinian greek orthodox christians
2 0.32% khandiza mine
2 0.32% islam karimov crimes
2 0.32% karimova
2 0.32% Clintons and the King of Bahrain
2 0.32% usmanov
2 0.32% site:craigmurray.org.uk middleton
2 0.32% did tessa jowell know her husband was corrupt
2 0.32% Mr. David Craig
2 0.32% craig murray, osama bin laden
2 0.32% nadira
2 0.32% BT GROUP PLC DIRECT DEBIT
2 0.32% john milligan
2 0.32% bahrain 47 doctors and nurses
2 0.32% http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm/cmsecret/ 2009
2 0.32% The edge of darkness + japan nuclear
2 0.32% craig murray fort william
2 0.32% FCO hague madagascar
2 0.32% ryan giggs
2 0.32% script +ian Tomlinson response ‘incredibly slow’ bbc
2 0.32% craig murray weblog
2 0.32% henry cooper grocer
2 0.32% labour postal voting
2 0.32% Uk AV referendum No campaign Nick Clegg leaflet
2 0.32% farmers seeds terchnically illegal
2 0.32% doune the rabbit hole 2010
2 0.32% CRAIG MURRAY BLOGSPOT
2 0.32% “i hate london”
2 0.32% scottish independence speech
2 0.32% nathaniel rothschild
2 0.32% david weill
2 0.32% was carol caplin a mossad agent
1 0.16% bahrain not allowing saudi civilians to enter their country
1 0.16% george orwell quote in times of universal deceit
1 0.16% the vagrancy act 1824
1 0.16% гулнара каримова
1 0.16% Natalia Antaleva
1 0.16% Craig Murray British ambassador Uzbekistan boiled alive
1 0.16% scottish nationalists immigration
1 0.16% gaza youth breaks out
1 0.16% snp blog
1 0.16% The in war libya illegal war?
1 0.16% Osh Kyrgyzstan
1 0.16% daily mail archive lobby lud
1 0.16% murray blackburn
1 0.16% evidence mi6 complicit in torture
1 0.16% Ryan Giggs super in junction
1 0.16% man resemblin Mohamed Alfaed at the royal wedding
1 0.16% Jahongir Sidikov
1 0.16% “jerry gobshite sadowitz”
1 0.16% meteor over kent
1 0.16% “Suhayl Saadi” “neil barker”
1 0.16% manningham councillors 2002
1 0.16% israel attack on turkish flotilla-legal aspects
1 0.16% this is crazy. Israel is the superpower of the Middle East, but because we still think we’re the Jew
1 0.16% craig murray org uk
1 0.16% toby young arsehole
1 0.16% timothy kelly irish rich list 2011
1 0.16% ian tomlinson drunk?
1 0.16% “massacre of children” Flanders “world war 1”
1 0.16% bt internet total broadband 1 cancel contract
1 0.16% infidelity and bipolar disorder
1 0.16% margaret beckett
1 0.16% sir michael wright coroner
1 0.16% bt head office phone number 2011
1 0.16% awa pemsina song
1 0.16% May U.K. commentary on Libya no fly zone during May 2011
1 0.16% craig schmidt its a lovely war
1 0.16% jerome a paris
1 0.16% sam adams award
1 0.16% hossein turner
1 0.16% bahrain students UK
1 0.16% craig murray ambassador
1 0.16% david trimble bloody sunday
1 0.16% baharain crimes against humanity
1 0.16% incapable of voting tory
1 0.16% David Tennant Murder in Samarkand
1 0.16% ryan giggs super junction
1 0.16% the catholic orangeman togo
1 0.16% colin reynolds fco
1 0.16% craig mrray
1 0.16% does dale Steyn chuck it
1 0.16% How to Argue Against Torture chazelle response
1 0.16% 26 october 2006 bbc uncivilized minority in uk
1 0.16% laden again silverstein residence
1 0.16% royal garden party 2009
1 0.16% Ambassador to Yemen, John Craig
1 0.16% hassan fattah national craig editorial problem
1 0.16% craig murray sex offender
1 0.16% muzafar avazov pictures
1 0.16% snp corporation tax policy
1 0.16% craid murray
1 0.16% snp barnett formula
1 0.16% failed asylum seekers returning to uzbekistan
1 0.16% ian dale jew
1 0.16% david laws + expenses + blog
1 0.16% I despise london
1 0.16% “st andrews” history of art posh
1 0.16% https://www.craigmurray.org.uk/
1 0.16% I hate London trains
1 0.16% רוטשילד
1 0.16% snp overall majority
1 0.16% sting Uzbekistan
1 0.16% losing afghanistan
1 0.16% “craig murray” + oxus
1 0.16% 2212432.html
1 0.16% what is a pint of heavy scotland
1 0.16% david warren oxford
1 0.16% hydrocarbon boundaries transferred to england from scotland
1 0.16% euro porn
1 0.16% zbiginiew brysinski
1 0.16% Craig a Murray contact
1 0.16% torture results
1 0.16% sad refrain from bahrain
1 0.16% osh kyrgyzstan blog
1 0.16% the Ian tomlinson case 25th march- 11th may 2011 blogs
1 0.16% tim groves 9-11 truth
1 0.16% soas reputation in the US
1 0.16% bt problems april 22nd 2011
1 0.16% practical scotland independence
1 0.16% catholic orangemen of togo
1 0.16% video ian tomlinson american
1 0.16% +discuss the ethics issues identified in silverstein’s report
1 0.16% do you have to be rich to get into st andrews
1 0.16% karimov daughter
1 0.16% sir michael wright
1 0.16% vince cable climate change
1 0.16% mi6 + pauline neville-jones
1 0.16% tony baldry
1 0.16% i hate london on sundays
1 0.16% overworked and the law
1 0.16% interpal facebook
1 0.16% michael foot
1 0.16% murder in samarkand
1 0.16% +”Chris Dooley” CIA
1 0.16% “clayton burns”
1 0.16% Craig Murray Nadira
1 0.16% MI6 strawman
1 0.16% der spiegel
1 0.16% are there no liberals with any guts? UK
1 0.16% gafur rakhimov
1 0.16% “craig murray” + oxus gold
1 0.16% bloggs+giggs
1 0.16% craig from shameless
1 0.16% What arguments could human geographers make against the presence of British troops in Afghanistan?
1 0.16% stupid white women
1 0.16% post a comment site:www.craigmurray.org.uk
1 0.16% st andrews uni rich list
1 0.16% fco cuts
1 0.16% Patrick Wintour
1 0.16% regional list how are candidates selected ams
1 0.16% why can’t panish cambodia flag vessel
1 0.16% http://www.craigmurray.co.uk/
1 0.16% university privatisation
1 0.16% St Andrews uni for the rich??
1 0.16% met police dumbing down thick arrogant stupid
1 0.16% mi6 afghanistan
1 0.16% China continues its aggressive pursuit of Africa’s resources
1 0.16% https://www.craigmurray.org.uk/index.html
1 0.16% jimdevine.org
1 0.16% Timothy Hampton
1 0.16% doune the rabbit hole festival
1 0.16% kincora richard craig
1 0.16% craig urray
1 0.16% cupar protest anti-semitism
1 0.16% craig murray twitter
1 0.16% kay burley george pascoe watson
1 0.16% who can have nuclear weapons
1 0.16% the spectator magazine Benazir Bhutto osama bin laden
1 0.16% muhammad solih abutov
1 0.16% camberley mosque
1 0.16% which 2 palestinian parties called a halt to hostilities at a meeting in cairo this wk and were prom
1 0.16% togo censorship
1 0.16% ian tomlinson police blog
1 0.16% alisher usmanov jew
1 0.16% Nadine Dorries Pictures
1 0.16% nuclear power is silly
1 0.16% haynau incident
1 0.16% craigmurray.org.uk
1 0.16% BBC Panorama – the price of blood transcript 2006
1 0.16% kafkaesque system
1 0.16% bipolar infidelity
1 0.16% Jack Straw is a twat
1 0.16% vince cable is what position in the US
1 0.16% strange events
1 0.16% detained fast track
1 0.16% in a CIF contract the documents should be rejected by the principal on their face value murray
1 0.16% afghanistan war in archive
1 0.16% Ayesha Hazarika
1 0.16% zakhem
1 0.16% us green light for saudi action in bahrain
1 0.16% st andrews university palestinian student
1 0.16% paul afoko ghana
1 0.16% documentaries from gaza
1 0.16% susan hyland fco
1 0.16% ian tomlinson police lie again
1 0.16% nasser while burns roams
1 0.16% craig interview
1 0.16% complaint about bt charging me whilst they are still trying to fix my phone as it is not working
1 0.16% hidden behind a thin veil
1 0.16% Henry Jackson Society Douglas Murray
1 0.16% ian tomlinson blog
1 0.16% duncan marine group’s managing director in sierra leone
1 0.16% Craig Murray, the British ambassador to Uzbekistan,
1 0.16% whistleblowersknowledge of planned events
1 0.16% Alisher Usmanov
1 0.16% port of ramsgate, girl with black hair
1 0.16% craig murray arab school oxford university jack straw wife
1 0.16% criminal investigation craig
1 0.16% craig murray law
1 0.16% Murder in Samarkand download
1 0.16% is st andrews university good
1 0.16% barcelona children tie
1 0.16% “they thought they were free” family guide
1 0.16% eustace mullins mp3 archives
1 0.16% craig murray whistleblower
1 0.16% Frank Goebbels Gardner
1 0.16% sex and bicycles
1 0.16% simon gass
1 0.16% vince cable scandal 2011
1 0.16% craig j murray dunfermline facebook
1 0.16% does the social class matters
1 0.16% uk wanted model blog
1 0.16% paul alexander bergne
1 0.16% what do both sources say about the origin of human evil, and about the best means of preventing or s
1 0.16% soas reputation
1 0.16% www.craigmurray.org.uk
1 0.16% “they thought they were free” summary
1 0.16% craig murra
1 0.16% uzbekistan tashkent gay
1 0.16% pint of heavy scotland
1 0.16% greek anti-semetism
1 0.16% bhutto said omar
1 0.16% When Was The President Of Ghana Elected?
1 0.16% rory stewart mi6
1 0.16% olga guerin uk
1 0.16% is alisher usmanov a jewish
1 0.16% murrary 2010 trolls
1 0.16% The Catholic Orangmen of Togo
1 0.16% do not adjust your set
1 0.16% PURALIA ARMS DROP CASE+WIKI LEAKS
1 0.16% AJ Hill court case 9th May 2011
1 0.16% Sir Michael Wood Israel
1 0.16% gulnara karimova
1 0.16% rakeesh saxena
1 0.16% labour party evil
1 0.16% site:craigmurray.org.uk middleton
1 0.16% Tessa Jowell expenses
1 0.16% port of ramsgate blog
1 0.16% Turnr contemporary is crap

View with comments

Breath of Fresh Air

I am in person a notably happy, I hope humorous chap, whereas this blog tends to be a relentless criticism of those who wield power. It makes a change, therefore, to note a positive development. Vestas have announced plans to open a wind turbine plant near Sheerness in Kent, bringing 2,000 much needed jobs to the area. The move is dependent, however, on the government setting out a secure long term policy framework for the development of renewable energy in this country.

That is something to which Energy Secretary Chris Huhne is genuinely wedded, and this move by Vestas will strengthen his hand against the coalition Tories and their love of oil and nuclear. Vestas deserve criticism for their fickleness, with this coming just three years after the closure of their Isle of Wight manufacturing facility, but that event was also a stunning indictment of New Labour’s lack of genuine belief in renewable energy and lack of genuine commitment to UK manufacturing industry.

View with comments

Dodging the Jackboot

The existence of super injunctions is itself an indefensible restriction on freedom. The existence of gagging orders which are themselves secret is truly sinister. It also protects only the guilty – while your prostitute shagging footballer can get it hushed up “to protect his family”, it is precisely because the things are secret that they can be attributed wrongly to innocent (in this context) people like Jemima Khan.

But we should view with deep distrust the news that the Cabinet is going to discuss reform of the law, which will include regulation of social media. This is the same Cabinet which is looking to introduce a special track university entry for the British super-rich, who will be exempt from quotas and admissions competition if they pay large sums of dosh up front. There is no doubt whose interest the Cabinet will be looking to promote if they propose legislation which covers the ability to publish information about the rich and powerful.

The good news is, that in this new age of information technology, I am confident the judges and politicians will continue to be shown to be foolish by popular circumvention of whatever clumsy mechanism they seek to intrude in the path of electronic communication.

View with comments

No End To Afghan War

A friend still in a senior position in the FCO has informed me there will be no substantive British withdrawal from Afghanistan until 2015 at the earliest. According to a strategy paper classified Secret, carried out for the Cabinet overseas and defence committee, it is essential to retain Karzai in power until his term in office ends, to restore stability to the country. While that is official paper speak, my friend (who is not enamoured of this policy) says that the real thinking is that if Karzai falls from power after our withdrawal, we will be seen to have “Lost” the war, while the overriding aim in Whitehall and in Washington is to get out in circumstances in which we can claim victory.

The official judgement is that the loyalty of Afghan government forces is at best dubious, while they remain riven by ethnic dissension and still contain a huge over-representation of Tajiks and Uzbeks, especially at officer level. In the FCO’s view, Karzai would not last for days if NATO forces withdrew and indeed would flee very quickly rather than try to retain power. He is just not interested in being in Afghanistan without a US army to sustain his looting. That rather knocks on the head the various efforts we have made for a negotiated settlement, for which we regard Karzai remaining in power as an essential outcome.

Karzai’s predecessors as modern Afghan rulers installed by foreign invaders – Shah Shujah by the British and Dr Najibullah by the Soviets – were both murdered once their sponsors left.

The coalition government in the UK apparently believes that the sharp reduction in the casualty rate among UK forces has removed public pressure for an earlier withdrawal. The Obama administration has give firm assurances to Karzai that a high level US and NATO military occupation will remain in place until after the end of his term of office.

View with comments

SNP Headed For Overall Majority

It is 5.30 am and I haven’t been to bed. I intended to watch the first few results from the elections and to turn in around 2 am, but the first Scottish results were so riveting, I have been unable even to think of leaving. And just a moment ago “SNP gain Paisley” flashed up. Paisley!!

The SNP so far have won 28 constituencies on the first past the post part of the election, with many still to come. Compared to seven of these last time. If this were a first past the post election, the SNP would have a thumping absolute majority. But I reckon the regional lists wil still result in an overall majority to the SNP. As Scottish independence remains the practical political goal to which I am most attached, I am absolutely delighted.

Alex Salmond has already indicated that he will use his mandate to push for more powers for the Scottish parliament – most crucially, the power to borrow money so Scotland can run a more Keynsian economic policy, and the power to vary corporation tax. These will be resisted by the Tories, which will set up precisely the confrontation needed over the next four years to prepare for a referendum on independence.

I vote Lib Dem when in England and SNP in Scotland. I am sorry in a sense to see the collapse of the Lib Dem vote in Scotland, not least because Tavish Scott is a very decent person and a genuine liberal. But the atavistic unionism of the Scottish Lib Dems in recent years deserves a kicking, not least because it is the precise opposite of the party’s historical and philosophical roots, and would have Gladstone and Rosebery spinning in their graves. Any real Liberal in Scotland in 2011 should want Scottish independence, and it was only recently in my adult life that the view started to be taken that belief in Scottish independence is incompatible with being a Liberal Democrat.

That Liberals were prepared in Scotland to spend years in coalition with war criminals, but would not enter a coalition with the SNP because of opposition to letting people have a referendum on independence, was so stupid and illiberal, that bluntly the Scottish Lib Dems deserved their virtual annihilation.

New Labour will get an enormous raft of MSPs on the regional list system, having lost 75% of their constituency MSPs. By and large these list candidates are not the same people as the defeated New Labour MSPs. Amazingly, they are on the whole even less talented than the obnoxious numpties the electorate have just sent packing. There is not going to be any effective opposition in the new Scottish parliament, and I hope that the horrible regional list system at least throws up some greens and independents to liven things up,

View with comments

FCO Finally Admits I Was Innocent

fcomurray2

fcomurray1

(You need to click on fcomurray1, and then on the lower smallcase fcomurray1 that will appear again, and then repeat the process with fcomurray2. Hopefully I might find a more elegant way later.)

The Foreign and Commonwealth Office has, for the first time, admitted I was cleared on all 19 charges they laid against me, except for the Kafkaesque charge of talking about the charges against me in order to prepare a defence.

However the letter from Lord Howell claims – falsely, as far as I am aware – “that the disciplinary allegations taken by the FCO in Craig Murray’s case related first to complaints made about him by members of his staff”. In the course of a four month investigation under suspension, I was only ever shown a single complaint about me by members of my staff. This consisted of a signed statement by a small group of staff in the visa saction, to the effect that on a named morning I had told them I had a hangover.

This statement was not the source of the allegation, but rather obtained after the allegation that I was an alcoholic had been made by the FCO. Every single member of my staff was called in and asked if they had ever seen me drunk. That statement, that I once said that I had a hangover, was the sole result of this fishing expedition. I was never shown any staff statement on any other allegation, including the astounding allegation of sex for visas, and as these were all dropped for lack of evidence I presume there were no such statements. Lord Howell is telling an untruth, though I fully expect as a result of being lied to by his civil servants.

On the other disciplinary count – that of unauthorised disclosure to the media – relates to my appearance on the Today programme etc AFTER I had told the FCO I was leaving the service, so is hardly germane. Jack Straw added that line to parliament in order to say I had not resolved all charges against me. Straw had fudged this to appear still to refer to the sexual charges.

Of course, what Lord Howell fails completely to mention is, that these eighteen disciplinary charges miraculously appeared from nowhere immediately after I became the only UK civil servant to enter a written objection to our complicity in torture in the War on Terror.

What sickens me most about this in Lord Howell’s letter is the FCO’s claim to have cleared itself in its own investigation of having made the allegations against me “maliciously or in bad faith”.

Do they really expect anybody to believe that you can make eighteen serious allegations against somebody, every one of which turns out to be untrue, in good faith?

I am very grateful indeed to Nigel Jones for his persistence in winning at least this much acknowledgement of my innocence from the FCO, after eight years in which they have systematically blackened my name. I am sorry that Lord Howell can’t tell Nigel Jones from Digby Jones!

View with comments

Death of Alexander Burnes

Bombay Times, April 23 1842 Deposition of Bowh Singh, lately a Chuprasse in Sir Alexander’s service

“Sir Alexander Burnes was duly informed by his Afghan servants, the day previous to his murder, that there was a stir in the city, and that, if he remained in it, his life would be in danger; they told him that he had better go to the cantonments; this he declined doing, giving as his reason that the Afghans never suffered any injury from him, but on the contrary he had dome much for them, and he was quite sure they would never injure him.

On the day of the murder, as early as three o’clock in the morning, a cossid came to me, on duty outside; he said “Go and inform your master immediately that there is a tumult in the city, and that the merchants are removing their goods and valuables from the shops.” I knew what my master had said on this subject the day before, so I did not waken him, but put on my chupras and went to the char choukh. Here I met the wuzeer, Nazamat Dowlah, going towards my master’s house; I immediately turned with him, and on our arrival awoke him, when my master dressed quickly, and went to the wuzeer, and talked with him some time. The wuzeer endeavoured to induce him to go immediately into cantonments, assuring him that it was not safe to remain in the city; he, however, persisted in remaining, saying: “If I go, the Afghans will say I was afraid, and ran away.”

He however sent a note to Sir W. Macnaghten, by Wallee Mahomed.

A chobar came from the king to call the wuzeer, who asked and obtained permission to stay at the door; the wuzeer said to Sir Alexander Burnes, “Why, you see already that some of Ameen oola Khan’s people have collected to attack you; if you will allow me I shall disperse them.”

He (Sir A Burnes) said, “No, the King sent for [you] to go to him without delay.”

The wuzeer accordingly mounted his horse, and went away. The gates were then closed, and then in a little time surrounded by Ameen oola Khan and his rabble. Hydur Khan, the late kotwal of the city, whom Sir Alexander Burnes had turned out of office, brought fuel from the human on the opposite side of the street, and set fire to the gates.

The wuzeer shortly returned from the Bala Hissar, with one of the king’s pultuns, on seeing the gates on fire, and an immense crowd about, he took it apparently for granted that Sir A Burnes had either escaped or been destroyed, and withdrew the regiment.

At this time, the whole mob of the city was collected, and the house in flames.

The jemadar of chuprassees told Sir A Burnes that there was a report of a regiment having come to assist him; he was going to the top of the house to look, and had got half way, when he met an Afghan, who said that he had been looking about, and there was not the least sign of a regiment.

My master then turned back, and remarked, there was no chance of assistance coming from the cantonments or the king. A muslim, a Cashmeeree, came forward, and said “If your brother and the chuprassees cease firing on the people, I swear by the Koran that I will take you safe through the kirkee of the garden to the fort of the Kuzzilbashes”.

The firing ceased, and Sir A Burnes agreed to accompany him, and for the sake of disguise, put on a chogha and a longee.

The moment he came out of the door, a few yards, with the Cashmeeree, the wretch called out “Here is Sikunder Burnes.”

He was rushed on by hundreds, and cut to pieces with their knives. His brother Captain Burnes went out with him, and was killed dead before Sir Alexander.

Captain Broadfoot was shot sometime before, in the house, and expired in half an hour. There was a guard of fourteen sepoys, they were all killed in the affair. All the Hindoostanees except myself were killed. His sirdar-bearer, who is with me, escaped, as he was at home. I got away, having an Afghan dress. All the Afghan servants deserted. I got into cantonments, after being several days in a shop. Sir Alexander forbade the chuprassees and others firing on people until they set fire to the gates.”

View with comments

47 Bahraini Medics Charged

Bahrain is putting 47 doctors and nurses on trial for treating wounded and dying protestors. Again there is total silence from the UK and US governments at this sickening human rights abuse by our “ally” in the Gulf. There is no discussion of sanctions against Bahrain or Saudi Arabia. There no longer seems to be even the slightest attempt to disguise the double standards. Human rights are merely an excuse to attack those who oppose UK and US interests, meaning corporate wealth; those who promote those interests can rape, kill and pillage whosoever they please.

View with comments

Ian Tomlinson Unlawfully Killed By Metropolitan Police

The comments by the jury make this sound more like murder than manslaughter:

The jury decided Pc Harwood acted illegally, recklessly and dangerously, and used “excessive and unreasonable” force in striking Mr Tomlinson.
Jurors added that the newspaper seller, who was not taking part in the protests, posed no threat.

Unfortunately the jury cannot compel a prosecution, so my bet is that the killer, PC Simon Harwood, will get off scot free. But at least a British jury has shown its historic independence of authority has survived – an independence which was denied it in the case of the murder of Jean Charles De Menezes by the utterly disgraceful Sir Michael Wright, grovelling tool of the authoritarian state.

Talking of which, it seems to me that Dr Freddy Patel needs to be sacked and struck off for the disgraceful lie that Tomlinson died of a heart attack. The last thing this country needs is bent pathologists tailoring their evidence to suit the police.

View with comments

UK State Terror Resurgent

Predictably, the death of Osama Bin Laden has brought the return of “war on terror” impunity to the crazed British security services. An extraordinarily sinister body, the “Civil Nuclear Constabulary”, has arrested five Asians for possibly taking photographs of the Sellafield nuclear power station – of which there are thousands of photographs online and which is visible on Google Earth.

Because of course, if you were a fiendish mastermind wishing to have intelligence on Sellafield, you would covertly and surreptitiously take photos using five young Asian men in a group in Cumbria in broad daylight.

Racist harassment by the state is firmly back on the agenda.

View with comments

Henry Cooper

To my generation, Henry Cooper was a real working class hero whose unaffected manner belied his status as a great master of his craft. Possessing incredible courage and skill, he was prevented from becoming world champion only by prominent eyebrow ridges that made his skin cut easily there. Sensibilities change with the years, and I now dislike boxing. But nobody could doubt Henry Cooper’s nobility of spirit, or the genuine warmth and respect between him and Muhammad Ali.

There is a scene in the movie Royal Flash, where the camera is in the place of an opponent boxing Cooper. Anybody who doubts the real skill of the sport should watch that scene. The lightning speed of the moving head, the bewildering feints. Not all the Rocky movies together demonstrated the reality of the sport a fraction as well as that brief scene of Cooper.

I listened to Cooper’s final defeat against Joe Bugner on the radio with my grandfather in his back parlour. The decision was highly unpopular and probably dubious – there was talk of low punches. But Cooper bowed out with grace, and represents a time of innocence when a great champion would go on to invest his little earnings in a grocery shop. Bugner, who had the physique of a Greek God, was to disappoint in the rest of his career by not punching his weight. I seem to recall my grandfather told me that this was because he had once killed a man in the ring; which should be enough to end this thread of boxing romanticism.

They called Cooper “Our Enery” and he did feel like just one of us in a way that sporting superstars somehow don’t any more. His death seems a break with a better past.

View with comments

He Who Lives By the Sword

Osama Bin Laden had perpetrated many acts of violence. Blowback does not only affect states; Osama Bin Laden was killed by his former allies, those who used to support and arm him. Celebrations of someone’s death are always distatsteful, but Osama Bin Laden dealt in violent death and died a violent death. Of course, he who lives by the sword is a two-edged observation; it applies to Americans too, and I am afraid there will sadly be further violence in the short term.

There are questions to be asked about why Osama Bin Laden was killed rather than captured, when he would evidently be such a valuable intelligence asset. There are aspects of the official story which do not add up. I have seen the photo of his body on France 24, and plainly he was killed by a head shot; if you have to shoot someone you are trying to capture, you do not go for the head. Secondly we are told that he could not be captured because there was a fierce firefight of resistance at the house; but that no Americans were injured. So not that fierce, then. Aside from Osama Bin Laden, only two men and one woman were killed – so again, hardly a great pitched battle. The building was then torched, destrying the forensic evidence.

If Bin Laden did not kill himself, or get one of his own men to shoot him, it remains open to question why he was taken out with a headshot in a situation where resistance had been so ineffective that no American had been hurt.

It is yet another commentary on the state of Pakistan that Bin Laden was living in a large house in Abbottabad – which is by no means a backwater. It is also a major garrison town and the headquarters for military and intellligence operations in the Afghan frontier areas. (By chance, James Abbott, its founder, is one of the Great Game players I am currently studying). I simply do not believe that Bin Laden could live for years in a million dollar home in Abbottabad without significant parts of the Pakistani military and intelligence community knowing he was there.

View with comments

Good Vibrations

One of my cunning plans for making a living was to open sex shops in the arrivals areas of airports. Since air travel became such a horrible experience, I figured that people must be chary of taking with them in their baggage the battery operated items that they find essential to their personal happiness, for fear of having them waved about by security men. Therefore the chance to equip themselves suitably on arrival might be welcome.

I was surprised to find that the Germans have got their already. In the departures lounge at Munich airport, and most importantly after you have passed through the last security search, is a Beate Uhse sex shop. And more than that, in the window they had a display of solar powered vibrators. How wonderful! You can have an orgasm and save the planet all at the same time. Good vibrations indeed.

View with comments

Mission Gallop

It is worth reminding ourselves that the stated aim of SCR 1973 is negotiations, not the wiping out of one side in Libya. Killing children by bombing a residential house in a residential suburb is not remotely defensible; for Cameron to claim that killing children is “protecting civilians” is awful – those children were civilians, whoever may have been their grandfather.

I could accept that SCR 1973 could be stretched to include knocking out air defences as pre-emptive action against a challenge to the no-fly zone. That it stretches to widespread attacks on the “command and control” facilities of one side of a civil war, is plainly nonsense. The resolution calls for negotiations between the two sides; it cannot therefore be construed to mean that the only way to protect civilians is the utter destruction of one side. Then the “command and control” excuse was used to attack civilian telephone networks, then TV networks, then civilian electricity supplies. Now it is used to justify the murder of children in a family home.

I am frankly astonished that more concern is not coming from the Liberal Democrat side of the coalition about this mission gallop.

View with comments

Jealous Superiors

Alexander Burnes is going to dominate my thoughts and my time for a few months. I am going to continue to post my transcripts as I make them so they are more readily available to other researchers.

There is a syndrome at play in this letter that I very much recognise from my own days as an up and coming diplomat. Burnes gets carpeted for suggesting Karachi should become the major regional trading centre by an old hand who knew better from his thirty years experience in the field! Burnes was of course proved right about Karachi, but did not live to see it.
NLS MS 5899 f 151 Inv

From Colonel Pottinger Bhooj Residency
Apr 15 1837

To the Honourable Sir Charles Metcalfe

My Dear Sir Charles,

I have been so very busy of late that I have not had time before to thank you for your letter of 21 February last with the two accompanying Indus reports which has been at last got up in a very complete and businesslike form – I was glad to find from Corless when he was here with me last month, that his examination and survey of this year go decidedly to support the opinion that I have entertained from the first, that the Indus affords the greatest facilities for navigation.

The last time I was at Hyderabad, the native agent who came from Calcutta was was with me and he had travelled a great deal on the Bengal rivers – his opinion was strongly in favour of the Indus, but if people expect that they are to ascend a superb river like it against the current without difficulty (I mean of course when they have not steam or a fair wind) they will be disappointed. I went up at the worst period of the year (in December) without any particular exertion at the rate of 14 miles a day with a fleet of seven boats abd when the southerly wind blows fresh a boat will often clear 50 miles between sunrise and sunset.

I have nothing to do with Capt. Burnes’ reports except to pass them on to the supreme government, but I have seen enough of them to satisfy me that his information is incorrect. He asserts in one of them that Karachee has been – I think his expression is – “for ages” the sea port of Scinde and dwells on the “beaten path” thence to Tattoh as the desirable one for a passage – so far from this being the case, Karachee was only taken from the Khan of Khelat (Beloochistan) by the present family of the Emirs in 1795 and previous to that the whole trade of Scinde went into and came out of the Indus and goods that are now landed at Karachee are chiefly conveyed thence over the range of mountains into the small district of [Lus?] of which [Sommeam?] is the seaport and out of it by the “Kohunwat” or “mountain road” by which Captain Christie and myself travelled to Kelat in 1810.

The boats of Cutch ply to and from the Indus from the 15th September to the 15th April and I see no good reason why our merchant’s boats should not do the same. The agreement however which I have made with the Ameers for warehousing goods will overcome every difficulty in the way of trade, so far as Scinde is concerned. It is quite clear at the same time, that we cannot hope for any great extension of it until the countries to the northward are tranquillized.

Believe me etc.,
Pottinger

View with comments

Small Crowds At Royal Wedding

I have been watching the BBC coverage of the Royal Wedding build-up. Try to put aside all of the hype, and look carefully at the actual crowds. They are not actually that deep, there is no sense of crush – people are standing with a reasonable amount of space when they go in for their crowd interviews – and there is plenty of space on the pavements to pass behind those people ranked behind the barriers. The crowds are much, much smaller than they were for Charles and Diana’s wedding (I was in London that day). Despite an obvious BBC policy of interviewing lots of token black guests, the crowds are also overwhelmingly white and, judged by the crowd member interviews to date, composed of embarassing simpletons.

Like many of my readers, I was on the demonstration against the Operation Cast Lead Israeli attack on Gaza, which went from Hyde Park along Bayswater, down Kensington Church Road and along Knightsbridge. It was crushed, twenty abreast, and the tail was still leaving long after the head had arrived at destination. That was a longer route than this royal procession. It undoubtedly had more people than this event, and the Metropolitan Police put the number at 40,000.

If today’s event was an anti-war demonstration, the Police would tell us it was 30,000. As it is a royal occasion, I have no doubt they will claim 3,000,000.

View with comments

Nuclear Disaster – Nothing To See Here, Folks

The nuclear industry managed to get an “expert”, whose livelihood depended one way or another on nuclear power, onto every mainstream media broadcast about the Fukushima disaster, to persuade us that an incident ranked by the IAEA as on the same level as Chernobyl, was actually nothing to worry about.

Subsequently they have managed to persuade the media that the whole thing has simply gone away. How many of you, for example, knew that the highest levels of radioactivity so far at Fukushima were measured two days ago?

The highest radiation readings since March 11 [date of the tsunami] were recorded at the Fukushima plant by robots this week. Two robots sent into the reactor No. 1 building on April 26 took readings as high as 1,120 millisierverts an hour, according to Tepco, or more than four times the annual dose permitted to nuclear workers at the stricken plant.

View with comments