Legal Does Not Mean Wise 65


To bomb ISIS in Syria is now legal in international law, with authority granted by the Security Council. (I subscribe to the argument of my ex-boss Brian Barder on the interpretation of SCR 2249). Whether it is wise or not is a quite different question.

Even John Simpson on the BBC yesterday admitted that many innocent civilians had been killed in recent bombings of the ISIS occupied city of Raqqa. Though being the BBC, while reporting correctly that the United States, France and Russia are all bombing Raqqa, they contrived only to mention civilian deaths in a sentence about Russian bombing. That bombing creates terrorist blowback has been proven beyond any rational dispute. So if ending terrorism is truly the aim, it is a curiously counter-productive means of going about it.

There is also the question of mission creep. In Libya, the security council mandated nothing but the enforcement of a no-fly zone, to prevent the possibility of a massacre in Benghazi, which was precisely as genuine a danger as Iraqi WMD. Quite illegally, the UK participated in a massive western air to ground attack including on populated areas, under the pretext of disabling any possible threat to western aircraft enforcing the no fly zone. The aim, quite illegal, was regime change. This is how “the no-fly zone was enforced” by western bombing of Sirte.
Sirte-destroyed-1

The danger is that a bombing campaign will cause this kind of devastation of civilian areas, as indeed is now happening in Raqqa, but also as in Libya will be carried far beyond the authorised objective, and extended against the areas loyal to President Assad. This risks confrontation with Russia – a danger that has been starkly illustrated since I started sketching out this article by the downing of a Russian jet by Turkey.

Libya illustrates starkly the last and largest problem – that you cannot control what fills the vacuum. The governance of Libya is now a disaster. The ultimate irony was that the people of Benghazi demonstrated their gratitude at being saved from “massacre” by slaughtering the American Ambassador. The truth of the matter is that, despite the dreadful records of both Saddam and Gaddafi, the manner of their removal resulted in a situation where life was undoubtedly better for the vast majority of the population under the dictators. Which is a massive testament to Western incompetence.

David Cameron appears to have no idea whatsoever what will replace ISIS in the areas under its control. We know that he does not want the Syrian state under President Assad to take control. The area is not Kurdish, so they are not an option. Hezbollah is regarded as an Iranian proxy. The West’s attempts to create moderate pro-Western Sunni rebel forces have been a pathetic failure. The Saudis and other Gulf states have funded a variety of rebels, including much of ISIS and other groups which have an equally insane agenda. If any of the Wahabbi groups besides ISIS could be strengthened sufficiently to hold major territory, they would undoubtedly be found to be just as enthusiastic at persecuting Christians and other minorities and beheading people.

Someone has to control the physical territory, and Cameron has no viable alternative for this at all. Talk of funding and training moderate groups is whistling in the dark. The USA has already put far greater resources into this than the UK ever could, and the result has been complete failure.

Having delivered Sikunder Burnes to the publisher, I have started research on a life of Lord George Murray, working title The Man Who Terrified London. It is in fact true that some Scottish aristocratic families deliberately allocated members to each side in the 45, to ensure continued family control of the estates. But such instances are very rare, the Frasers of Lovat being the most notable. Most family splits, like among the Murrays of Atholl, were genuine and painful. My favourite example is the MacDonells, who were all Jacobite but decided that Glengarry himself, a hopeless alcoholic incompetent, would do more harm to the Hanoverians by remaining on their side. There is an excellent simile here to the Saudis, where numerous minor royals and all their business contractors are pumping money into ISIS and other extreme Wahabbi groups, while the King and Crown Prince pretend to be pro-Western and anti-ISIS. That is when they can spare a moment from their aerial massacre of the Houtha, or sentencing children and poets to death at home. The situation in all our Gulf “allies” is the same.

It is of course instructive that there is no sense at all in which Trident missiles are helpful in this dilemma. It is worth repeating out loud every time we consider a defence or foreign policy dilemma “Trident is useless in the particular situation”. We should say it all the time. We are spending an inconceivable sum on a system which is no earthly use.

But bombing is just as useless. It can achieve nothing whatsoever except pointless death. It will make Cameron look macho and win some jingo votes, enabling the corporate and state media to whip up a frenzy of hate against non-militarists. I suppose that is a useful purpose for the establishment. There is no other useful purpose.

Bombing ISIS in Syria may now be legal. That does not make it useful or wise.


65 thoughts on “Legal Does Not Mean Wise

1 2 3
  • craig Post author

    Sora,

    Thanks. I fear Charlie will not come well out of it. George was an astonishingly principled man, and extremely physically courageous.

  • calla lily spa

    Chewing or biting into the plant releases the crystals which penetrate tissue leading to
    injury or even death. Knitting could be a wonderful way to pass time
    or relieve stress. Lilies love the sun’s rays, but do their
    utmost when planted inside a location that provides them with strong morning sun and light-weight shade through the hot afternoon summer sun.

    Besides, their significant role naturally and economy, they beautify the environment
    making life more colorful and meaningful. The handle
    is created of black satin ribbon with black pins, and an ornate costume broach shimmers in silver
    in the midst of the royal blues, greens, and tans with the feathers.

  • strongest nerf gun ever for

    Besides the toys, stock activities that could be done together to
    construct fun memories with those precious grandchildren whenever they come over and visit.
    Before deciding to get toy storage bins, here really are a few things to be kept in your mind.

    Where to find nerf guns Not only will be the toys kept neatly contained, but they are
    able to also include a decorative look on the room.

    You will need to keep safety planned when choosing child toys.

    Toys needs to be used as a possible adjunct to interactions between parent and caretaker,
    not as a substitute to have an adult’s participation inside child’s play.

  • security cameras Remote recording

    Consequently, aside from closing the door within your room it truly is necessary which
    you assign a security alarm password on your computer system to make certain the documents are secured.
    As these security systems work for the Wi – Fi signals,
    there may be practically no limit for the number of cameras that is usually installed.
    Wireless security cameras zoom ADT Safewatch Video – View even allows a gamers to keep a
    close look on each and every portion of these house through any mobile phone or
    i – Pad, even while these are traveling abroad.

    Here would be the necessary things you need to keep in your
    mind when searching with the perfect wireless safety camera on your outdoors.
    Any surveillance camera provides a boost to peace of mind in any indoor setting.

  • nonetheless

    This laptop will dominate any gaming laptop rolling around in its
    immediate surroundings. The beta will incorporate a new European server,
    two new characters, a number of new maps plus a game mode.
    Best laptop for gaming under 500 With just one core processor, internet
    connected computers reads and executes actions in a single brain.

    The short life of the battery can not risk that much of your problem for gamers, as most of them will probably stop reminded to
    seal their laptops. Replacement laptop batteries
    are affordable and so are only each day away facing Laptop Power UK.

1 2 3

Comments are closed.