Reply To: Russia in World War Two


Home Forums Discussion Forum Russia in World War Two Reply To: Russia in World War Two

#47018 Reply

John2o2o

@ kempe

With respect – and I am not going to attempt to answer your specific points, which Tatyana can, I am sure do for herself when she is ready to do so – I would say that your claim that Tatyana is saying that:

“Poland deserved to be invaded and have regime change forced upon it.”

is false. I see nowhere on this comment thread in which such a position has been stated by her.

Tatyana’s passionate defence of her country is I think very reasonable and understandable in the context of Poland’s recent cowardly snub to the Russian Federation and in the context of her country’s great (and in the west often scandalously ignored) and undeniable contribution to fighting the evil Nazi war machine.

Germany was invited to the event to mark the beginning of World War II by Poland just over a week ago. According to WIkipedia the USSR apologised to Poland for the Katyn massacre in 1990:

“when it officially acknowledged and condemned the perpetration of the killings by the NKVD, as well as the subsequent cover-up by the Soviet government”

And if we are going to make comparisons, who committed the greatest atrocities in Poland in the war. Germany or the USSR?

The purpose of my making the original post was to honour the contribution made by the Soviet people in the war and was not intended to highlight the issue of Poland specifically.