The Feminist Defence of Blowing Out the Brains of Small Children

by craig on April 9, 2014 8:05 pm in Uncategorized

The number of people still prepared to defend the Iraq War in public is tiny.  The interesting thing is the very strong correlation between those people, and those prepared to pretend to give credence to the farcical sexual allegations about Julian Assange.  Zoe Williams Guardian piece about what a jolly good chap Blair is I find breathtaking.  War crimes like Blair’s result in terrible anguish for millions.  I am prepared for purposes of argument to believe that Williams’ anguish for female victims of crime is genuine; why she can’t extend that to the tens of thousands of women who were raped because of Blair’s Iraq War, or had the still worse agony of seeing their children killed and mutilated I don’t know.  Nick Cohen is just very, very sad.  I just hold up these two in the hope that those deceived by feminist political correctness into following their lead against Assange will see to what they are subscribing.

Rather a side issue, but even if we accept Zoe Williams view that dead Iraqi children don’t matter, she appears not to have noticed that Blair introduced tuition fees, academies, kick-started NHS privatization, allowed the banksters’ bonanza leading to worldwide economic crash and oversaw the greatest widening of the gap between rich and poor in British history.

 

Tweet this post

615 Comments

  1. Mary; “Keep up why don’t you or are you being deliberately obtuse”

    Mary, some people’s blinkered POVs depend on them being exactly that !

  2. “The Sunni Shia divide did not exist”

    Also completely untrue.

  3. Ba'al Zevul (Thank God Tomorrow's Friday)

    10 Apr, 2014 - 2:12 pm

    “The Sunni Shia divide did not exist”

    Also completely untrue.
    Correct for once. On the other hand we have done our best to exploit the division, and in Iraq succeeded beyond comprehension.

  4. “On the other hand we have done our best to exploit the division”

    I would put it more down to ignorance rather than genuine intent.

  5. Iraq, now Syria …. more collateral damage from Western intervention.

    Some Syrian refugees arriving in Jordan are opting to marry off their daughters at a young age believing that marital status offers a form of protection and insurance.

    http://www.irinnews.org/report/95902/jordan-early-marriage-a-coping-mechanism-for-syrian-refugees

  6. Ba'al Zevul (Thank God Tomorrow's Friday)

    10 Apr, 2014 - 2:30 pm

    They post here?

    Why is that of relevance – is insulting people behind their backs somehow better?

    You are with President Obiang of Guinea, I take it:
    “What right does the opposition have to criticise the actions of a government?”

    As the people – in the public domain – you are defending almost certainly remain unaware of any insult*,and are far too important to take notice of it it if they did, it’s probably more harmless than incessantly stalking the contributors you don’t like here and being as unpleasant as you can to them for no particular reason – or maybe you have a reason?

    * Do note that criticism, or outright condemnation, especially when backed by checkable facts, are not per se insulting. Also that people whose columns you could read every week in the Spectator, if you were literate**, do a far better crucifixion job on people who are not actually present in their office than anyone here.

    ** Insult.

  7. Ba'al Zevul (Thank God Tomorrow's Friday)

    10 Apr, 2014 - 2:36 pm

    I would put it more down to ignorance rather than genuine intent.

    Please support that opinion. As I recall, the UK media were falling over themselves to tell us in 2003 how the Shi’a would welcome us into Iraq – and they did, briefly, because we’d been telling them they would at last be able to express their majority view democratically. And I am absolutely certain that someone in the FCO was aware that the Shi’a traditionally look to Iran for support, and that Israel for the last twenty years has been urging the US to attack Iran. Ignorance? If so, there was no possible justification for intervening in the first place.

    The current civil war in Iraq is largely Shi’a vs. Sunni. Lousy as the previous regime was, they weren’t murdering each other on a industrial scale then. Indeed, they shared neighbourhoods. Not any more.

  8. Ba'al Zevul (Thank God Tomorrow's Friday)

    10 Apr, 2014 - 2:44 pm

    http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/middle-east/the-vicious-schism-between-sunni-and-shia-has-been-poisoning-islam-for-1400-years–and-its-getting-worse-9139525.html

    The invasion of Iraq instigated by George Bush and Tony Blair in 2003 was the second big factor in the deterioration of Sunni-Shia relations. Saddam Hussein led a Sunni elite which governed Iraq’s Shia majority with a reign of state terror. The US had backed Saddam in Iraq’s war with Iran throughout the 1980s, in which half a million troops died.

    But after 9/11 the US changed its mind about Saddam, overthrew him and brought democracy to Iraq. The resulting election placed in power leaders from the Shia majority who have excluded the Sunni minority – who have responded with the car bombs which are killing thousands in Baghdad and elsewhere. Al-Qa’ida jihadists have flooded into the country to join Sunni terrorists in attacking the Shia government. And now the polarised sectarian conflict has spilled over into Syria.

    When the Arab Spring reached Syria in 2011 it began as a protest against the corruption, nepotism and human rights abuses of the Assad government. But within two years the armed uprising against the regime was transformed.

    Rebels motivated by political indignation, who received limited backing from Western governments, slowly became outnumbered by rebel groups with extreme Islamist motivation fighting to create what they call the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS).

    These jihadists have come from across the Islamic world but they are backed by Saudi cash. More recently Shia militants from the Lebanese paramilitary group Hezbollah have arrived to support the Alawite-led army of the Assad regime. Full-blown civil war is the result.

    What all this means is that Sunni and Shia are locked in conflict all across the Shia Crescent. As each side steps up its activities, the other feels more threatened and hardens its response in turn.

    Sunni-Shia tensions are increasing across the world as a result. They are on the rise in Afghanistan, Pakistan, Turkey, Kuwait, Lebanon, Bahrain, Libya, Tunisia, Malaysia, Egypt, and even in London as issues of identity, rights, interests and enfranchisement find sectarian expression.

    The tensions are deep-rooted in wider economic and geopolitical concerns. But the risk – given the long history of division and tension – is that predictions of a transnational civil war between Sunni and Shia could become a self-fulfilling prophecy.

    Which side will we be supporting? Think we’re going to stop selling arms to Saudi?
    Stop destabilising Iran?

  9. ESLO 10 Apr, 2014 – 2:14 pm

    “On the other hand we have done our best to exploit the division”

    I would put it more down to ignorance rather than genuine intent.

    ……………………………

    “Text of report by Iranian Arabic language television news channel Al-Alam on 15 October

    The British government has officially apologized to Iraq over the recent Basra events.

    A statement issued by the British consulate in Basra has said that London apologizes to the Iraqi people and government, Basra residents, city and province councils and the police force over mistakes made by the British

    This comes after a British [army] unit stormed Basra police station and used force to release two British soldiers arrested by Iraqi police for the charge of seeking to carry out sabotage acts and stirring sedition among the residents of the city.”

    http://www.globalresearch.ca/britain-apologizes-for-terrorist-act-in-basra/1094

  10. A Node and Ba’al Zevul:

    You may be right, A. Node about Geldof being part of the promote Blair conspiracy I hyposthesized, but whether or not this is true, is it right, Ba’al, to regard the Gleneagles summit as worthless?

    For decades previously I read every week in the papers how debt was crippling what we then called the third world. This term is not used anymore, since around the time of 2005 and I would guess that the cancelling of massive amounts of global debt has made a big difference.

    Craig in his book on Africa and elsewhere has documented the way Blair has exploited African capitalism for the personal gain of himself and his cronies, but to acknowledge that is not the same thing as dismissing the value of Gleneagles and related agreements.

    Furthermore to call Geldof a ‘sleb’ does him a disservice. In the year or two leading up to the first Bandaid concert back whenever that was, Geldof toured Africa interviewing political leaders and astonished certainly me with his cojones.

    We all know aid has limited value in itself but we should be discerning in criticising people like Geldof I think.

  11. ESLO, and not just Iraq and Iran. Saudi Arabia too.

    http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/8493402.stm

    Here are a couple of petitions you, and others, might care to sign.

    http://www.walkfree.org/show-support-yemen-free-forced-child-marriage/
    http://www.change.org/petitions/stand-firm-against-child-brides

    Your comment in support of Blair, the mass murderer and war-criminal, is distasteful. Anybody with a conscience would disassociate themselves from such a character, a person who has probably murdered, and continues to murder, more children than Beria and Stalin put together, in Afgahnistan, Iraq and Libya. His Judas kiss of Gaddafi said it all.

  12. “a person who has probably murdered, and continues to murder, more children than Beria and Stalin put together, in Afgahnistan, Iraq and Libya.”

    Not even near I’m afraid – not even with your estimates for Blair.

    I’m not a fan of any backward religion – I find it difficult to place them above and below each other as they have all been pretty nasty at different stages in their development.

  13. conjunction 10 Apr, 2014 – 2:49 pm

    “We all know aid has limited value in itself but we should be discerning in criticising people like Geldof I think.”

    I think Geldof knowingly and deliberately created his Live 8 event to relieve pressure on Blair and Bush at the G8 summit. I believe he is a liar and a fraud.

    More of the same from me in a post on previous thread:
    http://www.craigmurray.org.uk/archives/2014/03/andy-myles/comment-page-4/#comment-450741

  14. “Not even near I’m afraid – not even with your estimates for Blair.”

    Figures?

  15. Habbabkuk (La vita è bella) !

    10 Apr, 2014 - 3:11 pm

    Mr Scorgie

    “verb
    “…variant spelling of fantasize (restricted to archaic uses or, in modern use, to the fields of psychology and psychiatry).”

    http://www.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/english/phantasize

    Very strange!”
    __________________

    Why strange? Other links and sources to back up your assertion, please.

  16. Habbabkuk (La vita è bella) !

    10 Apr, 2014 - 3:14 pm

    Nevermind

    ““I suppose I don’t see this blog as a pyschologist’s couch.”

    No, you don’t, its more like an annonymous hole in the wall in some dinghy peepshow for you, somewhere to get off all over people.”
    ___________________

    “dinghy peepshow” – your expression, not mine! :)

  17. These are a few of Blair’s child victims.

    http://www.coia.org.uk/

    It says 300 children die every day. 138,000 children under 5 die a year according to UNICEF. And that’s just Iraq! You might want to associate with a mass-murderer like that. But I have morals.

  18. Habbabkuk (La vita è bella) !

    10 Apr, 2014 - 3:21 pm

    Macky

    “Habbabkuk; “A draft law, Fujisan, a draft law. Which means that it is not yet law. And may in fact never become law”

    Actually according to the Telegraph, it “looks likely to pass”

    http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/middleeast/iraq/10753645/Iraq-ready-to-legalise-childhood-marriage.html
    ____________________

    Ah well, if that’s what the Telegraph says, it must be right, eh?

    “Looks” and “likely”.

    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

    ““This should be OK as well:

    Mr. Jonesxxx is a paedophile and he rapes children in Malaysia and kill them in the process, after torturing them of course. But here at home (UK) he is is an exemplary citizen, pays taxes, gives money to charity organizations, and work hard for his country. Anyway, Malaysia is very far away, and who cares?

    What about that?”
    ________________

    Not OK at all. The contrary of OK I should have thought. Why do you think I think it’s OK (links, please!), and why do you seem to think it is?

  19. Habbabkuk (La vita è bella) !

    10 Apr, 2014 - 3:26 pm

    ESLO

    ““On February 25th, Iraq’s Cabinet approved a draft law lowering the age of legal marriage for females to nine years old.”

    Iran of course already has such a law”
    __________________

    Thank you for bringing that to my attention, ESLO. As an Eminent Poster on here might say : “I was not aware”.

    But Iran’s OK, I mean, isn’t it? ‘Cos it’s deemed to be anti-Western?

  20. Ben-Scot NON-collaborator

    10 Apr, 2014 - 3:26 pm

    Jaafari Law;

    “The law appears to run counter to the UN Convention on Rights of the Child, ratified by Iraq in 1994—which expressly bans the legalization of child marriage—as well as Iraq’s own constitution, although al-Shimmari, himself a Shi’a, has dismissed critics of the bill. “By introducing this draft law, we want to limit or prevent” child marriage outside the legal system, according to al-Shimmari.”

    http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2014/04/09/iraq-wants-to-legalize-child-marriage.html

    It seems the West’s imposition of their version of democracy has unintended consequences.

    We didn’t intend for them to mimic our form of government in toto.

  21. Habbabkuk (La vita è bella) !

    10 Apr, 2014 - 3:30 pm

    Hurby

    “Meanwhile, in the real world, people are buying Renmimbi.”
    _________________

    Well, personally I haven’t yet met anyone who is, but never mind. Are you?

    ******************

    La vita è bella, life is good!

  22. “I think Geldof knowingly and deliberately created his Live 8 event to relieve pressure on Blair and Bush at the G8 summit.”

    Correct.

    Poverty is intrinsic to the western system of exploitation.

    Make poverty history and you make the Washington Consensus history too.

    Geldof channelled the genuine and growing revulsion of people against poverty into something elites could accept.

    Fine words but no change.

  23. Habbabkuk (La vita è bella) !

    10 Apr, 2014 - 3:37 pm

    Ba’al Zevul

    “Could we have a full biography of your father so that we can all play the game of visiting the sons of the father on the child? You really are incorrigible. (@ Mary)

    Personal attack.

    “Blair killed my association with the Labour Party.”

    Yes he was rather good at clearing out the infiltrators. (@JG)

    Personal attack.”
    ___________________

    Not at all. The first response is a legitimate rejoinder ( of methodological intent) to a poster who appears to set great store by what sort of ancestors people in the public sphere have; in her case, Jewish ancestors). The second response makes a political point, namely that Blair rid the Labour party of its far-left infiltrators, thereby completing a process started by Clement Atlee.

    If the Mods should suppress something, it should be the constant references to people’s Jewish ancestors.

  24. Ben-Scot NON-collaborator

    10 Apr, 2014 - 3:37 pm

    Additionally, the efforts to make sex slaves of their children is a violation of the Rule of Law; a sacrosanct policy created for the other guy and not for personal consumption.

    It’s much better to hide one’s fetishes from behind holy vestments which no one would dare reveal because it would bring reproach on a major institution necessary for society’s well-being.

  25. Habbabkuk (La vita è bella) !

    10 Apr, 2014 - 3:38 pm

    Constant references against which you have never once raised your otherwise over-loud voice, Ba’al Zevul.

  26. John Goss:

    Stalin is generally supposed to have been responsible for around 20 million deaths either through direct executions, ‘reforms’ of agriculture on a massive scale in the thirties which collectivised agriculture, the sending of millions to Siberia. For instance his own heroic soldiers who suffered untold miseries fighting the Germans in the Second World War were in huge numbers rewarded on their return with what was often a one way ticket to Siberia because Stalin was afraid they might have been corrupted on their trip to Europe.

    He even had a considerable number of his own family executed. Shortly before the Second World War he efficiently purged his senior military commanders.

  27. And here are some more figures just in on Iraqi deaths. Where are yours ESLO?

    http://www.justforeignpolicy.org/iraq

  28. Habbabkuk (La vita è bella) !

    10 Apr, 2014 - 3:47 pm

    Clark

    “ESLO, 1:22 pm

    “Yes he was rather good at clearing out the infiltrators.”

    As, I believe, was Stalin.”
    _______________________

    Invalid comparison, displaying little sense of history.

    1/. It is Stalin who should, in fact, be considered as an infiltrator if we are to judge by his systematic rooting out and elimination, in the 1930s, of almost all the old Bolsheviks.

    2/. Various leaders of the Labour party, starting put with Clement Atlee, have declared membership of far-left parties, organisations and groupings incompatible with membership of the Labour Party. Members of those parties, etc, whether declares or (more usually) covert, were the infiltrators.

    Hope you understood that, ‘cos I can’t be arsed to explain further. Cheers!

  29. “Well, personally I haven’t yet met anyone who is, but never mind.”

    You’ve discussed it. That’s good.

    So they’ve other strategies for when USD collapses.

    Or they’re skint.

    Which is it?

  30. Ben-Scot NON-collaborator

    10 Apr, 2014 - 3:52 pm

  31. A. Node:

    I have read your comments, and those of Brian Fujisan on the previous thread. In general I am not an expert on this field, it is not something I have gone out of my way to research.

    But to say as Herbie does above of Geldof: ‘Fine words but no change’ is clearly not true. You might not like the change, but change there has been.

    Yes there has been massive investment in the third world by western agencies and global companies, yes it has often been their agenda which is dominant, but there has been change, and there have been jobs created on a massive scale.

    The levels of poverty in ‘the third world’ bear no comparison, I don’t think, to what they were say forty years ago. Some of this has to be down to western investment and cancellation of debt, even if the investment is skewed.

    I felt unhappy in 2005, I remember feeling that Geldof’s timing was all wrong, but in general I am not sure that his legacy is a negative one, and in your earlier post which you link to, with respect, you do not produce much hard evidence.

    BrianFujisan does make a case against Bono, mostly on the subject of western dictation of terms of investment, but thats Bono not Geldof.

  32. Ba'al Zevul (Thank God Tomorrow's Friday)

    10 Apr, 2014 - 3:58 pm

    Conjunction
    “We all know aid has limited value in itself but we should be discerning in criticising people like Geldof I think.”

    I bow to your reasoned and informed opinion- pretty well confirmed by this:

    http://www.oxfam.org.uk/media-centre/press-releases/2013/05/make-poverty-history-and-g8-promises-was-it-all-really-worth-it

    Public pressure certainly needs to coalesce around well-known figures, and I suppose they are necessary. Mean-minded caveat; they don’t actually do the work.

  33. My sleuth-like brain asks a question. Suddenly, unless others know differently, a character called Conjunction appears on the blog. This is the day after I get some release from Habbabkuk using Habbabreak. This Conjunction speaks in the same voice as Habbabkuk, with praise for Resident Dissident and an eagerness to answer comments aimed at ESLO with unsubstantiated figures, much in the way Habbabkuk does. Is Conjunction the latest manifestation of Habbabkuk?

    A simple Yes from regular comment-makers will suffice. Or even No if that’s what you really think.

  34. Not sure why you’re getting at Mary taking an interest in genealogies, habby.

    I seem to remember that elites put great store by such measures.

    Breeding, they called it. Drew up big long family trees, with crests rampant and everything.

    Apart from a brief period during the post war period when it became rather unfashionable, it’s now happily all back in vogue again.

    There’s barely an area of elite life these days where “aristocracy” isn’t thriving.

    They’re all very proud to be special, and indeed owe their position in life to it.

    More elite family trees, please.

  35. Ben-Scot NON-collaborator

    10 Apr, 2014 - 4:03 pm

    Bono, and ostensibly Geldof, are like any other politician who gets caught up in the net of populism and finance. Becoming mainstream is the Obama effect.

    You have to go along to get along. When those parameters have already been established, it’s nearly impossible to effect change at all, and so minor victories on the perimeter of change are seen as good, rather than perfect.

    So if you have an intervention on a loved one a little too into his/her cups, just remember it’s ok to enable them to drink less rather than abstain completely.

  36. Habbabkuk (La vita è bella) !

    10 Apr, 2014 - 4:06 pm

    Hurby

    ““Well, personally I haven’t yet met anyone who is, but never mind.”

    You’ve discussed it. That’s good.

    So they’ve other strategies for when USD collapses.

    Or they’re skint.

    Which is it?”
    __________________

    Difference between the verbs “to meet” and “to discuss”, Hurby?

    Anyway : are you putting your money where your mouth is and buying the Chinese currency? Why so coy?

  37. Nick Cohen:
    The leaders of political cults, like their religious counterparts, increase their power by fostering paranoia. Members can trust no one outside the party, especially the police and judiciary. The SWP says that Comrade Delta’s alleged victim was free to go to the police and chose not to, but party dogma insists that justice is impossible in bourgeois courts. Only when it’s too late do women learn that the alternative disciplinary system of Marxist-Leninists exists to control them and let the leaders do as they please. The parallels with the Catholic church are too obvious for me to labour.

    Ditto: political Islam

    Feminist political correctness = sexual politics = all politics = lying. What has also reached my attention recently is that Magic is a form of private/ sexual politics which is practised inside Islam for the same evil purposes as political extremism is practised inside Islam. The worst aspects of Salafist jihadism and offshoots of manipulative Sufism converge into cult bullying and mental/ spiritual breakdown.

    What I find curious is that Craig can see and feel the pain from the black arts of feminism, whose mill western man has been ground down by since the onset of Thatcherism, but he does not see the black arts of Monarch brainwashing that appear to have touched the upbringing of Julian assange, which to me are parts of one and the same thing,viz: sexual politics/ lying/ transfer of power from the individual to New world order bullying .

  38. Habbabkuk (La vita è bella) !

    10 Apr, 2014 - 4:14 pm

    Mr Goss

    “My sleuth-like brain asks a question.”
    _______________

    Not sleuth-like and even less a brain. But I’ll give you Clouseau if you like.

    But no matter, the answer is no. Not that I – or probably Conjunction – could care less what you think. Do get it into your skull that large numbers of people disagree with you and occasionally feel moved to let you know.

    Put it down to coincidence – the same coincidence that, on Craig’s Ukraine/Russia/rasPutin threads, saw the appearance of a large number of handles unseen before and after. Comments on that?

  39. Ben-Scot NON-collaborator

    10 Apr, 2014 - 4:15 pm

    Can one man fight effectively within existing systems?

    Cesar Chavez; not perfect but also not a tool.

    http://www.newyorker.com/arts/critics/atlarge/2014/04/14/140414crat_atlarge_heller

    “Chavez’s own will was mammoth, and his battle against agribusiness lasted weeks, then months, then years. The goal, he said, was to cost growers fifty dollars for each dollar spent on the strike. Ostensibly, field workers were pushing for better wages and treatment. But they also fought for recognition of Chavez’s new field-labor union, now called the United Farm Workers, and the political authority of a marginalized demographic. The strike, which began and was headquartered in Delano, a San Joaquin Valley town that lay at the heart of table-grape production, grew to represent the fate of a new national cause.”

  40. Habbabkuk; “Ah well, if that’s what the Telegraph says, it must be right, eh?”

    It’s odds on even I reckon as to whetever your obtuseness is deliberate or not; you stated with all your non-expertise in Iraqi matters, that the child marriage act “may in fact never become law”, whereas even the pro-war & Blair friendly Telegraph, who presumeably had consulted with people more knowledgeable in this matter than yourself, have concluded this it “looks likely to pass”, a complete polar opposite to your baseless assertion.

    “Why do you think I think it’s OK (links, please!), and why do you seem to think it is?”

    Read my Post again; note that it is two parts; note that the first part was addressed directly to you; note that the second part starts with the words, “Re topic of thread, this comment seems to appropriate”

    As I believe I have previously receommended to you, adult classes in basic English comprehension skills, will save you posting even more superfluous comments than you already do.

  41. Habbabkuk (La vita è bella) !

    10 Apr, 2014 - 4:18 pm

    Mr Goss

    I should have said “most people”, not “large numbers of people”.

    BTW, how’s your “Left Unity” Party getting along? Membership exploding?

  42. Deleting Mods/ Vermicious knids of all kninds, Please note: not a Z in sight. Pretending to be zzzzzing. Wink, wink!?!

  43. Habbabkuk (La vita è bella) !

    10 Apr, 2014 - 4:23 pm

    Macky

    “Habbabkuk; “Ah well, if that’s what the Telegraph says, it must be right, eh?”

    It’s odds on even I reckon as to whetever your obtuseness is deliberate or not; you stated with all your non-expertise in Iraqi matters, that the child marriage act “may in fact never become law”, whereas even the pro-war & Blair friendly Telegraph, who presumeably had consulted with people more knowledgeable in this matter than yourself, have concluded this it “looks likely to pass”, a complete polar opposite to your baseless assertion.”
    ________________________

    Well, let’s wait and see , shall we, Macky.

    But i have a pretty goos track record in these things: no World War 3 starting in Syria, former President Chavez not assassinated by injection of a lethal cancer virus, Malaysian airliner not hijacked to Diego Garcia, AS Victoria Nuland didn’t appoint the new Ukraine govt, etc, etc – the list is long!

  44. Ba’al Zevul

    You’re easily impressed.

    =========================

    Habby

    How would you know what people you meet are doing with their money unless you’d discussed it with them?

    More generally, do you think that USD will collapse, and what impact will that have on GBP and EUR?

    Do these people you meet think that USD will collapse, or do they expect things to just keep on going as they are?

  45. Ben-Scot NON-collaborator

    10 Apr, 2014 - 4:27 pm

    ” how’s your “Left Unity” Party getting along? Membership exploding?”

    Even a blind sow finds the occasional truffle.

    It’s true that the Left is a quagmire of qualitative opinion whose power is limited by the very independent thinking that makes sounds of reform a dissonant incoherence. If lefties could meld with conservative ‘me too’ intellect and create alliances out of differences, the political landscape would benefit greatly.

  46. Ben; “Turkey tries to roast a Hersh for Sader”

    Here’s a couple of interesting links in the aftermath of the Hersh article;

    http://members5.boardhost.com/medialens/thread/1396964089.html

    http://www.veteranstoday.com/2014/04/08/296525/

  47. John Goss

    Earlier I suggested that I was paranoid. However I think I got the wrong guy.

    For what its worth, as I said on the earlier occasion you refer to, I have contributed to this blog occasionally for many years, since some time before you ever did.

    However I do beg your pardon for not recognising that this blog was really a private conversation between you and ESLO.

    In the meantime why not do a little light research into comrade Stalin and find out what everyone else knows for yourself?

  48. Ben-Scot NON-collaborator

    10 Apr, 2014 - 4:40 pm

    Macky; The fact that NYT and WaPO are silent about the Hersh piece….telling.

  49. Ben-Scot NON-collaborator

    10 Apr, 2014 - 4:42 pm

    Conjunction; Is this a new ‘nic’? If not, what name was used. Be careful not to reveal any Tells.

    “In the meantime why not do a little light research into comrade Stalin and find out what everyone else knows for yourself?”

    This is a familiar tone.

  50. Conjunction

    Stalin was definitely a baddie, but who funded him.

    Who made it all possible.

    And were they by any chance related to those who cleaned the new world of all those pesky natives.

    Chomsky and others have come up with a figure of around 60,000,000 killed since only WWII, by the West.

  51. “For what its worth, as I said on the earlier occasion you refer to, I have contributed to this blog occasionally for many years, since some time before you ever did.”

    Sorry I missed this. Where did you say “I have contributed to this blog occasionally for many years”? I must have missed something.

  52. Herbie

    The west funded Stalin in his successful efforts to fight the Germans in World War Two. Is that what you mean?

    Do you have a reference for the 60 million figure?

    Ben and John Goss: because I value this blog I will make one more comment on my identity.

    I first started commenting on this blog in 2010 after I read Craig’s books. There are reviews of both his books posted on Amazon under the same nickname which is the one I always use on any blog.

  53. The Specious Defence of Blowing Straw Women Out Of Your Assange
    This womanista defends the bad war and that womanista dislikes my chum. Feminism is a problem. Now carry on.

  54. Thanks for the sleuthing, Mary, she was a remarkable photograp[hers who could take the most exceptional pictures with a box brownie, she always used second hand cameras of the older variety and she loved black and white.

    I put her in the same league as Fritz Land, both of them artists of light and dark.

  55. Habbabkuk (La vita è bella) !

    10 Apr, 2014 - 5:03 pm

    Hurby

    “More generally, do you think that USD will collapse, and what impact will that have on GBP and EUR?”
    ____________

    The answer to your first question being “no, I do not believe the USD will collapse”, a reply to your second question becomes otiose.

    ~~~~~~~~~~

    “Do these people you meet think that USD will collapse, or do they expect things to just keep on going as they are?”
    _________________

    As I have not discussed it with them, I do not know what they think.

    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

    And now that I’ve amply answered your questions, perhaps you would answer mine, ie, are you yourself putting your money where your mouth is and buying Chinese currency?

    If so, I wish you luck. :)

  56. should mean Fritz Lang

  57. Ben-Scot NON-collaborator

    10 Apr, 2014 - 5:07 pm

    “Now carry on”

    Phil; I think, as well, it’s a personal thing…toes stepped upon.

  58. Habbabkuk (La vita è bella) !

    10 Apr, 2014 - 5:08 pm

    Weedsmoker

    ““In the meantime why not do a little light research into comrade Stalin and find out what everyone else knows for yourself?”

    This is a familiar tone.”
    _________________

    And a very pertinent one.

  59. Habbabkuk (La vita è bella) !

    10 Apr, 2014 - 5:12 pm

    Nevermind

    We had the “sleuth-like” Mr Goss and now we read “Thanks for the sleuthing, Mary,..”

    WOW! Clouseau and Clousette!

    Verily I say unto you : ‘Strewth, what a slough of sleuths!

  60. Habbabkuk (La vita è bella) !

    10 Apr, 2014 - 5:14 pm

    Anyway, enough of me. Carry on, chaps. Or, on Buddy Hilly’s words: Rave on!

  61. Habbabkuk (La vita è bella) !

    10 Apr, 2014 - 5:15 pm

    Too quick – Buddy Holly (and even : in)

  62. Habbabkuk (La vita è bella) !

    10 Apr, 2014 - 5:20 pm

    I can confirm that Conjunction has written reviews of Craig’s books on Amazon UK.

    When did John Goss start squatting on Craig’s blog, as a matter of interest? Was it really only after 2010? From his tone, you’d think he’s been on here forever.

  63. Craig might just as easily have used the tags:
    The Islam-ist defence of blowing out the brains…
    The Christian Fundamental-ist..
    Marx-ist.

    -Isms are all self-serving political wolves hiding under the good names/sheep’s clothings of high principled ideas. Feminism is not an exception. Islam is ultimate truth, but ex-Zword Freemason, ex Muslim Brotherhood Ayman Zawahiri of ‘The List’ of Robin Cook fame pronounced that anybody who engages their brain into analysing what political Islam is doing, is automatically a spy and an enemy of Islam.

    Give the followers of his zombie cult guns and others who are in the habit of using their brains guns and put them in Syria where the general population is in the habit of practising the ultimate truth of Islam- what do you get: chaos. Then he wails that hsi followers have mutinied. Thank God. Allahu Akbar!. The possessors of brains have mutinied against the cult that would slit their throats for engaging their brains.

    If there had not been any opposition to the mercenaries of UKUSIS we could definitely say we were doomed. Similarly, we can also take hope that feminism took a virtual kick in the balls by the resignation of Maria Miller. wrongdoing is still being challenged in spite of NWO power.

    The case of Julian Assange is like the case of the Ukraine. Equal participants in feminist political tripe Assange and Swedish feminism cross virtual swords in a virtual legal battle computer game. Equal participants Jewish Russian oligarchs and NWO powers USUKIS cross virtual swords in a virtual legal battle computer game.

    Why is it interesting to consider the rules of a virtual game? Well chess is interesting to those who play it. But are these virtual heroic Beowulfan battles of covert politics and virtual power in the real world? Only to the extent that you believe in them. Does the presence of the black box of MH370 in the most inaccessible part of the Indian Ocean prove that nothing happened to the passengers between take-off and disappearing? Only to the extent that you believe in them.

    We live in an age of deception and the only limit is the boundaries of our imaginations to understand the full scope of the evil that our rulers are capable of doing.

  64. “The west funded Stalin in his successful efforts to fight the Germans in World War Two. Is that what you mean?”

    Nope.

    Stalin and the Bolsheviks were funded from an early stage by western bankers, as of course was Hitler.

    The Tsar was being a bit of a pain over his state banking system, so they decided to help topple him. Some things never change.

  65. Habby

    You say:

    “I do not believe the USD will collapse”

    What makes you think that?

    Is it anything other than mental inertia on your part?

    IOW, you just can’t imagine it happening because you’re conditioned to expect things always to remain the same.

    And, how can you know what people you meet are doing with their money if you don’t discuss it with them?

  66. Habby

    “I can confirm that Conjunction has written reviews of Craig’s books on Amazon UK.”

    How do you know this?

  67. Ben-Scot NON-collaborator

    10 Apr, 2014 - 5:43 pm

    “We live in an age of deception and the only limit is the boundaries of our imaginations to understand the full scope of the evil that our rulers are capable of doing.”

    Guano;

    I’m of the opinion that any person who seeks elected office should be disqualified on that basis.

    If they want the job they must either be barmy or duplicitous; seeking the perquisites of office rather than be inspired by the notion of Pubic Service.

    We used to conscript or Shanghai people for military and maritime bizness.

    “If nominated i will not run, if elected i will not serve” would be preferable.

  68. Nearly all of H’s remarks are personal and/or insulting. Going so fast, the typos are coming as fast as Pistorius’s bullets.

    O/T Aren’t you sick of the latter’s whining voice and the blubbing. Mr Nel is having none of it. The trial being covered live on TV news channels and featuring in news bulletins. Another diversion.

  69. I can confirm that a person who named himself Conjunction wrote a glowing review of “The Catholic Orangemen of Togo and other Conflicts I Have Known” which Craig picked up on in his blog.

    http://www.amazon.co.uk/product-reviews/0956129900/ref=cm

    Why these two people are not the same I have no way of knowing. Habbabkuk was not contributing to the blog at that time, at least under the name Habbabkuk.

  70. Habbabkuk (La vita è bella) !

    10 Apr, 2014 - 6:03 pm

    Hurby

    “You say:

    “I do not believe the USD will collapse”

    What makes you think that?”
    _________________

    My sincere apologies to you, but my sources are confidential and my lips must therefore remain sealed.

    Are you buying Chinese currency, Hurby?

  71. Habbabkuk (La vita è bella) !

    10 Apr, 2014 - 6:06 pm

    Mary

    “Nearly all of H’s remarks are personal and/or insulting. Going so fast, the typos are coming as fast as Pistorius’s bullets.”
    _______________

    What a tasteless, misplaced comment, showing total disregard for his victim and her grieving parents. Please show a little compassion.

  72. “I would put it more down to ignorance rather than genuine intent.”

    Please support that opinion.

    Very difficult to support the existence of ignorance/prove a negative – I think the onus has to be on you to demonstrate that genuine intent existed.

  73. Habbabkuk (La vita è bella) !

    10 Apr, 2014 - 6:13 pm

    Hurby

    As an afterthought and to be helpful to you:

    If you get a shove on, you’d still be able to buy your Chinese currency in NY before the exchanges close, alternatively, you could wait a little until the Far East opens again. Let me know how you get on, won’t you.

  74. Habbabkuk (La vita è bella) !

    10 Apr, 2014 - 6:16 pm

    To a person naming himself John Goss:

    “I can confirm that a person who named himself Conjunction wrote a glowing review of “The Catholic Orangemen of Togo and other Conflicts I Have Known” which Craig picked up on in his blog.”

    _____________

    And that a person who named himself Conjunction also wrote a review of “Murder in Samarkand” on Amazon.

    I hope this helps the person naming himself Herbie (even though I always think of him as “Hurby”)

  75. Habbabkuk (La vita è bella) !

    10 Apr, 2014 - 6:18 pm

    Mary

    “The trial being covered live on TV news channels and featuring in news bulletins. Another diversion.”
    ______________

    I’m intrigued. Diversion from what?

  76. Is there something in the water at No. 10?

    Definite signs of religious mania setting in Agent Cameron and shades of BLiar all over again.

    David Cameron: ‘Jesus invented the Big Society – I’m just continuing God’s work’
    http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/david-cameron-claims-jesus-invented-the-big-society–he-is-just-continuing-gods-work-9250449.html

    PS How about Ave Javid or Vale Maria?

  77. Mary. Only if you read or listen to them. They are not diversions, they are distractions so that while your mind is busy engaging with them, you swallow another bit of garbage. I heard a Classic piece of BBC R4 tripe the other day in the program about interventionism: there were no UK boots on the ground in Libya.

    I have looked but I cannot find the report in the Daily Telegraph boasting defiantly that up to 1000 UK or NATO troops had been deployed covertly prior to Gaddafi’s murder. The same is obviously true today in Syria.

  78. John Goss

    So how many were killed by Stalin – you made the claim that it was less than those killed by Blair so now support it – I am interested in your sources for your claim!

  79. Habbabkuk; “But i have a pretty goos track record in these things: no World War 3 starting in Syria, former President Chavez not assassinated by injection of a lethal cancer virus, Malaysian airliner not hijacked to Diego Garcia, AS Victoria Nuland didn’t appoint the new Ukraine govt, etc, etc – the list is long!”

    LOL ! All the examples you cite are unproven &/or far too early to call; instead for a real example of foresight, remember Theresa May’s planned £3000 Surety Bond scheme for overseas visitors, that you posted many supportive comments on, well look who predicted, not once but twice, that it would never see the light of day, months before it was ditched;

    http://www.craigmurray.org.uk/archives/2013/06/pandering-to-racism/comment-page-2/#comment-415225

    http://www.craigmurray.org.uk/archives/2013/06/pandering-to-racism/comment-page-3/#comment-415767

    It was quite amusing that you were not amused when you were forced to admit that the Government were being forced to review aspects of it just days after it was announced !;

    http://www.craigmurray.org.uk/archives/2013/06/pandering-to-racism/comment-page-4/#comment-415821

    Actually the whole thread it worth revisiting, as it illustrates how you had nothing to offer when I actually decided to fully engage with you on something, and also for the fun of you getting yourself into a spin & put right by others over Cast Lead & Shannon Airport figures ! Enjoy & re-live ;

    http://www.craigmurray.org.uk/archives/2013/06/pandering-to-racism/?showmore=1

  80. Ben-Scot NON-collaborator

    10 Apr, 2014 - 6:31 pm

    “Mr Cameron faced a backlash from his own Conservative Party MPs yesterday over the way he handled Ms Miller’s resignation.”

    Just invoke the Jesus Principle and all your sins are forgiven. “Big Society” is what, Cameron’s nod to the Great Society of LBJ?

    Now if Christian qualities are truly represented, hypocrites should flee for their very lives.

  81. “Stalin was definitely a baddie, but who funded him.

    Who made it all possible”

    The natural resources of Russia extracted by slave labour and the export sales of grain stolen from the victims of the Holodomir are two sources that come to mind – but I suppose that you attribute it all to his Jewish relatives or some other anti- semitic rubbish – don’t worry Mr Goss has provided the links many times.

  82. John Goss

    Come on hurry up – don’t play your usual game of making wild assertions and then thinking they are valid because you ask someone else to prove the opposite. Your claim – you back it up or it is garbage. What is stated without evidence can be dismissed without evidence.

  83. An O/T interview with Lothar de Maiziere on the extend of US spying and what can be done to understand it fully.

    http://www.spiegel.de/international/germany/german-interior-minister-warns-us-spying-has-no-boundaries-a-963179.html

    There is also an article on the heartbleed virus, cursating for the last two years before being detected, but its in German and I can’t be arsed.
    Apparently a german wrote the code thjat could devastate two thirds of the internet and reveal vital personal data.

    http://www.spiegel.de/netzwelt/web/heartbleed-programmierer-deutscher-schrieb-den-fehlerhaften-code-a-963774.html

  84. Ben-Scot NON-collaborator

    10 Apr, 2014 - 6:41 pm

    Pinochet was a baddie as well, and we know who funded that mass-murderer.

    Of course, any who point this out are bigoted toward Chileans, and generals and mass-murderers.

  85. Habby

    “My sincere apologies to you, but my sources are confidential and my lips must therefore remain sealed.”

    I see. Clueless as ever.

    Why do you think the US is encircling Russia and China with anti-missile shields?

    You do realise that the only way out for the US and a soft landing for its dollar is that the Russians and Chinese meekly submit to a new banking order.

    You obviously think that’s very very likely.

    We’re back to blinky blinky who blinks first.

    Only difference this time is they’ve killed all the Kennedys.

    Have you any idea just how many systems accidents there have been with nukes, and that the only reason we’re still here is that Russian humans assumed an error.

    Are they really likely to still assume an error with all the first-strike tension the American teenagers are creating.

  86. “John Goss

    So how many were killed by Stalin – you made the claim that it was less than those killed by Blair so now support it – I am interested in your sources for your claim!”

    How many what? Dogs? Men? Women? Germans? Look up how many children Stalin killed yourself. Not as many as Blair I will wager.

  87. ESLO

    Are you claiming that western bankers did not support Stalin?

    Why is this such a problem for you.

    The bankers wanted rid of the Tsar because he wouldn’t join their banking system.

    Same as now.

  88. “What is stated without evidence can be dismissed without evidence.”

    I gave you two links concerning figures for Blair. You have not refuted them. You just tried to change the argument, which was about children Blair killed, not people. Stalin’s purges were against adults and those who he thought posed a threat. Of course there was the siege (Leningrad) during the war in which countless numbers died of starvation and cold. Are you counting them?

    Where are your figures?

  89. Jonangus Mackay

    10 Apr, 2014 - 7:15 pm

    OT
    ‘Yes. No. Of course’ epitomises BBC’s dire response to cumulative effects of Birtist Thatcherism. Highly recommended for devastating no-joke logo joke three-quarters of the way through: http://tinyurl.com/nh5e36o

  90. Habbabkuk (La vita è bella) !

    10 Apr, 2014 - 7:16 pm

    Macky

    Your entire post was hilarious, but what really almost made me fall off my chair was the following modest gem :

    “Actually the whole thread it worth revisiting, as it illustrates how you had nothing to offer when I actually decided to fully engage with you on something,..”

    Macky, you have never engaged with me, fully or otherwise. You have however been floored by me on several occasions.

    Whereas I have sometimes likened you to a broken-down old pug, struggling up from the canvas for yet another pasting, I think out friend Dreoilin said it better when she opined : “Macky is not the sharpest blade in the drawer”.

    In fact, more of a (wooden) spoon.

  91. Jonangus Mackay

    10 Apr, 2014 - 7:17 pm

    OT
    Outside UK, one of simplest ways of getting access to BBC iPlayer (see above) is via:

  92. “On February 25th, Iraq’s Cabinet approved a draft law lowering the age of legal marriage for females to nine years old.”

    It should be pointed ot that the word “marriage” doesn’t mean just the same thing in Muslim countries as it does in Britain. Just because two people are married it does not mean they are going to sleep together, or even live together. It’s a contract, the man agrees to support his wife/wives. In countries where there are many poor, where women are often uneducated and unable to support themselves, where parents are often unable to support their families to adulthood, it can be a good thing as well as bad.

    Thanks to Bush and Blair I expect there are many orphan young girls in Iraq right now, this law offers them a life, financial independence, rights. Many rich men would marry them as a form of charity, not to have sex with them.

  93. Jonangus Mackay

    10 Apr, 2014 - 7:20 pm

    *tries again*

    Outside UK, one of simplest ways of getting access to BBC iPlayer (see above) is via: https://www.tunnelbear.com

  94. Habbabkuk (La vita è bella) !

    10 Apr, 2014 - 7:24 pm

    “Stalin’s purges were against adults and those who he thought posed a threat.”
    __________________-

    Radio Moscow’s on the air again, I see.

    With the Kremlin balls (sorry, I meant bells) in the background.

    **********************

    “Life had become grim, life has become bloodier” (J. Stalin, ca. 1938)

  95. Your posts there Macky illustrate the point well that H’a avatar then was different to the one on these recent threads. Different location? Different IP address? Different persona altogether?

    Keep going. I can’t bothered with his continual nit picking, just like a monkey with a low pack rating who can only rise to a higher position by grooming the coats of the more dominant ones in the troupe thus providing a useful service. Or so he thinks.

    https://lucygoes.files.wordpress.com/2013/10/img_6986.jpg?w=625&h=416

  96. Nevermind

    In my mind’s eye I can see Angela Merkel pointing her right forefinger to her lips as pretty as pie, while protesting about NSA bugging of her phone.

  97. Habbabkuk (La vita è bella) !

    10 Apr, 2014 - 7:25 pm

    Fred

    That was an interesting post, thank you.

  98. “Many rich men would marry them as a form of charity, not to have sex with them.”

    Marriage is not adoption. A child cannot understand it implications. If a rich person wanted to provide for an orphan all well and good. But that can be done at a distance. The child has no need to be in the company of the benefactor. There is no excuse for marriage to a child.

  99. Habbabkuk (La vita è bella) !

    10 Apr, 2014 - 7:29 pm

    Mary

    “Your posts there Macky illustrate the point well that H’a avatar then was different to the one on these recent threads. Different location? Different IP address? Different persona altogether?”
    ________________

    Can’t get your head round the simple idea that I am, by myself, more than a match for the while bunch of you, eh?

    BTW you’re posting a lot – are you trying to hit the top of page 2?

    ****************

    La vita è bella, life is good! Exterminate nits and fleas.

  100. ESLO

    Come on hurry up.

Powered By Wordpress | Designed By Ridgey | Produced by Tim Ireland | Hosted In The Cloud